Collector's Edition: Innovative Packaging and Graphics

by Stuart Tolley

This global survey of graphic design innovation brings together over 170 examples from the worlds of music, book publishing, and magazines that have been released as collector’s, limited, or deluxe editions. It includes a broad spectrum of work, formats, and genres, ranging from editions of albums by international recording artists including Coldplay and Radiohead, to ultra-rare and expensive publications such as The Vatican Secret Archives, handbound in the Vatican studio and produced in an edition of just thirty-three copies (three of which were reserved for the Pope).

Collector's Edition is organized into four sections: Boxed; Multiples; Hand; and Extras. Each of the featured design examples is accompanied by a brief yet detailed project description, a list of specifications outlying the format, materials, and finishes used, and full credits for the client, record label, publisher, and designer behind the work. Each section also includes interviews with designers such as Stefan Sagmeister and Stanley Donwood to gain their views and insights on why the materiality and tactility of printed packaging are more important than ever.

Genres: Nonfiction

288 pages, Hardcover

First published September 16, 2014

Reviews

[Haryasena Adhi Pramana · Rating 4 out of 5]

Collector's Edition promises an exploration into the world of innovative packaging and graphic design, and at first glance, it certainly sparks curiosity. As a designer, I found moments of inspiration throughout the book — especially in some of the experimental formats and unexpected branding approaches. It offers a decent overview of how packaging can transcend its functional purpose and become an object of desire.

However, the overall execution feels somewhat underwhelming. The book touches on many concepts but rarely dives deep enough to provide meaningful insight or analysis. The content feels like it’s caught between being a visual catalog and a critical design anthology — and ends up achieving neither fully.

Visually, while some spreads are captivating, much of the layout and photography lacks the dynamism and immersive quality one would expect from a book about visual innovation. The graphic design is serviceable, but not particularly engaging or daring — which is ironic, given the subject matter.

In short, Collector's Edition offers a few sparks of inspiration, but falls short in delivering a truly compelling or comprehensive experience. It might be a good coffee table book, but less so a source of in-depth creative fuel.

[Richard · Rating 3 out of 5]

Form follows function /
is the standard ruling — here /
functions follow form.