What do you think?
Rate this book
Os Grandes Casos de Psicose (Coleção Transmissão da Psicanálise)
Este livro reúne, pela primeira vez, comentários sobre os mais célebres casos de psicose que os grandes mestres da psicanálise nos legaram: o caso Schreber de Freud, o caso Dominique de Dolto, o caso das irmãs Papin de Lacan e outros. Cada capítulo, consagrado a um caso, compreende:
• a vida do paciente, seus sintomas e o desenrolar da análise;
• a importância do caso para a teoria psicanalítica;
• uma seleta bibliográfica sobre o caso.
Mestre na explanação de conceitos psicanalíticos complexos, inclusive para não especialistas, o psiquiatra e psicanalista J.-D. Nasio é autor de outros dez títulos publicados por esta editora, dentre eles: Cinco lições sobre a teoria de Jacques Lacan; Introdução às obras de Freud, Ferenczi, Groddeck, Klein, Winnicott, Dolto, Lacan; Lições sobre os 7 conceitos cruciais da psicanálise; O livro da dor e do amor e O prazer de ler Freud.
• a vida do paciente, seus sintomas e o desenrolar da análise;
• a importância do caso para a teoria psicanalítica;
• uma seleta bibliográfica sobre o caso.
Mestre na explanação de conceitos psicanalíticos complexos, inclusive para não especialistas, o psiquiatra e psicanalista J.-D. Nasio é autor de outros dez títulos publicados por esta editora, dentre eles: Cinco lições sobre a teoria de Jacques Lacan; Introdução às obras de Freud, Ferenczi, Groddeck, Klein, Winnicott, Dolto, Lacan; Lições sobre os 7 conceitos cruciais da psicanálise; O livro da dor e do amor e O prazer de ler Freud.
- GenresPsychologyPsychoanalysis
273 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2000
16 people are currently reading
140 people want to read
About the author
Juan-David Nasio
60 books57 followersJuan-David Nasio (or J.-D. Nasio) is a psychoanalyst in Paris and former member of the Ecole Freudienne of Jacques Lacan.
Nasio was born in Rosario, Santa Fe, Argentina. After qualifying as a doctor Nasio completed his residency as a psychiatrist at the hospital in Lanús. He emigrated to France in 1969 where he worked with Jacques Lacan. He was a professor at the University of Paris VII Sorbonne for 30 years from 1971 and is considered one of the foremost commentators on Lacanian psychoanalysis. He was the first psychoanalyst to be inducted into the prestigious French Legion of Honor. In addition to participating in Lacan's seminars and translating his Écrits into Spanish, he has authored numerous books in French and Spanish, and he is the director of the Seminaires Psychanalytiques de Paris, a major center for psychoanalytical training and the dissemination of psychoanalytical thought to nonspecialists.
Nasio was born in Rosario, Santa Fe, Argentina. After qualifying as a doctor Nasio completed his residency as a psychiatrist at the hospital in Lanús. He emigrated to France in 1969 where he worked with Jacques Lacan. He was a professor at the University of Paris VII Sorbonne for 30 years from 1971 and is considered one of the foremost commentators on Lacanian psychoanalysis. He was the first psychoanalyst to be inducted into the prestigious French Legion of Honor. In addition to participating in Lacan's seminars and translating his Écrits into Spanish, he has authored numerous books in French and Spanish, and he is the director of the Seminaires Psychanalytiques de Paris, a major center for psychoanalytical training and the dissemination of psychoanalytical thought to nonspecialists.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews
October 13, 2017
Proud of his prolific writing [at least 25 books have been published] Nasio said once (in Spanish) in an interview, as justification for his talent and work: “I am obedient to my super ego” ["…obediente a mi superego”].
A disciple of J. Lacan, Juan David Nasio, is a psychiatrist and psychoanalyst established in Paris.
From the very beginning of the book, Nasio questions the word “clinical case” and seems to give it a new meaning. A case is “an account” made “by a clinician”. Nasio finds dialectical, heuristic and metaphoric functions in this account. He ventures on saying: “my observations of the patients can be read as novels”. He’s right, in a sense, because all clinical accounts are always “reconstructions”.
The book approaches several cases which eminent psychologists, psychiatrists or psychoanalysts have dealt with. Here’s the list of cases, with a short description (but the first case) of the problem and the professional involved.
1-President Schreber (of the Dresden Senate); a case of paranoia and narcissism ; by S. Freud (*).
