I have mixed impressions of the book. I like Syl Arena. He incorporates his hometown and his family, namely his three teenage sons, in his business and features them in the book. The book has much good information, including a few nuggets that were new to me. The book was comprehensive, specific to the Canon equipment that I currently own or hope to own in the near future, easily understandable, and Syl’s writing style is engaging.
So what is not to like? As well done as Speedliter’s Handbook is, as I read the book I’m continually finding problems with it: illustrations/photos that do not clearly demonstrate the concept being taught, text that invokes terminology that has not been defined, poor analogies, etc. I guess I have done enough writing that these kinds of things stand out to me.
I guess my biggest complaint is that his image stock seems recycled. There were few photos in the book that I haven’t already seen on his website and in the seminar videos available online. To his credit, many of these photos were taken for the purpose of demonstrating photographic techniques including step-by-step illustrations of how each photo was made. But again, the downside to this is that the reader doesn’t see any of his actual commercial work. Few of the photos look really finished. And he comes off as though he doesn’t get very much work. Maybe he doesn’t. (I doubt that.) So I am left unfulfilled by the book.