Very difficult to review this. As a novel, I don't know that the plot is satisfactory, but as for the writing itself, the themes and the scenes - 5* all the way. Gunn is a newfound favorite for me. I can only think to describe his work as having elemental themes - how the individuals who live from the earth, or in this case, the sea, have very little "skin" between themselves and the world. I mean, nature and the elements are their life, which is as obvious a statement as you can get, but is lost on most of us who have 10,000 distractions battering us from within and without at any given moment. Gunn is masterful at taking us into a world we no longer possess. His description of a violent storm and the villagers congregating on the seashore in desperation to catch a glimpse of their fishermen, fathers and sons and brothers, as they try to make shore without being crushed by the waves, is as close to being there as I can imagine.
..."As the boats came nearer a silence fell on everyone and the bodies grew still. The first great relief was passing into the menace of the the harbour bar. The storm leapt alive again, its thunder pounding on the beach, its drift stinging eyes that stared with unwinking fixity. The women had drawn a little nearer the knot of men by the breakwater, and their wide skirts flapped in the wind below faces hooded and peaked by tight-drawn shawls. They looked like a group caught in a grey dawn of history, or legend, their separateness from the men fateful and eternal."
The book is written from the perspective of the youngest son of a fisherman's family, and his vulnerability and impressionable nature seem to me what takes it from a good story to a great one. His developing sense of family and brotherhood, of what it means to be a full human being - well, the events of life work on him in a similar way as the waves and storm did on his father and brother. We stand on the shore, desperately hoping he will come through.