The Bachelor

Plain City Peace #2

by Stephanie Reed

In this sequel to The Bargain, Betsie Troyer is back home in her Amish community where she knows she belongs, free from the confusing Englisher way of life. She and Charley Yoder have made promises to each other, and her life is back on track--until Gerald Sullivan shows up with his young daughter, asking for Betsie's help. He’s on his way to find his estranged wife, and begs Betsie to take young Sheila in. When she agrees, Betsie's carefully planned life is shaken up again. Sheila's newfound faith is troubling to Charley--and his attraction to another girl is beginning to be a problem. But how can Betsie confront him when she is still trying to confront her own feelings about Sheila's brother, Michael? Keeping the peace between the Amish man she's always loved, a twelve-year-old Englisher girl, and a draft-dodging hippie is more than she ever thought she’d have to deal with in her simple, orderly life. Still, Betsie is convinced she can keep things from falling apart completely. Then during her best friend's wedding, tragedy strikes and her world is upended. She has to make a decision: does she love Charley or Michael . . . or is she craving a deeper love that only God can give? The compelling second novel of the Plain City Peace series, The Bachelor deftly weaves together the strands of a solid, simpler time with the turmoil of an era of change, revealing the strengths of both in its powerful narrative.

Genres: Amish, Christian Fiction, Fiction, Contemporary

256 pages, Paperback

First published October 1, 2014

About the author

Stephanie Reed lives on the outskirts of Plain City, Ohio, site of a once-thriving Amish community. She gleans ideas for her novels from signs glimpsed along the byways of Ohio, as she did for her previous books The Bargain, Across the Wide River, and The Light Across the River.

Reviews

[Kathleen (Kat) Smith · Rating 5 out of 5]

I almost thought I had missed out on the opportunity as a book reviewer to review Stephanie Reed's latest novel The Bachelor, the second in the Plain City Peace Series. You don't know how happy I was when I realized that Kregel Publications had extended the invitation to do so even though many others had read it way before I did. There is joy in the small things like this.

I feel in love with the character of Betsie Troyer from the first novel and if you're like me, you often times, have to wait quite a bit to get the next novel in any series. However, I knew right away, I wanted to see right where Stephanie was going to pick her up story since Betsie's parents along with her Aunt Lovina had moved away from the Amish community to settle far away so they could practice their new found faith in the Jesus of the Bible as well as learning more about salvation. In an Amish community if you left, your salvation was doomed for all eternity. This is the reason so many Amish remain and become baptized in their Amish faith to ensure that through their good works and obedience they might get to heaven, but they had no way of knowing for sure.

Betsie was left behind on the family farm trying to do her very best along with his younger sister Sadie to make ends meet until she believed one day her parents would return home. Until that time, the Amish had a firm rule of shunning that prevented them from associating with them until they made a kneeling confession in front of the church. Betsie held on to her belief, her parents would be coming home. That didn't stop Charlie Yoder, from pressing the issue with Betsie that they would be married soon, having children, and take over running the Troyer farm. Betsie was more than surprised with Charlie's way of dismissing her faith that her parents would be home soon and they would be running the farm again. It is clear that Charlie has a firm way of holding on to the old Amish way of running things especially having his mother Mattie supporting them since his father had died.

But is Charlie really the bachelor for her or perhaps is her heart bringing her back to Michael, an English man who saved her life from what could have been a brutal attack. Now that Michael is living on the Farm to avoid having to serve in the Vietnam war, she wonders just what their relationship might have been like if Michael were Amish instead of English. In order to keep her mind busy, Betsie has been asked to take care of Michael's little sister Shelia while his father has left to try and reconcile with his distraught wife who has run off. It is the faith of a small child that will lead Betsie to the truth of salvation in a way she never imagined.

I received The Bachelor by Stephanie Reed compliments of Kregel Publications for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation for a favorable review and the opinions expressed here are strictly my own. I absolutely LOVED this novel but once again must way until 2016 to get the third novel in the series, The Bride. This is such a moving novel to conveys hope for our eternal salvation in heaven through the simple faith of becoming like a child again. It is that simple faith of simply accepting things at face value rather than trying to figure them out that makes this one a winner in my opinion and well worth 5 out of 5 stars. The only downside is the wait between the novels, but all great things come to those who wait! There are Book Club Discussion Questions included at the conclusion of this novel as well!

[Brenda · Rating 5 out of 5]

Nineteen year old Betsie Troyer is glad to be back in her Amish community, but she knows that her family is on shaky ground because her parents Fannie and Noah left the faith in order to become Christians. Her aunt Lovina tried convincing them to come back but instead she left the faith as well. Betsie has plans to marry Chaley Yoder and become a good Amish wife. When she is ask to keep her Englisher's twelve year old daughter Sheila,she knows she shouldn't but does it anyway. Added to that is the fact that she is pretty close friends with Sheila's brother and things just seem to keep getting more complicated.

I read quite a bit of Amish fiction and sometimes I find a really stand out series and Plain City Peace is one of them. I like that this series takes place in Plain City, Ohio and the time period of the seventies isn't one that I often read about in Amish series.The author does a very good job of capturing the time period, I don't think I have ever read the term draft dodger in an Amish romance! What really makes this series shine is the unique storyline that involves the Troyer parents leaving the Amish faith, which causes their children turmoil. While the plot is smoothly written the author provides a few twists to keep it interesting. This book is the second in the Plain City Peace series and I recommend that the books be read in order. Overall a unique Amish romance that is far from predictable. I will certainly be watching for the next book in the series.

