As an American Jew who has pretty much grown up with a Jewish perspective on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, this book was a major eye-opener. The author is discredited by many as fervently anti-Zionist. If your litmus test is whether a writer is critical of Israel, then I guess he is.
The colonial conquest of Palestine, by Israel, supported strongly by the US, is hard to deny. The myth of tiny Israel being overwhelmed by surrounding Arab countries bent on its destruction (including terror groups like Fatah and Hamas) is undeniable. But we ignore that Israel has enormous military advantages over its foes (military hardware, munitions, fire-power). And in every clash or full-scale war, Israel’s military might has proven overwhelmingly powerful.
At the time of the Balfour Declaration in 1916, Palestine was 95% Palestinian (indigenous). These second-class citizens have either fled to other countries or been pushed into Gaza and the West Bank and they have few rights. Settlements continue to grow. As an American, it’s hard to miss the similarities between our treatment of Native Americans and Israel’s treatment of Palestinians.
We call Israel a democracy that espouses equality?
The 10/7 massacre of more than 1,200 Israeli Jews by Hamas is nothing short of horrific and completely unconscionable.
But most people are unaware of the many massacres of Palestinian innocent civilians from the 1930’s to the present either directly or indirectly engineered by the military.
Khalili is no fan of Hamas, the PLO, or Fatah. Khalili sees no place for these terror groups in the future of Palestinians. Nor does he give a pass to Israel’s neighbors. He advocates for Palestinians to give up violence in return for equal rights in a two state solution where all 10 million Jews and Palestinian have equal rights. Easier said than done, obviously, for many reasons.
There is much more packed in this brilliant book.
Unfortunately, it will fall on deaf ears among those who long ago decided that supporting Israel’a policies blindingly is the only course.
I urge you to set aside all your pre-conceived notions and wade into this book. It will make you feel very uncomfortable if you are, like me, a supporter of an Israeli state.