Freud got to know about the case via books (namely: Memories of my nervous illness) . The German president (a judge and doctor in law) was hospitalized for hypochondria at the age of 42; had an attempt of suicide; had ideas such as: God had engendered a plot against the president: of turning him into a woman; little men had been torturing him, vermin getting into his lungs, intestines removed, his stature reduced. Bleuler said of this case: a paranoid schizophrenia. Schreber developed a kind of mysticism over time.
2-Dick: a case of autism; by Melanie Klein.
3-Little Piggle, a case of an “unstructured child”; at stake the “mother concept” too; by D. Winnicott. (**)
4-Joey; a case of autism; by B. Bettelheim (***).
5-“Mirror’s girl”; a case of schizophrenia; by F. Dolto (****).
6-Dominique; a case of a psychotic teen; by F. Dolto.
7-The Papin sisters; a case of “acting out” and paranoia; by J. Lacan.
For those inquiring on “psychosis”, Nasio offers early on the Freudian view: psychotic manifestations occur (delirium or hallucinations…) due to a “struggle of the ego to defend itself from unbearable pain”; it’s a “self-preservation fight”.
Lacan said about the phenomena: a psychotic patient is a “martyr of the unconscious”.
A good work.
Of course, one of the possible approaches to psychosis.
There are other ones.
(*)
http://www.metro.inter.edu/facultad/e...
(**)
http://icpla.edu/wp-content/uploads/2...
(***)
http://www.weber.edu/wsuimages/psycho...
(****)
http://www.journal-psychoanalysis.eu/...
UPDATE on the Papin sisters:
'They looked like such good girls': the mystery of Genet's murderous Maids"
in: http://www.theguardian.com/stage/2016...
A disciple of J. Lacan, Juan David Nasio, is a psychiatrist and psychoanalyst established in Paris.
From the very beginning of the book, Nasio questions the word “clinical case” and seems to give it a new meaning. A case is “an account” made “by a clinician”. Nasio finds dialectical, heuristic and metaphoric functions in this account. He ventures on saying: “my observations of the patients can be read as novels”. He’s right, in a sense, because all clinical accounts are always “reconstructions”.
The book approaches several cases which eminent psychologists, psychiatrists or psychoanalysts have dealt with. Here’s the list of cases, with a short description (but the first case) of the problem and the professional involved.
1-President Schreber (of the Dresden Senate); a case of paranoia and narcissism ; by S. Freud (*).
Freud got to know about the case via books (namely: Memories of my nervous illness) . The German president (a judge and doctor in law) was hospitalized for hypochondria at the age of 42; had an attempt of suicide; had ideas such as: God had engendered a plot against the president: of turning him into a woman; little men had been torturing him, vermin getting into his lungs, intestines removed, his stature reduced. Bleuler said of this case: a paranoid schizophrenia. Schreber developed a kind of mysticism over time.
2-Dick: a case of autism; by Melanie Klein.
3-Little Piggle, a case of an “unstructured child”; at stake the “mother concept” too; by D. Winnicott. (**)
4-Joey; a case of autism; by B. Bettelheim (***).
5-“Mirror’s girl”; a case of schizophrenia; by F. Dolto (****).
6-Dominique; a case of a psychotic teen; by F. Dolto.
7-The Papin sisters; a case of “acting out” and paranoia; by J. Lacan.
For those inquiring on “psychosis”, Nasio offers early on the Freudian view: psychotic manifestations occur (delirium or hallucinations…) due to a “struggle of the ego to defend itself from unbearable pain”; it’s a “self-preservation fight”.
Lacan said about the phenomena: a psychotic patient is a “martyr of the unconscious”.
A good work.
Of course, one of the possible approaches to psychosis.
There are other ones.
(*)
http://www.metro.inter.edu/facultad/e...
(**)
http://icpla.edu/wp-content/uploads/2...
(***)
http://www.weber.edu/wsuimages/psycho...
(****)
http://www.journal-psychoanalysis.eu/...
UPDATE on the Papin sisters:
'They looked like such good girls': the mystery of Genet's murderous Maids"
in: http://www.theguardian.com/stage/2016...
April 20, 2024
Una gran introducción a la psicosis desde diferentes corrientes del psicoanálisis
March 15, 2025
"Os grandes casos de psicose" consegue a proeza de reunir um material rico e prático ao mesmo tempo. O livro possui uma fluidez que ainda não tinha visto com o Nasio. O desenvolvimento dos casos clínicos seguem um "roteiro" capaz de alinhar a história desses pacientes, os pontos pertinentes da teoria de cada autor e a análise propriamente dita do que é relatado, demonstrando como a psicanálise consegue mostrar uma outra via de tratamento para sujeitos por vezes "destinados" a "cuidados" focados em controlar ou modificar seus comportamentos, deixando de lado a singularidade do sofrimento de cada um. Como dito no preâmbulo: "Independentemente da época e do lugar, jamais deixaremos de nos surpreender, a exemplo dos que nos antecederam, com o mistério da loucura e com o poder insuspeitado de uma escuta analítica capaz de aliviar o sofrimento do paciente psicótico."