A complimentary copy of this book was provided for review.

[Virginia Winfield · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is the second book in the Plain City Peace series. It is wonderful. There seems to be a bit of controversy in the Amish and Mennonite churches during this time period. I keep hoping that Betsies parents will come home or convince her to move. Betsie thinks she is in love with Charley or is she really in love with Michael? You will want to read The Bargain before reading this book so you know what is going on. I am looking forward to the next book to see how this all ends. I can't wait. I received this book from book fun.org for a fair and honest opinion.

[Reinalyn · Rating 3 out of 5]

Not my cup of tea

[Beth · Rating 5 out of 5]

I received this book from Kregel Publications for no charge in exchange for an honest review of this book. The opinions expressed here are my own.





Book Description:



In this sequel to The Bargain, Betsie Troyer is back home in her Amish community where she knows she belongs, free from the confusing Englisher way of life. She and Charley Yoder have made promises to each other, and her life is back on track--until Gerald Sullivan shows up with his young daughter, asking for Betsie's help. He’s on his way to find his estranged wife, and begs Betsie to take young Sheila in. When she agrees, Betsie's carefully planned life is shaken up again. Sheila's new found faith is troubling to Charley--and his attraction to another girl is beginning to be a problem. But how can Betsie confront him when she is still trying to confront her own feelings about Sheila's brother, Michael? Keeping the peace between the Amish man she's always loved, a twelve-year-old Englisher girl, and a draft-dodging hippie is more than she ever thought she’d have to deal with in her simple, orderly life. Still, Betsie is convinced she can keep things from falling apart completely. Then during her best friend's wedding, tragedy strikes and her world is upended. She has to make a decision: does she love Charley or Michael . . . or is she craving a deeper love that only God can give? The compelling second novel of the Plain City Peace series, The Bachelor deftly weaves together the strands of a solid, simpler time with the turmoil of an era of change, revealing the strengths of both in its powerful narrative.





My Thoughts:



The Bachelor is the second book in Stephanie Reed's Plain City Peace Series. I had the pleasure of reading her first book, The Bargain, so I was very excited when The Bachelor came out, it had been a long wait. Amish Fiction and Historical Fiction are my favorite genres and this series is both so I LOVE IT! In this next book, Betsie is back home in her Amish community, happy to get back to her plain way of life. Betsie isn't back long before Mr. Sullivan, her English employer, shows up asking Betsie to take in his daughter, Shelia, while he goes to find his wife and try to bring her back to the family. Shelia has nowhere else to go because her brother, Michael, is gone too. Betsie couldn't refuse especially because of her love for the Sullivans especially Shelia. Betsie finds her simple life very complicated again. Betsie is raising her sister and now their brother comes back home after staying with their older brother. Their parents and Aunt Lovina are living in the city as Christians, shunned from their Amish community and happy to be able to believe in Christ. Betsie and her family are being watched by everyone in the community especially Betsie's beau's mom. She is just waiting for Betsie to slip up and has made no secret of it. Charley, Betsie's beau has taken "control" of Betsie's family farm and trying to take control of the Troyer family. Shelia's presence and her faith threaten Charley and he does what he can to convince Betsie Shelia shouldn't be there. As Betsie works hard to keep peace and help Shelia she is also dealing with her torn feelings between Charley and Michael Sullivan. Michael finds himself draft dodging in Tennessee and has written to Betsie and Shelia many times. As Betsie is dealing with all of this she finds out her best friend is moving up her wedding and moving away. While at the wedding, tragedy strikes the Troyer Family and her whole world has fallen apart.



The Bachelor is a great story that combines my two favorite genres, Amish and Historical Fiction. This book takes place in 197, after the Kent State massacre, the draft, the anti war roits and of course the Vietnam war, a time in history that I haven't read many books about, especially about the Amish during this time. This is a very unique story and series. Stephanie Reed writes with authority on The Amish, our country in 1970's, Ohio, and Christian Faith. I loved the way Stephanie Reed starts every chapter with a verse or a saying that Betsie had recorded in her journal or from the Bible. I enjoyed most of the characters in this book, especially Betsie and Shelia. As different as their worlds are they are so much alike and do whatever they can to help each other. They are truly like sisters. Their interactions are deep and their connection is amazing considering the differences in their upbringing. I also enjoyed the letters between Betsie and Michael. Again two people from two different worlds who connect in such a loving way. I found myself unable to put this book down once I picked it up. Stephanie Reed kept me guessing until the end and now I cannot wait for the next book in this series to come out.....it will be a long wait! I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Amish and Historical Christian Fiction, you will not be disappointed! I impatiently await the next book in this series!

