Tess Thompson, thank you so much for this uplifting book, When Stars Rise at Midnight, Part Two of The Midnight Stars Saga Book. When we last saw Estelle and Percy I had used up a box of tissues and not for happy tears. Estelle’s outlook on the future says it all: “Pining for a man married to another was an endless ache, a combination of guilt, self-hatred, and longing that threatened to smother me each and every day. Regardless, Percival and I had agreed that we could not act on our feelings. To do so would hurt too many people. Worse, it would be a betrayal of his marriage vows, taken before God. Neither of us could be that selfish, even though I wished more than anything he could be by my side.” Heart-wrenchingly hopeless. Estelle wouldn’t have to be reduced to a life of shame, they would still see each other and be friends, but within the iron boundaries of society. I wanted to rail against the horribly cruel and restrictive rules, how just the tiniest hint of impropriety – whether justified or not – could ruin a person, especially a woman and I thought: this is the Twentieth Century, not the Regency Era. It’s the 1920s, the Roaring Twenties, for heaven’s sake, but it doesn’t matter. The rules of the upper crust in New York City are unbendable, at least in the public eye. What goes on behind closed door is another story, but Estelle and Percy have strong moral codes and will not give in, do not give in, even behind those closed doors. It’s pure and it’s admirable, but as the reader you just want them to be happy, want for their hurting to stop, see how they are truly meant for each other and wish for that to somehow be possible. For Estelle, Percy, Clara and Mrs. Bradford to be the happy, content family they deserve to be.
We already met most of the players in the first book, and most of them are still as deplorable as ever. Estelle’s mother shut out Estelle and her twin sister Mauve after the death of their little brother. She preferred Mauve, never stood up for Estelle, was never a comforting mother, never on her side, even when Estelle was banished as if she were dead. Grief over her lost son might account for some of that, but Estelle feels her own similar grief. And even if she was unaware of Estelle’s father’s true business and didn’t necessarily actively take his side, tacit withdrawal was enough. She was not the mother Estelle needed. Until maybe she was
Estelle’s father has always been demanding, cruel, unyielding, and she’s only recently discovered he’s a murdering mobster, with the death of Estelle’s fiancé on his hands and a connection to Percy’s wife’s family that seems to destroy any chance they have at even a friendship.
What more tragedy could possibly befall Estelle? Read on and you’ll find out.
Percy’s wife Mary is mentally ill, violent and dangerous and had to be confined to an asylum several years ago. Percy is a man, with all a man’s needs and wants, desires and jealousies but with a sense of honor and a determination to not be the cruel and uncaring man his father was that overrides all those other emotions. He is a married man; he meant his vows when he took them and he intends to keep them, even if there is no chance his wife’s condition will improve, even if it means he has no chance for future happiness. He will not be like his father. But Mary’s brother Simon is not content with that, particularly after the connection between his and Estelle’s families becomes known. He causes Estelle to leave the Bradford house and does not approve of Percy providing an apartment for her, even if they truly are just friends. He suspects her motives and wants to destroy her and her family.
When Stars Rise at Midnight is nerve-wracking. The tension rises and the suspense and fear wind tighter and tighter. Mysterious people show up seemingly around every corner, threats and attacks are made, everyone is on edge and afraid, deaths occur. Even more secrets are revealed. Can there ever be even a small amount of happiness for Estelle and Percy and his family, or will they even survive? Author Thompson as always does a masterful job of balancing the sweet and romantic and charming with the crude and ruthless and dangerous. You cannot turn the pages fast enough; you think you know who is responsible. You’re wrong, and you think you know who’s responsible again. A thriller, a romance, a tale of those times and of what people will do to survive. Engrossing and completely satisfying.
Thanks to author Tess Thompson for providing an advance copy of When Stars Rise at Midnight, the second book in the Midnight Stars Saga as part of her review crew. I thoroughly enjoyed it as I do all of Thompson’s books, recommend it without hesitation, and am grateful that this time the smiles outnumbered the tears. I voluntarily leave this review; all opinions are my own.