Fiquei particularmente interessado (em alguns casos, enternecido) pelos casos do Dick, da "pequena Piggle", do Joey e, obviamente, das irmãs Papin. Na verdade, o livro me instigou a voltar o olhar para a clínica infantil, algo que me fugia. Acredito que ele seja uma excelente opção para introdução à clínica da psicose.
Fiquei particularmente interessado (em alguns casos, enternecido) pelos casos do Dick, da "pequena Piggle", do Joey e, obviamente, das irmãs Papin. Na verdade, o livro me instigou a voltar o olhar para a clínica infantil, algo que me fugia. Acredito que ele seja uma excelente opção para introdução à clínica da psicose.
August 15, 2020
Un libro bastante interesante que exige tener cierto conocimiento de la materia para poder entender algunos conceptos. Creo que es un libro que gana más si ya has leído los casos completos, los resumen es que presentan están bien, pero si quieres tener una mayor visión crítica de los casos, mejor leerlos aparte y después leer este libro.
August 23, 2013
Siempre le he tenido su reserva a las psicosis. Esa aparente incoherencia me las vuelve particularmente inaccesibles. Sin embargo, recientemente me he sentido atraído a estudiarlas, y este libro me pareció un buen punto de arranque, por alguna revisión fragmentaria que ya había hecho del mismo.
Me parece muy buena opción poder elaborar estas breves síntesis de algunos casos de importancia teórica e histórica, y articularlos con las nociones y los conceptos que derivaron de su estudio (y no, como puede creerse, a los que sirven de ilustración). Además de reencontrarme a unos viejos conocidos, Joey y las hermanas Papin, me encantaron los demás casos, por una parte me llamó mucho la atención que en su mayoría son de niños, y esto me llevó, por otra, a comprender algo más acerca del carácter constitutivo de la psicosis para cualquier estructuración psíquica.
Añadido a los casos, me parece muy ilustrativo el primer punto, donde se aclara precisamente la noción de caso. Y el último, sobre el concepto de forclusión local, es interesante pero creo que le puedo sacar más jugo en otro momento.
Tenía tantas ganas de entrarle a la lectura de este libro, acrecentadas por no estar disponible en la biblioteca, que cuando por fin pude acceder a él, hasta olvidé renovar el préstamo y terminé pagando una buena multa. Pero eso ya será para elaborar sobre mi propio caso.
Me parece muy buena opción poder elaborar estas breves síntesis de algunos casos de importancia teórica e histórica, y articularlos con las nociones y los conceptos que derivaron de su estudio (y no, como puede creerse, a los que sirven de ilustración). Además de reencontrarme a unos viejos conocidos, Joey y las hermanas Papin, me encantaron los demás casos, por una parte me llamó mucho la atención que en su mayoría son de niños, y esto me llevó, por otra, a comprender algo más acerca del carácter constitutivo de la psicosis para cualquier estructuración psíquica.
Añadido a los casos, me parece muy ilustrativo el primer punto, donde se aclara precisamente la noción de caso. Y el último, sobre el concepto de forclusión local, es interesante pero creo que le puedo sacar más jugo en otro momento.
Tenía tantas ganas de entrarle a la lectura de este libro, acrecentadas por no estar disponible en la biblioteca, que cuando por fin pude acceder a él, hasta olvidé renovar el préstamo y terminé pagando una buena multa. Pero eso ya será para elaborar sobre mi propio caso.
November 27, 2016
Learning psychologic through the review of psycotic cases that helped define the psychoanalysts theories that 'cured' or explained the patients is the offer this book has for the reader.
I found specially interesting the focus on the forclusion phenomenon. If i have to make a tease about the concept i would say is an explanation of a containted form of psycosis, a smaller version that only affects a 'local' area of the patients psyque and expresses itself as a temporary sickness of the mind.
I wonder how far i can take this concept to explain even smaller but less impressive forms of psycotic behaviors.
I found specially interesting the focus on the forclusion phenomenon. If i have to make a tease about the concept i would say is an explanation of a containted form of psycosis, a smaller version that only affects a 'local' area of the patients psyque and expresses itself as a temporary sickness of the mind.
I wonder how far i can take this concept to explain even smaller but less impressive forms of psycotic behaviors.
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews