Jump to ratings and reviews

The Big Lie: A Shane Cleary Mystery

Poodle. Standard. Black. Studded collar. No tags. Goes by the name of Boo.Sun Tzu may have said, ‘Keep your friends close; keep your enemies closer,’ but he didn’t live in Boston, he’s not Shane Cleary, and Shane’s latest and most unexpected client is Southie’s most dangerous criminal.The man who almost killed Shane wants to hire him, but Shane is more interested in Jimmy’s ‘bonus for a job done well and discretely—information about his father’s death.His cat Delilah is against it, his girlfriend Bonnie the lawyer doesn’t know.Everything screams he shouldn’t take the gig, but Shane can’t resist Jimmy’s ‘incentive.’Life is neither easy nor simple for Shane. Bonnie asks for help on a pro bono case, friend Bill wants a background check, mafia henchman Tony makes a peculiar request, and Shane can’t help but think his client just might kill him anyway after he finds the dog.Does Jimmy know a Truth that will change Shane’s life, or is it a big lie?

192 pages, Paperback

Published March 12, 2024

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Gabriel Valjan

38 books273 followers
Gabriel Valjan is the author of The Company Files, and the Shane Cleary Mysteries with Level Best Books. He has been nominated for the Agatha, Anthony, Derringer, and Silver Falchion awards. He received the 2021 Macavity Award for Best Short Story and the 2024 Shamus Award forBest Private Investigator. Gabriel is a member of the Historical Novel Society, ITW, MWA, and Sisters in Crime. He lives in Boston and answers to a tuxedo cat named Munchkin.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
16 (53%)
4 stars
10 (33%)
3 stars
3 (10%)
2 stars
1 (3%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews
Profile Image for Laura Thomas.
1,576 reviews108 followers
April 4, 2024
There are several important ingredients that I feel are needed in a mystery. There’s the character’s. I need them to be quirky. To be genuine. You know…. flawed and such. And I need to connect with them. To see their faces in my mind. To almost recognize them as neighbors. or family or friends.

Then there’s the mystery itself. I like it to flow and not be too easily solved. I need several false trails and suspects.

A little romance, perhaps. Not so much the main focus, but I like to anticipate if it will become a thing.

Location or setting. I like to feel as if the author is showing me the place, like I’m being introduced to a character.

And any kind of critters are always a bonus. I love them and it’s such fun to have them be characters as well. To have their own quirks and silliness.

And if it’s part of a series I want that desire to continue. To want to see what happens to the main characters later on.

If I get all of that, I’m happy. And getting more is even better. The Big Lie gave me all of it. And even better. I hadn’t read the previous books and the author filled me in on enough backstory to help me make sense of things.

I received a complimentary copy. My review is voluntarily given.
Profile Image for Annarella.
14.4k reviews174 followers
March 17, 2024
Funny, entertaining, and gripping. A well plotted mystery that kept me hooked and turning pages.
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine
Profile Image for Bailey Jo.
155 reviews43 followers
Did Not Finish
July 25, 2025
Lots of people say "books are political"...yeah yeah yeah, anyways. This book was too political for me.
Profile Image for T.G. Wolff.
Author 21 books206 followers
August 5, 2024
The Big Lie is PI mystery. PI Shane Cleary is a popular guy. Everyone wants a favor from him. An MIA standard poodle, Latin tutoring for a mafioso’s niece, pro bono work for a grand larceny defense, and a background check as SOP for getting serious. It’s going to take the help of friends and enemies to keep all these balls in the air.

Bottom line: The Big Lie is for you if you like stories where the pacing keeps up with the PI’s fast talking.

Shane Cleary is juggling four jobs plus keeping off his girlfriend’s $% list. It’s a lot for anyone. One of the strengths of The Big Lie is the skill with which author Gabriel Valjan lets us know exactly where we are at all times. He distinctly draws the characters making it easy for readers to differentiate between the cases.

Shane as a character is well developed both with a full back history in Vietnam and with the Boston PD and a more recent history such as with this girlfriend, friends, cat, and answering service. He is a character readers can get behind, working from the moral high ground that lets him make hard and sometimes painful decisions.

The story is set in a colorful Boston. It is not set in modern time, but I could not find reference to a year. Based on Shane having (and hating) a beeper, his having been in Viet Nam and worked for Boston PD, and a reference to punter Ray Guy, it seems to be set late 1970s to early 1980s. Shane navigating Boston’s segregated Irish, Italian, Black, and Jewish communities adds a layer of complexity to his tasks that ups the stakes and heightens the entertainment. You can add the Boston PD hating Shane to the complications.