[Jeanie · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Bachelor, a complex novel that is the second in the Plain City Peace series by Stephanie Reed, can be enjoyed as a stand-alone book. If one were to read The Bargain, the first novel, prior to reading this one, the reading experience would be richer by far to meet the characters and see the occurrences that immediately preceded this novel.
The Bachelor is written about Plain City, Ohio, Amish in the 1970’s when life in this country seemed to change daily. The communities where Amish lived changed quickly as a result of the occurrences and growing immorality around the country. Betsie Troyer tried desperately to cling to family and friends, even as they were moving – some to Missouri where land was more affordable, some completely leaving the Amish culture while seeking the move of the Holy Spirit in Christian churches.
Betsie’s parents had been away for weeks, as had the aunt who had been going to stay with them. Betsie and her sister Sadie, with the help of Charley Yoder – who wanted to marry Betsie – worked to keep going what they could of the Troyer family farm. Betsie was chafing under Charley’s thumb, who said he was just looking out for her best. In the meantime, Betsie was trying to keep up correspondence with the English man who helped teach her to become a harness maker. So many concerns were on her young shoulders – could she be certain that the path she followed was where the Lord wanted her?
The characters in The Bachelor are so well-developed that they are almost real. I could picture them, felt what they felt as part of their family, struggled through Betsie’s challenges with her. Conversations and descriptions of the primary characters were clear enough that I could form an opinion about them. Betsie, Aunt Lovina, and Sheila were hands-down my favorites. I didn’t like Charley at all, and had mixed feelings about Sadie and Michael.
The plot was thorough and well-executed. In a decade of tumultuous change throughout the country, Stephanie Reed designed a story that reflected the times faced by Amish, even as they were separate from most of the challenges of mainstream America. At times their very separation from the rest of society probably brought much relief to older Amish who heard about anything going on in mainstream schools. Stephanie Reed’s insight into human emotions and spirituality coupled with excellent research and writing brings a unique voice into Amish fiction. The author has successfully woven together the traditional culture and gender roles with some of the current events of the 70’s into a compelling read with sufficient surprises that leaves one eagerly awaiting the next novel. I, for one, can’t wait to see how the choices Betsie will make are introduced – and how they work out! I highly recommend this novel to young adults and adults of all ages who like Amish fiction, are interested in the changes brought to the Amish through the late and post Viet Nam War eras.
With a grateful heart, I received a copy of this book through the “For Readers Only” group at The Book Club Network, in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.

[Narita · Rating 5 out of 5]

Seventeen old Betsie Troyer, and her teenage brother and sister, Abijah and Sadie, are left to fend for themselves when their parents leave the Amish faith and move away. They are faced with the shame of their parent’s shunning because they accepted Christ as their Savior. The children pray fervently that their parents will see the error of their ways and return. In the mean time they must carry on with Betsy trying to be both father and mother to her siblings. The pressure she faces is incredible.
Charley, Betsie’s intended beau since childhood, comes frequently to assist with the chores and repairs that require a man. He seems sincerely devoted in helping her, but is he? Michael, an Englisher friend of many years who has moved away continues to write her. She treasures his friendship, as he truly understands her.
To add to her already heavy load, a man she has worked for in the past leaves his 12 year old daughter Shelia to stay with the Troyers. He is leaving town to try and bring his wife back that has left them. This creates conflict not only with her siblings, but also with her church and Charley. A shocking tragedy reveals who really has Betsie’s best interest at heart.
Just when I thought no one could come up with an Amish novel with a unique storyline, Ms. Reed has managed to! Most of the time it is the youth leaving the church for the world, but this time it is the parents. I was shocked and upset with her parents for abandoning their children. Especially with all the responsibilities that are a part of an Amish household.
The story was made even more interesting by all the details of the situations the author so vividly describes. So much so in fact, I felt pressure with all Betsie was dealing with! She was a brave and dedicated young woman, but there were so many decisions that she needed her parent’s wisdom for. All in all, she does an incredible job.
The characters were interesting. I enjoyed Shelia. Her youthful innocence, candidness and strong, childlike Christian faith unaffected by others, was delightful! Psalm 8:2, “Out of the mouth of babes and sucklings hast thou ordained strength . . .” aptly describes this little lady!
As the story progresses, the integrity and motives of each individual was gradually revealed. I liked this because it added suspense, and excitement to the plot. I was inspired by Betsie’s taking every problem and decision to the Lord in prayer. She continued trusting and asking even though circumstances seemed unchanged. Through her trials she begins making her own choices separate from the opinions of other and the rules of her culture.
I did not read the previous book but I feel this one stood alone. I look forward to reading it and the 3rd sequel to come in 2016. Well written, entertaining and hard to put down!
I received this book free from the publisher through Kregel Publications which requires an honest, though not necessarily positive, review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.

[Laura · Rating 3 out of 5]

Title: THE BACHELOR
Author: Stephanie Reed
Publisher: Kregel
October 2014
ISBN: 978-0825442162
Genre: Amish / Women’s fiction

In this sequel to The Bargain, Betsie Troyer is back home in her Amish community where she knows she belongs, free from the confusing Englisher way of life. She and Charley Yoder have made promises to each other, and her life is back on track--until Gerald Sullivan shows up with his young daughter, asking for Betsie's help. He’s on his way to find his estranged wife, and begs Betsie to take young Sheila in.

When she agrees, Betsie's carefully planned life is shaken up again. Sheila's newfound faith is troubling to Charley--and his attraction to another girl is beginning to be a problem. But how can Betsie confront him when she is still trying to confront her own feelings about Sheila's brother, Michael?

Keeping the peace between the Amish man she's always loved, a twelve-year-old Englisher girl, and a draft-dodging hippie is more than she ever thought she’d have to deal with in her simple, orderly life. Still, Betsie is convinced she can keep things from falling apart completely.

Then during her best friend's wedding, tragedy strikes and her world is upended. She has to make a decision: does she love Charley or Michael . . . or is she craving a deeper love that only God can give?

The compelling second novel of the Plain City Peace series, THE BACHELOR deftly weaves together the strands of a solid, simpler time with the turmoil of an era of change, revealing the strengths of both in its powerful narrative.

It has been a long time since I read the first book in this series, and I had some issues remembering what had happened. It would help if there was a blurb reminding readers what happened in the first book, The Bargain, and in this book so readers would remember the story better. Either that or read the books together. I was hopelessly lost at first.
The Amish district in this book is very strict, very harsh. I didn’t connect with the characters in this book at all. Looking back I did enjoy The Bargain. Betsie had no problems lying and there is a lot of discord among her family, future in-laws, and the community. But that may be realistic since it is based on a real life Amish community that the Englisch world is swallowing up. In fact, in the author’s notes, she says there are only four Amish families living there at the time this was published.

THE BACHELOR is well written, and I loved the diary entries and quotes at the tops of the chapters. The third book in the series, The Bride, will be coming in winter 2016.

Available in ebook and paperback. 256 pages.

[Sheila · Rating 2 out of 5]

I get so aggravated at myself when I request a book to review only to find out it is the second in a series and I have yet to read the first. I really need to pay more attention to this! Sometimes this is not a problem, but more often then not it is better to read a series in order. So, with that being said, that is what happened to me with The Bachelor.

The Bachelor by Stephanie Reed is book two in the Plain City Peace Series. As I mentioned, I did not read the first book in the series and I feel like this really took away from the book for me. I felt lost and unconnected to the characters, especially at first. It seemed as if I was missing the first part of the story and I guess I was, I think this book picked up right where the first one left off. The end of The Bachelor is a bit of a cliff hanger so I am sure that book three is going to pick off where this one ends as well. Even though I started with the second book it did peak my interest enough to make me want to go back and read The Bargain, which is the first book. I think I'll wait till the third book comes out though. The Bride is not to be released until 2016 so I will wait till closer to that time and read book one for the first time and then book two again to refresh my memory.

There were several things about The Bachelor that I liked. It was different than a lot of the Amish fiction stories I have read in the past. It is set in the 70's and I have read very few books from that time period and I really enjoyed that. I also liked that it gave a more realistic view of Amish life and their beliefs. I would definitely recommend reading it, but be sure to grab The Bargain first and start from the beginning!

More about The Bachelor:

Betsie Troyer is back home in her Amish community after her parents have left for the English world. Her parents have been shunned by the community and Betsie is now caring for her siblings. Betsie is happy with her life and feels like she is getting everything "back on track". Her and Charley Yoder have made promises to each other and she is looking forward to a future with him, but when her English neighbor asks Betsie to care for his 12 year old daughter Sheila, Betsie's life gets turned upside down once again. Between trying to keep peace with Charley, taking care of a 12 year old, and her friendship with Sheila's brother..the draft dodging, hippy Englisher named Michael, Betsie begins to question what God's plan is for her life. Will God make the choice clear?

[Blue North · Rating 5 out of 5]

Betsie, Abijah and Sadie are brother and sisters. In The Bachelor by Stephanie Reed, the parents of these three have been shunned by the Plain City, Ohio Amish community. They are shunned because they have accepted Jesus. The parents leaving the community surprised me. Usually, young people leave the Amish world for other experiences but not the parents.This time the parent aren't the good role models. It is Betsie. It is Betsie, Abijah and Sadie who keep the candle light burning in the window while hoping and praying their parents will come back to the fold. While the parents are gone, Betsie contends with a tragedy that happened to her while at the same time trying to choose the man she will love. She sees Charley everyday. She writes to Michael who is living in a school bus away from home.

I became most interested in the parents leaving the Amish world. Also, I did not expect the ending. The shocking ending leads to more questions and answers. In the meantime, there are the different ups and downs facing the Amish household. It is surprising that Betsie is able to keep her head on straight. She has her moments, but overall she does wonderfully. She almost becomes too good to be true.

Charley is the one who seems like a real person. This is because it is so easy to see his flaws. Charley wants his own farm one day. As Betsie's parents stay away longer and longer, I think he sees himself as married to Betsie with a farm already prepared for him to manage. Perhaps, Charley is too confident. He never doubts that Betsie will marry him and fill his house with children. His attitude bothered me.

In the end, Betsie makes her own decisions about whom to marry. The strength of the novel is that Betsie is strong. She's not a fragile Amish girl who can only pick up chicken and eggs. She's running a whole household with no man around to help except for Charley's occasional appearances. When times really get tough, Charley is not the one who helps her. Even when the most shocking and painful circumstance come into their lives, Betsie is able to hold up under pressure.

It is a novel about love and family. Families are not stagnant. Families change and the unexpected can and does happen. It is not possible to lock people into any role. Betsie did not expect to take the place of her parents in that farmhouse. So Betsie faces a test of faith and love. It is hoped that her love will remain steadfast.

[Nicki Olsen · Rating 4 out of 5]

*Book Description*

Betsie Troyer knows life will be so much more simple again, now that she's back in her Amish home. Or so she thought before Sheila Sullivan reenters her life. Now with 2 men, one english and one amish, an English little girl to cheer up, and a nasty pony, Betsie finds herself more frazzled then ever. Trying to regain Charley Yoder's trust, however, is easier said then done. Especially when Michael insists on sending her letters...and she insists on responding to them. Now, as she eagerly awaits hearing from the Englischer, she begins to wonder if she's made the right decision... if she even wants Charley to trust her again. With all these feelings, will her life ever be back in order again?

Charley Yoder can't believe Betsie would defy her promise just minutes after she made it. That's not the only thing making his blood boil though...Sheila Sullivan is an Englischer and therefore doesn't belong here. Why can't Betsie see that? Will she ever make up their mind so they can have a life together? And can he even live with someone who refuses to abide to his rules?


*What I liked*
Stephanie did a realy great job both with showing the Amish life and how they think towards the English. It really showed both sides well, and somehow had us rooting both men at the same time. She also had a sweet cover.


*What I didn't like*
The main thing I didn't like was the ending!! It was so rushed and cut off with her decision in the end, I'm pretty sure my mouth was gaping. Add in the fact that her third book doesn't come out until 2016 and you have a slightly disappointed, avid reader. Stephanie will make up for it though!

*My Rating*




*Why my rating is what it is*

My rating is 3 1/2 stars (4 stars on store reviews) mainly because of the ending but also because it was a bit slower then I'd like it. However, it is a very good book all in all so get this book and the first book in the series!

[Becky Lewis · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a very different kind of Amish story. Betsie Troyer is struggling to care for the family farm and her sister, plus eventually her brother and also a young daughter of a former Englisher employer. As we enter this unusual storyline, we find that Betsie's parents have been banned by the bishop because they have announced their faith in Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior. This puts them at odds with their community and family, and the parents actually leave the community.

Even in her busyness, Betsie is incredibly lonely for her parents' wisdom and help with raising the three younger ones. It is her hope and dream that her parents would return to their farm and family. Michael also plays prominently in Betsie's dreams, although she is promised to neighboring Charley and determined to marry him.

Others hold their own dreams. Charlie has his dreams that take Betsie quite a while to discover. Michael has some wild ones and some of his do not pan out. Sheila shares her faith, praying for her dreams to come true. In the end, we get a hint of whose dreams will come true, but the ending is not real definitive as this is the second book of three and the author leaves plenty of room for book three to answer many loose ends.

I will hand it to Ms. Reed, not many authors tackle this ticklish topic of Amish doctrinal beliefs. It might also be fair to say that not all Amish communities hold to the rejection of Jesus Christ as Lord, as portrayed here. Young Sheila was an amazing little girl, who was unafraid to stand for her beliefs and knew her Bible verses, yet was still sweet and loveable. I found myself searching the back of the book for information on the third book of the series. Alas, this book is fairly new!

I received this book from bookfun.org in exchange for an honest review.

[Mary · Rating 3 out of 5]

Betsie Troyer longs for all of her family to return to their farm in Plain City, Ohio. Instead adhering to the Ordnung, the set of rules that guide Amish everyday life, they left the farm and Amish life and now claim to follow Jesus in the novel The Bachelor, book two in the Plain City Peace series. Left to manage the farm with her younger sister, the two struggle to maintain everything on their own. To make matter worse, Gerald Sullivan, an Englisher who owns the harness shop where Betsie serves as an apprentice, wants to leave his young daughter with her while he goes to find his wife that left him to pursue other interests. Betsie agrees to take in the young girl, Sheila, to the objection of her sister. The presence of a young Englisher girl in their home adds to the negative opinion the Amish community holds against the Troyer family.

She feels relieved that Michael, an Englisher, close friend and Sheila’s brother, left Plain City to dodge the draft and live as a hippie. Betsie’s feelings towards him confused her, although she misses the playful, poetry reading, thoughtful Michael. Now she focuses on the handsome Amish Charley Yoder as they make plans to share a life together. As the story progresses, Charley’s distant, authoritative manner causes Betsie to question if he is the man for her. Charley reluctantly accepts Sheila’s presence and the faith that she talks about irritates him. As far as he is concerned, the worldly teaching of following Jesus is not the way to salvation. Only the Amish will spend eternity with God.

When trouble visits the Troyer family, Charley’s cool demeanor gives her pause: time to consider if Charley is the man for her and time to consider which way is the path to salvation. Although The Bachelor contains more discontent among its characters than what is typically found in Amish fiction, overall it was a decent book.

[Jaquelyn Scroggie · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Bachelor is book 2 in the Plain City Peace series. I haven’t read book one, The Bargain, but would recommend reading it before reading this book. It wasn’t necessary, but I feel like I might have understood the characters better if I had more of their back story. I will probably go back and read book one for fun. I would also like to read book three, the Bride, which will come out in 2016. The Bachelor is set in the 1970’s which adds a different feel to the story overall, and makes it interesting. Betsie Troyer had spent some time in the English community, but is now back home where life is more simple. There are some things the English do that she will never understand and is thankful to be back on normal ground. Charley Yoder has always seemed like the man of her dreams, and the best looking Amish man in her community, not that she is supposed to notice that. When Charley hints about a marriage between them Betsie is thrilled. But is Charley the man she thinks he is? Betsie can’t help but follow her heart when a English friend of hers asks if his daughter can stay with Betsie for a while. Shelia is such a sweet girl, and strong in her faith in God. When Betsie takes her in, almost everyone in the Amish community thinks she’s making a mistake. Charley shows his disapproval in her decision, but tries to guide her in his own way. This book is full of twists and turns you don’t see coming. There is joy, sadness, tragedy, and love mixed throughout the story. I would recommend this book to someone who enjoys a different type of Amish story than the normal. I received a copy of this book from the publisher and TBCN in exchange for my honest opinion. All opinions expressed are my own.

[Linda Ortiz · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Bachelor, by Stephanie Reed is a second novel In the series Plain City Peace. Since I did not read the first book, I was not sure if I would get lost reading the second book of the series. I found the second book to be easy to follow along. I did not get lost with the storyline and its characters. The story is placed in the 1970's in an Amish community, where during that time there were quite a lot of changes in that era. The story is about a young woman who has gone through several changes in her life in the Amish Community. Her parents have left the Amish to pursue Christ freely. She feels that they will change their mind and return to the farm in Plain City, Ohio. Also, she is courting Charley who she feels is safe and reliable and has made a promise to. It is not until, she is confronted with a decision to take care of her English employer’s daughter, Sheila that her life starts to take a different turn. Betsie, understands what the Sheila is going through being separated from her parents, but she is also torn from what is expected of her in the Amish community, especially, with Charley and her sister Sadie. Betsie, throughout the story goes through many different emotions, especially, when it comes to Sheila's brother, Mike. Who sounded like a kindred spirit with Betsie? Someone who accepted her for who she was and did not want anything different from her. Toward, the middle of the story I was not liking Charley very much, and rooting for Mike to be the one Betsie chooses. Overall, The Bachelor, was an excellent book to read! I was given this book by The Book Club Network for my honest review. I recommend this book, I am looking forward to Book 3 of Plain City Peace Series.

[Shannon · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Bachelor by Stephanie Reed is like no other Amish book I have read! This is the second book in the series but it was easily read without the first, although for further background would recommend, given the choice, to read in order.

Betsie Troyer is now the head of the household, as her parents having accepted Christ, have been banished from the Amish community. The parents have left behind everything to follow Christ. What a testimony!

Seems like an easy story until you add main characters: Charley Yoder whom helps out with the farm and wants to become the head of this home as well as Michael, an Englisher whom has sparks with Betsie, and whom she can't seem to forget. Although committed to Charley in her head, her heart is with Michael...but how can she ever be with him?

Betsie works for an English employer and when he leaves to seek to bring his wife home, he asks her to take in his young daughter Sheila. How can she do this? She knows the pain, the anger it will cause her younger sister Sadie whom is off at work at the bakery with Charey's mom. The pain of having her parents choose to follow Christ over the Amish life and the family, has left both daughters with struggles. And then there is dear sweet Sheila whom just overwhelms the family members, especially their brother when she says she will pray for him. Will God use this little one to reach this family for Him?

There is so much more to this story, and you will be laughing, crying, and cheering for Betsie to make the right choices.

Pick up this book today and be prepared for a most enjoyable, although unexpected read. You'll be glad you did.

I was given this book in exchange for an honest review by bookfun.org.

[Pamela Pavkov · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Bachelor is the second book in the Plain City Peace series written by Stephanie Reed. I enjoyed the first book so much I was happy to be able to continue the story since I already had the book. The author quickly reunites the readers with the characters and what had happened in the previous book.

Betsie Troyer is at home following an attack on her by Englisher and is trying to decide whether to return to Plain City and the harness shop. Since Betsie has made a promise to Charley Yoder to court leading to marriage she knows she should stay home. Before she can make her decision the Mr. Sullivan and Sheila, the young daughter, show up unexpectedly at her house. With a plea for Betsie help she is placed with the decision to go against Charley's wishes or honor the request from her friends.

Betsie has problems of her own with trying to keep it secret that her parents have left the Amish community. She is also the only one who knows where Michael Sullivan has run off to and why. With her growing feelings for Michael how can she break her promise to Charley. When the police show up at Betsie house and have Michael with them she is now faced with wondering what is happening next. Can Betsie figure out who she really loves before it's to late? Will she be able to convince her parents to return to the Amish community before the secret gets out?

I was not given a complimentary copy of this book for review. I am submitting my honest review for a wonderful story that has alot of twist and turns and keeps the readers wanting more. I have rated this book with five stars for a wonderful book. I will be watching for the next book which is scheduled for release on the winter of 2016. Congratulations to Stephanie Reed for continuing a wonderful story and series.

[Michelle Morgan · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Bachelor Book Two of Plain City Peace Series by Stephanie Reed (TBN)
Kregel Publications
ISBN 9780825442162
Amish, Christian Fiction
The Bachelor is set in 1970’s around the Vietnam war and draft. Bestie Troyer lives in Plain City where she is raising her two younger siblings and taking care of a English girl. Her biggest prayer is for her parents and aunt to return to Amish life. They left the Amish life to live out their new-found faith in Jesus. Bestie is promised to Charley but has a intense friendship with Englisher Michael. Among much confusion she has to decide who to give her heart to and which faith she will follow.
The author Stephanie Reed did a great job explaining salvation in this story. I really enjoyed learning how the Amish and English view faith and salvation. It was an eye opening experience to see the contrast of faith between Bestie who is Amish and Englisher Sheila. They both had such strong beliefs. The Bachelor is book 2 in Plain City Peace series but it stands alone. I have not read the first book The Bargain but after enjoying this one so much I will.
I loved this fast paced Amish novel. It was thought provoking, well written and filled with faith. I give The Bachelor 5 stars. And a high-five to the author Stephanie Reed and publisher Kregel Publications for bringing compelling Christian books that are entertaining and give hope to the reader with stories of faith. The Book Club Network Inc. provided me with this book in exchange for my honest review and I am so grateful for their, the authors and publishers generosity.

[Maureen Timerman · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Batchelor is set in the 1970’s and the setting is a failing Amish Community known as Plain City, and as we are reunited with Betsie, we are reminded that her parents have left her and her and her brother and sister. Through out the story, Betsie is on bended knee prayer her folks will return and give up their ideas of being saved.
The author has provided a lot of information if you haven’t read The Bargain, but it is an awesome book, and I would highly recommend reading it. We met the Sullivan family in The Bargain, and now Betsie is faced with a problem when she is begged to temporarily give Shelia Sullivan, a twelve year old, a home. She does so knowing her Community will not like the Englisher staying in her house. Even her siblings give her a hard time, but Charlie Yoder, who is now coming to court her, is really upset that Shelia is here.
There is more tension when Michael begins writing, and Charlie finds out. Betsie also begins to relive the attack that was made on her while at the Sullivan’s, and you have to wonder if it is Michael or Charlie she fears. I also found Charlie’s mother to be a person I sure would avoid, not a very pleasant personality here, and Betsie better be careful when she marries Charlie.
What an up and down story your about to experience, some chuckles, and some heart ache, come and immerse yourself in this great read. See whom Betsie belongs with!

I received this book through Kregel Publications, and was not required to give a positive review.

[Donna McGinnis · Rating 4 out of 5]

I love to read Amish fictional books. Curious about how they live, their lifestyle and faith. I wish I could have read The Bargain the first book in this series before reading The Bachelor but Stephanie's writing style gave me enough insight into the first book that I had no trouble getting into this story and the well developed characters. This story takes place in the 1970's.
When Betsie Troyer's parents Fannie and Noah renounce their Amish faith to follow Christ they are shunned from the Amish community leaving Betsie, her sister Sadie and their brothers to run the family farm. Betsie is happy to be back in her Amish community after finishing her apprenticeship in the English world. However she is also being drawn back to the English world. Charley Yoder helps Betsie out on the farm. They make promises to each other about a future life together. Then there is the Englisher Michael a quirky draft dodger. Will it be Charley or Michael in her future?
To add more to her already heavy load Betsie's English employer asks if she will look after his 12 year old daughter while he searches for his estranged wife. How can she do this? What will her church, her siblings and Charley think?
A great read. I recommend this book and plan to read the first and third books in the Plain City Peace series.

I received a free copy of his book from bookfun.org for my honest opinion and review.

[Pat · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Bachelor by Stephanie Reed is the second book in the series. I haven't read it the first one and this book can be read as a stand alone. Amish fiction, with a few twists and turns. Betsie Troyer is back home from spending time in the English world. She is attracted two different men. One English and one Amish. One is confusing and the other is steady, dependable and safe. Betsie has to make a decision with what to do with her life. Whether to remain Amish or to become English. To make decisions harder, her parents have left the Amish faith and have been shunned. Betsie is the one to try and keep the family together and take care of her siblings. To add to the mix, an English neighbor leaves his daughter with Betsie to care for while he tries to get his wife to return home. There is a lot going on and the book will keep you interested.

This book does leave you hanging. The bad part is that the next book in the series doesn't come out until the winter of 2016. There are a lot of unanswered questions so you will want to read the next book. I received this book through www.bookfun.org and the publisher. All I was asked to do was leave my honest opinion on the book. I did enjoy the book; however I wish I didn't have to wait two years for the next book in the series.

[Deanna Stevens · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Bachelor by Stephanie Reed is the second book in the Plain City Peace series. I have not read The Bargain but I found thatThe Bachelor can be read as a stand alone. This is Amish fiction with ideas about the Amish I hadn't read before. Betsie Troyer is back home from spending time in the English world. Betsie has to make a decision with what to do in her life. Whether to remain Amishor to become English. Betsie likes her Amish life but her decision is harder because her parents have left the Amish faith and have been shunned and not allowed to contact anyone in the Amish community. Betsie is left to try and keep her family together and take care of her siblings. To add to the mix, an English neighbor leaves his daughter with Betsie to care for while he is away on an emergency. Betsie has to decide whether to join her parents and become English or become a member of the Amish community, and maybe become Charlie's wife. This Amish story was set in the 1970's was a little different
from what I have read about the Amish. I found there was a lot going on in The Bachelor but it made the story very interesting and I enjoyed reading it.
I was gifted this book from the publisher Kregel Publications and the Book Club Network (bookfun.org)
for my honest opinion which I have given.

