Going into this, I’ll be honest: I’m not usually a pregnancy-trope reader. It’s hit or miss for me. But Hooked on Them actually surprised me, in a good way.
Nora is a female NHL coach who finds herself at the center of a scandal after a risqué night at a charity networking event. One night turns into life-changing consequences, and suddenly she’s navigating pregnancy, public scrutiny, and complicated relationships with three very different men: Dominic (a player on her team), Carter (the charming outsider who steps up without hesitation), and Miles (Dominic’s best friend with a quiet, lingering admiration for Nora).
What really worked for me was how the pregnancy was handled. There wasn’t excessive time-skipping or glossing over the hard parts. It’s present throughout the story, and the characters actually confront real thoughts, fears, and emotional weight that come with it. The pacing overall felt solid, and I appreciated knowing what I was signing up for right from the synopsis.
That said, this was a solid four stars for me, not quite a five because while there were definite five-star moments, there were also some three-star ones. Nothing ever dropped below that, but the balance evened out.
My biggest hang-up? The number of love interests.
I truly believe Nora was meant to be with Carter. He felt genuine, emotionally present, and deeply invested in her. Not just the situations they find themselves in, but her. I would’ve been perfectly happy with a story centered on Nora, Carter, and Dominic, where Dominic struggles with commitment and Carter becomes the steady contrast. Honestly, a standalone romance with just Nora and Carter? I’d eat that up.
Dominic did grow on me over time. He starts off unreliable and frustrating, and there were moments where I wished he wasn’t involved in the “who’s the father” situation at all—but his character development added real depth, and by the end, I understood his place in the story.
Miles, though… that’s where I struggled.
I actually like Miles as a character. He’s solid, thoughtful, and caring, but I don’t think he needed to be a romantic lead. His involvement felt unnecessary and a bit forced. He could have easily remained a supportive presence: a friend to Dominic, an ally to Nora, someone level-headed who helps them navigate the chaos. Instead, his romantic inclusion felt confusing, especially when even Nora and Dominic seemed baffled by the solution he proposed to insert himself into the relationship. It just didn’t click for me.
Despite that, there’s a lot to love here. The spice hits when it needs to, the character growth is strong, and Nora herself is such a highlight—witty, capable, and resilient. The story is engaging from the start and definitely scratches that cozy-but-dramatic hockey romance itch, especially for winter reading.
While this works as a standalone, there are connections to previous books in the series. A few moments had me wondering who certain side characters were, but nothing that pulled me out of the story entirely.
Overall, Hooked on Them is fun, emotional, indulgent, and easy to get swept up in. Is it realistic? Not really. Is it something you can absolutely fantasize yourself into? 100%.
A strong four stars from me and I’ll definitely keep reading Maya Nicole.