This is the 5th book in the Shane Cleary Mystery series. I have not read the previous four. This can be read as a stand-alone as the mysteries Shane signs up for do not seem to be carried over from previous books. Character carryover is managed well with backstory snippets that get us what we need to know without dragging down in synopsis.

When looking at the logic of the story lines and the role Shane has in resolving them, we have to look individually. Shane outsources the Latin tutoring and the background check, making his role more of a facilitator. The missing dog story had a strong, simple logic. Shane uses his talents with the missing dog case to get people beyond the fear of the dog’s owner to be helpful. There was one spot that had me raising an eyebrow but the resolution is good without being predictable.

The grand larceny case showed excellent detective skills and definitely would have died without Shane pushing at apparent dead ends. The logic of the criminal action is more complicated here. I ended up with a few questions about the setup, which happened before Shane was involved. The logic of Shane’s actions is strong. He does his job, providing the defense with what it needs to combat a lazy if not corrupt PD, then wipes his hands, leaving it to the lawyers to pick up the work of charging the guilty party.

Overall, The Big Lie, the 5th in the Shane Cleary Mysteries, was a highly enjoyable, entertaining read. Readers who prefer the fast pacing that comes with getting four stories in one book will keep the pages turning on this one.
Profile Image for Lynxie.
755 reviews81 followers
January 25, 2025
This is the first book by Gabriel Valjan that I've read, but I can assure you, it won't be the last.

Part gritty mobster drama, part PI detective mystery with a healthy dose of noir-esque prose, The Big Lie delivers witty one liners, historical facts and fiction woven into a robust story line that has you both chomping at the bit to find out what will happen next and wincing in solidarity with our slightly-rough-around-the-edges protagonist, Shane Cleary.

The writing was full-bodied and glorious to read, even when the subject matter was less than palatable. The multiple cases and storylines flowed well together and each of the supporting characters added nuanced levels of complication to Shane Cleary's life, even his long-time girlfriend and lawyer, Bonnie.

I loved how the cat Delilah was brought into the story (a testament to Gabriel's own experience being owned by a feline friend) it was believeable and added a lovely layer of realness to Shane's harder exterior life.

The ending left a little to be desired, only in so much that we got a whole wallop of information right at the end and very little time to turn it over. I'm not sure if this is unpacked in other Shane Cleary stories, I'll have to have a look and see if there's a reading order, to see which story might follow on from this one. I'd like to understand what Shane does with that information.

Overall, this was a solid book. The writing was a welcome relief from some of the less polished indies I've read lately and the story was an easy read. Definitely recommend this one for fans of mystery, Private Investigator or cop procedural type stories and if you just love a good mobster/mafia story this one hits on some of those themes too.

**Note: I was provided an electronic copy of this book via NetGalley**
Profile Image for James McCrone.
Author 5 books103 followers
March 14, 2024
The Big Lie, the latest Shane Cleary novel from Gabriel Valjan is smart, surprising and beautifully rendered. This is the fifth book in the series, and Valjan's keen eye for detail, strong characters and narrative control, shine through this tale. Cleary, an ex-Boston cop, now a PI, is that rare person, an honest man in a world of shadows, lies and crime. Fans of Valjan's Shane Cleary series (and I count myself as one!) know that things are complicated for Cleary. But as compelling as the unfolding plot is, there's immense satisfaction in the way he does the job and still finds his way through to something honorable.

The story begins when Southie's most dangerous criminal hires Cleary to find his lost dog. Cleary is willing to refuse the job, except Jimmy says that he has information about Cleary's father's death years earlier. But only if he finds the dog.

Everything screams he shouldn’t take the job, but Shane can’t resist Jimmy’s added ‘incentive.’ Add in some other favors he's asked to do, some rival gangsters, dirty cops and an overzealous DA, and you have the kind of tasty recipe only Valjan can bring to the table. The notion of "the big lie" looms throughout, touching on disparate aspects of the evolving case. And Shane can’t help but think his client just might kill him anyway after he finds the dog.

To say much more would be to spoil the fun. Highly recommended!

(I read an advance copy of The Big Lie via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review; and I was pleased to get an early look)
Profile Image for Joan.
4,556 reviews138 followers
March 15, 2024
Who knew that being asked to find a missing dog would lead to so much adventure. But then, since the dog was owned by a mob boss, adventure was sure to follow.

These PI novels featuring Shane Cleary are unique in that Shane blends a life of being an acquaintance of mob bosses, an ex-police officer who had alienated fellow police officers by being truthful, and the significant other of an attorney. That makes for a complicated and tightrope walking kind of life and it all comes together in this novel. Although this novel is down the line in the series, it reads pretty well on its own with enough back story included to make sense of the action.

Valjan's writing style is clear and entertaining. The pace of this novel is consistent as Shane gets into all kinds of trouble. We are taken into the murky world of mob influence, wondering of Shane will make it through in one piece. He is also involved preventing the railroading of a young black accused of theft. The two plot elements are woven together to make an engaging novel centered on the character of Shane as the driving force. The tight dialogue and relationship interactions he has with Bonnie are good additional aspects of the novel.

I recommend this novel to readers who would like an adventure into the underworld of Boston in the 1970s featuring a realistic and determined hero.

I received a complimentary egalley of this book through Partners in Crime Book Tours. My comments are an independent and honest review.
Profile Image for Novels Alive.
279 reviews8 followers
March 29, 2024
Some writers have a gift for taking any topic and captivating readers not only with the content but also with the style.

Gabriel Valjan is a perfect example. As a skilled mystery writer, he hits all the basic expectations with relatable characters, an interesting mystery to solve, plus plenty of adventures along the way. However, Valjean delivers an exceptional reading experience because of how he presents the story.

The Big Lie, the latest installment in the Shane Cleary Mystery series, is more than just another look into an investigator’s case files. It’s an immersive experience packed with cultural and literary references along with a dry sense of humor.

This time around, the erstwhile detective finds himself searching for a missing dog owned by a dangerous gangster, running a background check on a friend’s beau, and helping his lawyer girlfriend with a pro bono case.

The author sets the stage for the next installment as Shane discovers an unsettling lie from the past. How he handles that information and those responsible will likely play out in a future book. Note that these books can be read as standalones.

The Big Lie delivers a well-crafted mystery featuring the latest adventure for Shane Cleary as he navigates the criminal underbelly of Boston. ~ Amy for Novels Alive
Profile Image for dianas_books_cars_coffee.
516 reviews16 followers
March 25, 2024
This is the 5th book in the author's Shane Cleary series, but I read it as a standalone. I will definitely be reading the 6th since this one ended on a bit of a cliffhanger, and I need to know what happens.

Shane Cleary is a private investigator in Boston. His latest client happens to be one of Boston's most notorious criminals. He wants Shane to find his poodle, who suddenly disappeared from a grooming. Shane's not so sure about taking the job, but when Jimmy tells him he has information about his father's death and will only tell him if he finds the dog, Jimmy takes it.
Meanwhile, his lawyer girlfriend, Bonnie, is working on a pro bono case and needs some assistance. His friend Bill needs a background check, and Mafia Henchman Tony makes a rather odd request. Will Shane be able to get all this done and still find the dog? Does Jimmy really know something that will change Shane's life?

Set in Boston in the 1970s and told in the POV of Shane, there was a lot packed into this short book. It had me hooked from page 1 and kept me entertained throughout. The pacing was good, and it was action-packed with a lot of characters and moving parts. This book can definitely be read in one sitting. I really enjoyed this and would highly recommend it.
Profile Image for Stanley McShane.
Author 10 books59 followers
March 4, 2024
Read his full review on Rosepoint Publishing.

A beloved pet is missing. Tony Two-Times wants him back and orders our hero to find him. There will be no reward, just a ticket to stay alive. Finding a dog does not usually require a private detective but refusing Tony invites a visit six feet under. He has lost his beloved dog and wants the bitch back yesterday.

A mob leader or mafioso boss has many things in common. Denying their requests is not an option. Our hero finds that leads he feels may be fruitful were not. Meanwhile, the time is getting short and the dog cannot be found!

This story explores the underworld and the loyalties that are required to stay alive! Cleary, an ex-cop, is the subject of the mob bosses’ angst, and the dog better be found. The result is an exposé of the thinking within the mob. Very informative! 4.5 stars – CE Williams

