I think that this book suffers from an identity crisis and I believe that may be why it has fallen into obscurity. For the first half of the book I kept wondering to myself why...why has this book been out of print for so long? It's lovely! And then it took a turn. It went from a "Harry Potter"-like story with magical gadgets that do magical things to.... a lovers quarrel and a series of matchmaking, all somehow healed by a 9-year old, yes, using magic but, not in such a believable way. I still liked it enough...but my 6-year old son was very bored. That is why I say it has a bit of an identity issue...the premise sets it up for being a story for young children (magic shop etc), but then it goes into relationship issues as I mentioned above, which I think would be more interesting for young adults. It was nice to read a story set on New Years Eve in New York City...