Wow. Just friggin' wow. This has to be my new record, having finished this in three days, so I think that says a lot. There was just so much to take in with this book, which was pretty overwhelming to be honest, having been very eventful, but also of course made it a particularly absorbing and exciting read.
I have to start by saying though that I was really disappointed to see how much they ruined and corrupted the character of Ben, who was a always a very nice, decent guy in the previous book 'The Little Angel", who had a very depressing fall from grace as he went from being a very nice guy and dedicated member of the Treetops family to the main antagonist of this story. He goes from being a nice, caring guy to taking advantage of his much younger stepsister (or adoptive stepsister-the family relations in this book could honestly get so confusing!), robbing Sunday of all her money and leaving her and the family financially broke, to kidnapping two children that are his but nevertheless who he is no more than a stranger to due to his long estrangement (though the latter was a result of being mentally disturbed rather than malice). He really underwent the ultimate Face-Heel turn and that was really disappointing and devastating to see, though it did also show what an incredibly complex, nuanced character he was. I mean you actually go from hating him and wanting him to get his comeuppance to feeling real concern and sympathy for him and wanting him to reconcile with Sunday and the rest of his Treetops family. That is what really disappointed me, as while I could see his fate coming as soon as he wrote a will for "just in case he didn't make it" (for why else would this be included) as well as just seeing how it would all fit in, I knew he would meet his tragic demise. However, I was hoping that before he did that he would at least get to reconcile with Sunday, but unfortunately, this never happens, with Sunday only seeing his letter of apology and giving all the money he stole off her back after he dies, having left it in his will. He really did become a tragic character and what you'd call a sympathetic villain, and despite all he's done, you really can't help but feel sympathy for him in the end, and seeing him fall so far from grace and become so corrupt was really upsetting to see, as well as how much he'd burned his bridges. His suicide scene was very upsetting too-we learn early on in the story that Maggie, who he starts a romantic relationship with at the end of The Little Angel and he is revealed to have married here, ended up dying a while back from childbirth, which was also a blow, even if her death was off-page, for she had already suffered so much and had been hoping she would get a nice new start to life, only to end up tragically dying. It turns out that this is what started Ben's mental downfall, having been heartbroken over losing her and their child, with everything having gone downhill for him since then. He only seeks solace in joining her when he finally decides to end things towards the end, feeling he has nobody or nothing left in his life, having burned his bridges the way he did. A redemption arc would have therefore been complicated, but nevertheless, I wish just even one scene of him and Sunday reconciling could have happened. I'm glad anyway that she accepted him back into the family after learning of his death by having him buried next to Tom.
That's another thing-Tom literally only appears for one second in this story at the very beginning, and it is his tragic death that kicks everything off. This story is definitely what you'd call coming full circle by the end of it, and is by far the most tragic and heartbreaking, having found myself very emotionally overwhelmed and in total emotional whirlwhind. The first book started with Sunday's birth, and this final book ends with her death, which only happens on the very last page, and it really is incredibly heartbreaking and upsetting. While only the first, second and this final book were the only ones of the series to heavily feature Sunday and the Treetops gang as a prominent character, they have still I think essentially covered the life story of Sunday herself, for you go from seeing her early adventures and experience of adversity in the workhouse, depicting her whole journey, from being raised in the workhouse to raising her own family at Treetops. I had a strong feeling the story was going to end with Sunday's demise as I was just sure that the title 'Time to Say Goodbye' meant more than just saying goodbye to Treetops-there was clearly a very heavy meaning to that, knowing it was the end of the series. There were also subtle hints about Sunday's fate throughout the book, that only get less and less subtle.