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with the opportunity to read and review this book. These opinions are my own. 4.5 stars
Profile Image for Country Mama.
1,776 reviews87 followers
March 12, 2024
I have never read any of the authors previous work on the character in this book, so this was my first foray into the world of Shane Cleary. I really love well written mysteries and this was a great one folks!
Shane is trying to find a lost dog in this book as a PI. I loved the writing style of the author this is reminiscent of at noir book of the old mystery days of writing. The story is engaging to the readers as you read through the book as well. Especially since Shane is tasked with finding a gangster’s prized puppy dog! A black poodle with a spiked collar.
Shane usually investigates family law cases so this case on a missing dog is new and interesting to him and its not like he can say no😉Jimmy the gangster and Shane have a history and Shane does take the case, not voluntarily.
I loved Shane’s relationship with Bonnie also, this was relatable in the early days of my own relationship and how they interact and banter with each other. The author did a great job with writing that part of the story also. I loved seeing the 1970’s in the neighborhoods of Boston. I have never been to Boston and I love stories based in the past!
2,527 reviews5 followers
October 30, 2025
The author is a real name dropper, full of cultural innuendos, that you have to ponder to “get”. I was always the queen of trivia, especially about old Hollywood and literature, so I enjoyed figuring it out. Also, I am 70 so I was around for lots. There were a few that I needed help from Wikipedia. There are several plots going with people like, Tony and Jimmy, and I had some difficulty remembering who the bad guys were. Some of the bad guys were cops and there was nothing to stop them. The right wing of our country often forgets, or never bothered to “know” , that there is a REAL history to police brutality.

Shane is a smart guy, ex police, who did the right thing. Thank goodness he has Bonnie, his attorney and girlfriend, to save him. He finds Boo, the missing poodle, and saves one of the two brothers who committed the stupid crime. He saves the black kid who was set up for the jewel heist. He helps his friend find love. He also learns the truth about his father’s “suicide”. The reckoning must come later.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Elizabeth G.
361 reviews5 followers
April 12, 2026
A razor-sharp addition to one of the most underrated PI series currently running. Valjan's fifth Shane Cleary mystery opens with a premise that shouldn't work, a Southie gangster hiring Shane to find his stolen poodle named Boo, yet within pages you're hooked by the moral complexity and propulsive prose. The 1975 Boston setting feels lived-in rather than nostalgic, all grime and tribal loyalties and the constant threat of violence underlying everyday transactions. What distinguishes Valjan is his refusal to make Shane a standard tough guy: he's broke, he's conflicted about taking dirty money, his cat Delilah has better instincts than he does, and his girlfriend Bonnie the lawyer keeps him honest. The plot braids multiple cases with the confidence of a writer at the top of his game, and the dialogue crackles with wit that never undercuts the tension. SJ Rozan is right: this is noir that lingers. If Raymond Chandler were writing today, he'd be taking notes.
Profile Image for Mark Reisig.
108 reviews2 followers
June 2, 2026
The Big Lie is an exceptional blend of classic noir and modern crime fiction. Gabriel Valjan's Boston feels authentic and lived in. The protagonist, Shane Cleary, is smart, flawed, loyal, and often in over his head. What begins as the search for a gangster's missing dog unfolds into a much larger story about loyalty, corruption, friendship, and lies.

What impressed me most was Valjan's voice. The dialogue is sharp, the humor dry, and the characters memorable without feeling exaggerated. Like the best mysteries, the novel is not just about solving a case but about the people caught up in it. Fans of traditional private-eye fiction and character-driven mysteries will find much to enjoy as I did.
Profile Image for Matthew Cost.
Author 18 books49 followers
February 19, 2024
"The Big Lie" is a sweeping PI mystery that careens through the streets of Boston in the late '70s filled with larger than life characters and gritty backdrops. Shane Cleary is as tough as they come, his girlfriend, Bonnie, is as whip-smart as they come, and the plot zips with authenticity on every page. The neighborhoods of Boston are treated to an in-depth rambling of history that fascinated and enlightens on every page. Put both boots on and jump right into this book and then hold on for the ride.
Profile Image for Grace Koshida.
791 reviews15 followers
February 24, 2024
PI Shane Cleary's newest case involves finding Boo, a missing black poodle owned by Jimmy, Southie’s most dangerous criminal. Meanwhile, Shane's lawyer girlfriend Bonnie asks for his help on a pro bono case involving a B&E jewel theft & a black teenaged suspect.

Both cases prove to be more treacherous & full of deceit thanks to some brutal encounters with Boston cops. In the end, Jimmy reveals the truth behind "the big lie" that has haunted Cleary's life.
Another fine mystery filled with pathos, humor, sarcasm & a glimpse into life in different 1970s Boston neighborhoods.

I received a digital ARC from Netgalley and Level Best Books. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Elaine .
1,146 reviews66 followers
March 30, 2024
It all begins with looking for a dog
But it's one big mystery,

One that keeps you involved,
It's intriguing. I must say.

A story like no other,


This one will keep you turning the pages.
The author did an exceptional job.


the cover of the book is exquisite. I love it. I myself am a dog Lover. 🐾🐾
1,299 reviews30 followers
February 9, 2024
I love the writing style and the language, but I don't like "historical" (1970s?) books. I do like the speed, so all in all this is a very entertaining book.
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews