Polish-Nigerian Remi Adekoya's 'It's Not About Whiteness, It's About Wealth' is a welcome addition to the literature on race.
Adekoya is a political scientist living in England, and his mixed-race background, along with his experience of having actually lived in Nigeria and Poland before settling in England, provide a powerfully pragmatic tonic for overheated Western conversations about race.
He opens this short, concise and impactful book with a story about an experiment. Specifically, a re-staging of a classic experiment, in which a child is presented with pictures of people - black, white or multiracial - and asked to indicate which people they 'liked'.
The preference shown by children for white people has been long-documented, but this particular study was staged in South Africa - 80% black, 9% white- yet the results were the same.
And herein lies the key insight of Adekoya's work - the preference is not a result of racial bias but rather indicates the experimental subjects' preference for status. The children liked the affluent - regardless of race.
Adekoya grew up in Nigeria, living without the material advantages of the Western world, among people with no real prospect for improving their lot, financially. As Adekoya notes early on, 'a race debate not embedded in detailed material realities is intellectual masturbation'. (p. 8)
Adekoya offers plenty of evidence to support his claims. His is an international take on race relations, and once the 'not-elite' countries of the world are added to the discussion, the power of money is fully revealed. Western stances on race relations put race first because they can AFFORD TO.
Money being more significant than race to poor Africans is an imminently reasonable proposition. As he notes, 'progressive Westerners not liking such worldviews is not going to stop others having them'.
There is a fundamental imbalance between the emigrant (generally more advantaged than the people left behind) and the immigrant (who typically moves to a world in which others are wealthier). And yet the flow of traffic remains the same - people leave in search or more, materially speaking.
Adekoya explores whether sometimes what people perceive as racism is more a simple difference in norms - giving the example of a middle-aged black Nigerian in London who perceives disrespect as racism rather than a different view of age hierarchies - confirmation bias. It's is his own diversity that allows him to make contentious claims such as this, a fact he notes himself.
Adekoya goes on to explain why this narrative is so sticky, exploring how perceived 'competence', as demonstrated by wealth, is a better indicator than race for value judgements about which group is 'better'.
This and other psychological tendencies prime us for quick, potentially biased judgements as a species, but our 'knowledge of how race works is usually derived from the writings of one or other prominent US-based scholar whose perspectives on the issue are primarily shaped the specific American context they inhabit'. (p. 77)
Gender is another subject for exploration. Controversially, perhaps, Adekoya argues 'it is now women who are increasingly setting the tone for how we should speak and act in the public sphere'. He concludes that DEI is so pervasive because 'women dominate the upper echelons of Human Resource departments'. (p. 137)
Western anti-racists are frequent targets for criticism here, and Adekoya lands a body blow when he writes 'the reason many antiracists focus on moral arguments is because they find the starkness of the material gaps to daunting'. (p. 162). Once again, 'it's about wealth'. 'For most people of colour in this world, the benefits of the moral atmosphere around race in Britain and America amount to zero'. (p. 163)
Adekoya concludes with a chapter arguing that empowering Africa and Africans is the way forward. The continent will soon constitute a quarter of the world's population, and their ruling classes need to start enabling African potential.
Consider me convinced. Published in 2023, this is one of the most relevant texts on race I could currently recomment, and I will be following Adekoya from now on.
BOOK GIVEAWAY - I accidentally ordered two copies of this from Amazon, and decided to keep both. So the first person who asks me for a copy gets one free! I'd love to have someone to talk to about this.