Like in The Little Angel, there is a war going on throughout most of the story, as we see how it tragically affects many of the characters in some way or another, only this time it is World War II and you see just how much worse it actually is, and longer lasting of course. There are actually so many deaths in this book, too many, which you might expect because it is set during World War II, but most of them aren't even as a result of the war. Goodwin decides to take her most ruthless approach yet as she ends up killing off most of the main cast by the end of the story. The most sudden and unexpected one though was Kathy's death, whose death was far too sudden as she just ends up getting ran over and it doesn't even fit in with anything, like it was pretty unnecessary as it didn't even really add a lot, mainly just to act as the last straw for Sunday realising she has no need for life anymore, but I still don't think this was necessary for that. It was pretty cruel to just suddenly kill off a main character like that, and after everything seemed to finally be going happily for her as well, and it was all just too rushed. Couldn't she have killed any of the more minor, supporting characters instead, like George, Cissie's husband, who while is a nice guy is really just that of a supporting character and doesn't actually do a lot. But no, it's the major characters that we get to know the most and become most attached to that are killed off, including John, who was perhaps the kindest character in the book, and the fact him and Sunday never get together, as you kept expecting Sunday to change her mind and accept his proposal, but no, he dies, again despite how happily things had been going, and Sunday follows him about a year later.
It was interesting actually at the beginning, as I actually thought that Ben was supposed to be Kathy's main love interest and that the 'wrong man' she falls for would be the doctor guy, David, or someone else, but it ends up being the total other way round of course. Poor Ben, he died with nobody, they couldn't have at least given him a bit of happiness in the end, for what he did was no doubt despicable but he was clearly very troubled and had once been a loving member of the family. It was so sad remembering all the loving memories of him with the Treetops family then seeing him turn against them and take such a face-heel turn, going corrupt and becoming the main antagonist. I just wish his end had been a little less tragic and had a little more closure. Ugh why couldn't you have kept him as the nice, good, lovely guy we all remember from The Little Angel?!
It was incredibly gripping, seeing all the events taking place and how World War II affects everyone, highlighting the real history of it all. I really found myself absorbed, reading about the tragic events of World War II as well as everything that was going on with the Branning family. The ending could be seen as bittersweet, but overall I think it was a very dark and tragic story with all the deaths of such major characters and of course the corruption and tragic end of a previously good and nice character. It makes you realise just how long it's been since the beginning of the series when we see the start of Sunday's adventures when she's merely a teenager, taking place a good 50-60 years after then. I was surprised to see Verity and Edgar still alive, as Lavinia, Sunday's mother had been stated to die of old age before the start of the story, and they were about the same age as her. It was possible of course, though what was kind of weird was that it was ambiguous whether they were still alive by the end or not, as I don't think they were mentioned amongst the guests at the party they had nearer the end. I'd be surprised if they outlived Sunday though. What was kind of disappointing as well was to see that there was no mention of most of the characters from the first book, like Mrs Spooner and Daisy, and even the bad ones like Miss Frost and Mr Pinnegar, as while two of them had died in the first book and the other two obviously would have been long dead by now, it would have been a nice little bit of nostalgia to look back to the very beginning of it all. Daisy is mentioned in the narration, with one of Kathy's children being named after her, but not in dialogue, and Sunday's harsh beginnings in the workhouse is mentioned but only briefly and vaguely. It just would have been a nice little nostalgic throwback to be honest. It also would have been interesting to know what happened to Kathy's dad, who was seemingly Richard from The Little Angel, as we never really had any closure on that.
Flora and Jamie from A Maiden's Voyage are mentioned a few times, but don't actually make an official appearance with actual dialogue. I was never quite sure that it was a good idea shoehorning them into the Treetops/Sunday saga, as A Maiden's Voyage felt like a whole different story in its own right, and there was enough going on with Sunday as it was.
Overall was a remarkable and particularly emotional read-definitely not recommended for if you are looking for a light and fluffy read at all. It was very upsetting, heartbreaking and tragic-especially by the end, and definitely the most emotional of finales I have come across. I'd say that you have to have read the first and second book in the series before reading this one, otherwise you might have trouble understanding and connecting to the characters and everything going on.