I received a free copy of this book in return for my honest opinion.
This is the third book of a series and I didn’t read the first two, so I had to take this into account when reviewing it. Nevertheless, I had several problems with it that had nothing to do with knowing what happened before. The book is a bit of a crazy jumble of a story, that begins badly and ends well, but getting to that ending is not a pleasant journey.
The first quarter of the book follows Yon, a 1000-year old alien with telepathic powers but the physical appearance of a teenage boy, who lands on Earth in the early 1940’s. This whole section rushes over a period of about seventy years, with only brief mentions of the things he sees or lives through in this strange new world. He is adopted by a British farmer, he grows up and moves to the U.S., goes to college, marries, has children, gets a job: all of this is described in general and very undramatic terms. For example, we are told (in all of one sentence) that his two children have deformities due to his weak genes, without being told what this weakness is, or what the deformities are, or how their mother feels about them, or what he does with them, etc. The story simply moves on to another stage in his life, as if none of this mattered. Characters popped in and out of the story with no warning and scenes had little connection with each other. At another point Yon stated that he want to study a reported alien landing in Roswell, New Mexico; but this was never mentioned again, which made me wonder why it was mentioned in the first place. There’s quite a bit of that, so it didn’t feel like I was reading an evolving story; more like ideas were being thrown onto the page in a haphazard fashion to stretch it out to book length.
It was around the quarter point of the book that the eponymous Cloud brothers showed up and the story then centered more on them and their dealings with various aliens, both friendly and unfriendly. (Several other characters with telepathic powers were introduced about here; these powers were used in often dramatic ways, but mostly in the last third or so of the book.)
As I read on I realized that the whole first section about Yon was merely an introduction to the main story about the battle against aliens that were colonizing the galaxy. Still, that didn’t make reading about Yon any more entertaining, as the story of his life was told with the depth and drama of a Wikipedia entry.
Once the Cloud brothers arrived on the scene, the author still had a tendency to explain what should have been dramatic situations in one or two throwaway lines. For example, we learn that another alien race called the Mantis, attempted to attack Earth but the Cloud brothers defeated them, saving the planet. The whole matter was told in less than two pages, with very little detail about how any of this was done. (Was it something which happened in an earlier book? I have no idea, but I’d like the book I’m reading to entertain me, not the book I haven’t read.)
This lack of detail about things that happened was a recurring problem in the story. Whether it was the battle against the Mantis (who come back later and try again), or dealing with a rare medical issue, or commandeering a space vessel: a quick comment along the lines of “I used my mental powers to disable the bomb” pretty much solves most problems, so that scenes that could have been tense or exciting are instead very ho-hum. As with much of the story, events occur with the most superficial of explanations, and characters act on the weakest of motivations.
It was only in the final third or so of the book that there were any scenes where the conflicts were described with any sense of the dramatic. A group of humans become marooned on the faraway Planet X. While they argued about whether they should return to Earth or not, the Mantis showed up again to threaten the entire human race with annihilation. The fate of humanity rested with this divided group on Planet X, which included the Clouds and Yon, as well as a couple of other aliens with their own abilities.
These are the only scenes in the book that didn’t feel rushed through, where conflicting loyalties were explored, and human ingenuity was tested against alien mind-control powers. There was still a tendency to solve some situations with eye-rolling ease, but there was also more in the way of ratcheting up the tension, and allowing scenes to unfold more fully, rather than wrapping things up too quickly and neatly. I was pleasantly surprised to enjoy watching Yon, the humans and the Mantis try to outsmart each other.
Reading these final chapters I couldn’t help but wonder if the author was in such a hurry to get to this part that he gave little thought to the earlier two-thirds of the story. With very little effort he could excise most of the book and be left with a compelling little novella, which would have been much more pleasurable to read. Had my review been limited to everything which happened after the group landed on Planet X I would probably have added a couple of stars to it. But, considering the book as a whole, and viewing it as a stand-alone book, a two-star rating was the most I could give it.