[Tammy G. · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Bachelor by Stephanie Reed is the second book in the Plain City Peace series. I missed book one, The Bargain, but as I began reading The Bachelor, the story of Betsie Troyer, I was caught up in her Amish lifestyle.
It seems that Betsie has been gone (assuming this took place in book one) but she now knows she belongs at home in her Amish community because being with the Englischers was quite confusing to her way of thinking. Ah! No place like home!
It seems that Betsie just wants a simple life but as others call on her for help...Gerald Sullivan asks her, well actually begs her, to take care of his daughter while he searches for his estranged wife. And then she and Charley seem to have made promises they can't keep...does she truly love Charley when she thinks about Michael? The quote at the top of page 133, "A woman is perturbed by what a man forgets, a man by what a woman remembers" is one of my favorite quotes out of the book...sort of/kind of sums up this read.
Even though I didn't read book one I found this the story of Betsie and Charley interesting.
This is a great read for all those Amish fans but you may want to read book one first just to get the whole story!


This book was provided for review by Kregel Publications*

[J.C. Morrows · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Bachelor is the 2nd book in Stephanie Reed’s Plain City Peace series.

In book 1 – The Bargain, we were introduced to the characters and their complex situations.

In book 2 we’ve taken the next step in that relationship and we become even more involved with these beloved characters.

The Bargain introduced to us the idea that the “Amish” way is not the only path to heaven and at the time it was a radical idea that really shook up our main character.

In book 2, we explore this subject even deeper and it brings so many questions to bear – questions that can probably never be answered to our satisfaction…

Betsie is facing confusion, not only about her parents but about her feelings about two certain young men.


Such confusion certainly explains why the plain people work so hard to limit their exposure to the outside world.

Since that wasn’t exactly an option for Betsie, she is left with her confusion and frustration and some pretty big decisions that may forever change the course of her life… and perhaps even the lives around her.

Stephanie Reed will capture your attention and have you positively desperate for the final installment of this trilogy.

[Tima · Rating 2 out of 5]

Betsie is home in the Amish community where she feels she belongs. But things are rapidly changing. Taking care of her siblings, as well as an Englisher girl can be overwhelming. Confusing thoughts about two completely different men, troubles with her siblings, and worry about her parents all pile on top of the tons of work that needs to be done almost overwhelming her. Can she decide where she wants her life to go while filling the ache in her heart?

I have the very bad habit of picking a book without realizing it is the middle of the series. This happened once again. The book is definitely not a stand alone. So be sure to read the first book before picking this one up. That being said, it starts off well and is entertaining. It follows the typical Amish pattern with conflicts about religion and distractions with the English community. The book hints at some endings, but leaves the reader hanging in anticipation for the next book in the series.

I received this book free of charge from Book Club Network in exchange for my review.

[Britney · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Bachelor is the second book in Stephanie Reed’s Plain City Peace series. There were several references to events detailed in the first book, The Bargain, which I have not read. However, enough information was given, and I was able to follow the story. For a better understanding of the characters and storyline, I would recommend reading this series in order.

“Set against the backdrop of the turbulent 1970s”, The Bachelor is a unique Amish tale. Betsie Troyer is a complex character and faces many challenges in her life. I felt compassion for this young woman and especially enjoyed her relationship with a young English girl left in her care. The romantic threads in this story were also interesting and I am eager to know where Betsie’s feelings will lead her. At the end of The Bachelor, unanswered questions linger and leave the reader in anticipation of the next book, The Bride.

I received a complimentary copy of this book through The Book Club Network. All thoughts expressed are my own and no monetary compensation was received.

[Cindi · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is the second book in the series. Although it would have been helpful to read the first one, to get some history on the characters, I was able to figure things out as I read.

I was very impressed with this authors writing skills and the storyline. The Christian influence was especially appreciated. The only downside of the novel is that it ended and I have to wait until the next book is released. I can't wait!! Ü

My favorite Character was Sheila. Having a strong and unshakeable faith at such a young age is commendable and truly an inspiration.

I received a copy of The Bachelor from bookfun.org in exchange for an honest review.

[Lori Weller · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Bachelor is Book Two in the Plain City Peace Series. I read the first book so I was able to understand and enjoy the characters. The book is able to be read as a stand alone but probably more enjoyable if read as a series. This concerns Betsy, an Amish girl who is taking care a the farm with her sister since her parents left. She is asked to help an Englisher and this displeases her Amish boyfriend. Their is humor, tears, faith and family found in this story. I enjoyed it and look forward to more works by this author.
I received this book from the Book Club Network in exchange for my honest opinion.

[Jami Bennington · Rating 5 out of 5]

A few years ago, I was given the opportunity to read Stephanie's Reed's novel Across the Wide River. I had never read anything written by her before, and I was moved by her writing. I've been a reader of Amish fiction since my teen years when my grandmother introduced me to Beverly Lewis' books, and for many years it was a genre that was my favorite. I don't read a lot of it at this point, due to burn-out, but when I saw that Stephanie's newest novel was available for review, I snagged the opportunity to read some well-written story!

http://jamiswords.blogspot.com/2014/1...

[Janice Sisemore · Rating 4 out of 5]

The bachelor

This is the 2nd in the series, could be read as a stand alone but better to read "the Bargain" first. In the first book Betsie was working away from home but in this book she is back to her Amish home, her parents had left to live as English. Betsie keeps hoping they will come back home. Two men in her life, Charley who is Amish and Michael who is English and his sister is living there for a short time. This is set in the 1970s. I did enjoy this book but was disappointed when it ended and found out have to wait over a year for the next book. I received this book from book club network for a honest review.