Claimed by the Elven Brothers: Decision is a light novella that feels more like a prologue than a full story when compared to its sequel, Fate which is set 50 years later, but it introduces an intriguing premise that may appeal to fans of low-stakes fantasy romance. The plot centers on Megan, a human woman suddenly drawn into the world of Elven politics and ancient customs when she meets two Elven brothers, Locien and Seren who both want her as their bride.
The dynamic between the brothers is one of the story’s stronger elements. Seren comes across as the gentler, more emotionally attuned of the two, while Locien feels possessive, bordering on selfish at times. There’s clear potential for interesting tension between them, but the story only scratches the surface. As for Megan, she’s written as quiet and submissive, and while that may appeal to some readers, I found myself wishing for more agency or inner conflict from her, especially given the life-altering decision she's being asked to make.
Romantically, the story teases more than it delivers. The sensual elements are present but restrained, more about suggestion than intimacy. There’s also a touch of mystery, with a third, unseen Elf influencing Megan's thoughts in ways that aren’t fully explained, adding an eerie undercurrent that gives the story a bit more texture.
That said, the novella leans heavily on exposition, with the story favoring telling over immersive scenes. Emotional beats are often told rather than felt, which makes the story feel a bit rushed despite its slow pace. Still, for a quick, accessible read with a unique setup and a hint of otherworldly intrigue, it may satisfy readers looking for a fantasy romance that doesn’t demand too much investment.
Just don’t go in expecting a complete arc, this is very much a story that feels like it’s just setting up for its sequel, Fate.