And now I've finally read another book from each of the ripoff series I looked at during my theme month. I will be getting to more as these tend to be fun.
This one is interesting as it is part of what I call the Creature Teacher trilogy. See, before Goosebumps did Creature Teacher in Series 2000, 3 of the ripoff/similar series beat Stine to the punch. Besides this, there was Graveyard School;s Creature Teacher, Spooksville's Creature in the Teacher, and then there was this. I know it's a common turn of phrase for horror stories but it's just funny so many did it before Goosebumps did.
Can't compare it to the Goosebumps one yet, although I have read The Final Exam. Still, I'll judge it on its own here and I ended up liking it. It did throw me off in a few ways though. It starts with protagonist Joey Powers and his friend Nate being goof off jerks towards their teacher which wasn't a good start for them.
Then when a literally hurricane is coming, Joey gets the idea to get back to the school and wait out the storm to prove to Nate he's brave or whatever. Yeah I was ready to hate this one but then around here it gets better. It actually takes a while for the Teacher Creature to appear, as the first half is them, along with the "Class brain" Molly Murphy, get trapped in school during the storm, with a monster emerging from a nearby swamp.
Once the storm clears and things get better, a new teacher comes in that turns out to be a mutation born from that storm. This happens like 60 pages into a 128 page book, so while they do spend a decent chunk of time exploring this, it being later in means we quickly get into Joey finding him weird while no one believes him.
One frustrating thing was that Molly and Nate are quck to shut Joey him down even though they straight up saw a monster during the storm. I know Molly's shtick is being the scientific type but it just felt forced, and what's Nate's excuse?
That aside, still some fun stuff here, like the nature of how they reveal Mr. Batrachian is a kid eater, and some solid descriptions here and there. Honestly the hurricane section was the best part, the stakes were high and this could have just been a sort of Sy-Fy Channel style natural disaster mutation story. The teacher stuff is more standard in comparison.
I ended up enjoying the dynamic with the characters, as joey tries to put on a brave face, Nate is kinda the same but more a jerk about it, and Molly is again, the brain that Joey initially doesn't like but of course they eventually get stuck together and team up. It's kinda sitcom-y but actually in the good fun charming way, for the most part.
There's some wonky logic things, which is to be expected although some kinda stretch it lol. Ending was pretty abrupt although the solution was something else. Much like Pet Shop of Horrors, this had dark parts, there's a running thing where the monster teacher is seen with blood in his mouth, at one point he full on eats a racoon carcass, and it is stated that he ate the previous teacher, again using that blood in mouth as a tell. Damn.
Overall, clunky in places but has some solid highs that it make it fun. It's about as good as Pet Shop, has a few more clunky bits but less threats of animal abuse at least. (As far as the Creature Teacher trilogy goes, a tad lesser than the Spooksville one but arguably a bit more creative since that one reuses elements from previous books in that series, making it a lesser one for that series imo but still good and that series stronger elements make it a bit better than this one in general)
One last thing, this had an episode in the TV show and it's a perfect example of how In Name Only. There, Batrachian is already an established teacher (and he's stern, while in the book he at least pretends to be nice), and becomes a creature after eating some gunk put in his sandwich that came from a swamp. So it's the total opposite, and ontop of that, while he is stern, he does rightfully punish the main boy kids for being disruptive and his monster antics are the fault of his mutation, not his true nature pr say so it's kind of harsh when he is thrown back in the swamp with no explanation as to if he's alive or not.
Yeah, I surprisingly like the book more. Okay, now I'm done.