1) Genre: Poetry
2) This is a compilation of various poems related to school situations.
3) Critique:
a) Honestly, this was one of the worst collections of poems I think I have ever encountered. I really wish I had listened to the title of the book, “Don’t Read This Book, Whatever you Do!” I have always felt that any book, regardless of the genre, has something positive about it and it should simply be appreciated because it is a work of literature. Consequently, I feel that some of the poems have catchy lines and interesting topics; however, the content of the majority of the poems are simply dull and at times rather sad for younger elementary students.
b) I’ll start with the positive. Interesting topics include friendship
(“Best Friends, p. 9) and a discussion amongst the items left in a lost and found box (“Voices from the Lost and Found”, p. 18). Not so interesting or sad topics include a fourth grader making fun that he hasn’t raised his hand since second grade (“A Fourth Grader’s Secret”, p. 27), a child pleading that the teacher/parent will still love him if he fails (“Don’t Tell Me”, p. 36), and a random poem about a child talking about her family killed in a war. (“Not Anymore”, p. 53)
c) Since it is obvious why the interesting poems would actually be interesting to students, I will focus more on the examples of poems I questioned. In “A Fourth Grader’s Secret”, I really felt like the poem was finding humor in the fact that he hasn’t raised his hand to answer a question since second grade. The accompany illustration portrays the young boy smiling as if he is content with this. Maybe it’s just the teacher in me, but I felt including this poem kind of encouraged non-participation in the classrooms, as if it’s okay to not participate in class because clearly the boy made it out of second grade. The first time I read “Don’t Tell Me”, I immediately thought of an abused child who is pleading with his/her teacher/parent to not stop loving them if they make a mistake, “Just tell me you’ll still love me, even if I do.” And to add to the randomness of the poems, “Not Anymore” is about a class asking a new student if he has any brothers and sisters, “He sighed so long we thought he would never breathe again. Then in a rush of words, like water going over the falls, he said, I used to but not anymore because they were killed in a war.” This is a poem included towards the end of the book, so by this point I was used to the random and sometimes awkward poems, but I felt like this was a bit much. The title of this book, “Don’t Read This Book, Whatever You Do!” seems a bit mysterious and fun and even has a very cheerful illustration along with it. Therefore, I was a bit confused on why these poems were just so…blah.
4) Curriculum Connection: I wouldn’t recommend creating any lesson in relation to this book; however, if I absolutely had to use it, I suppose I would pick one of the few interesting poems and use it as a model for my class. My students could use this to understand the structure of a poem and various rhyme schemes.