While reading this series, I found myself often asking if I should keep reading. I did complete the series, in part because at a foundational level the story line is interesting but there were several points of frustration for me. First, many of the love interest characters felt underdeveloped—their motivations are stated in a conclusively manner without truly digging into what guides them to those motivators. Second, the MC constantly forgives her love interests, because she loves them. In the case of Nyx, this was particularly difficult to accept as the MC talks about these huge betrayals and then just throws her hands up in a “but I love him” conclusion. Third, many plot lines of interest throughout the series never got full closure. Why do we loose the Catsuga and never fully come back to them? What happened to her gifts such as the compass, jewels, and cloak? What of her baby brother when she met her step mother again in the human world? Fourth, inconsistencies and underdeveloped sub plots and story lines. Fifth and finally, the author has the MC go through some pretty verbose and overly dragged out thought line that span pages and don’t really add anything beyond trying to emphasize how much she loves them or how important something is. Given the other issues noted above, this ultimately felt like wasted space on the page.
Again, interesting plot line overall but an underwhelming series. I won’t be going back for more if off shoots come out.