Ivy, Jilly, friends and pets head to Thistledown for the Rescue Mafia's Halloween dog adoption fundraising event. In spite of hating Halloween, Ivy would do anything to help rescue, even assist with a haunted house. When a contestant in the competition, Olive, offers up her newly purchased home because she thinks it is literally haunted, Ivy is certain there must be a logical explanation. An exterminator didn't find any critters but unfortunately for Olive, Percy finds old bones in the pumpkin patch! IS her house haunted after all or is there a logical explanation? With Asher taking the lead in the case, Ivy is determined to figure this one out and help whatever critters or ghosts move along and silently assist her big brother. Olive, meanwhile, is eager to return the house because the bones were not disclosed on the sales agreement! The realtor for the previous owners won't budge and Olive is deeply upset. With the help of a little mouse, Ivy uncovers a clue that may lead to the identity of the bones and answers to a long held mystery. A theft, an argument and murder in present day may or may not be tied to those old bones and the long ago mystery.
I really enjoyed catching up with Ivy and everyone even though this adventure took them off the farm. It's an unconventional story with the main mystery being the bones and the murder not happening until 75% into the book. It wasn't too hard to figure out who the present day murderer was but the identity of the bones was a surprise and not what I was thinking. This story only hints at the paranormal and even though Ivy calls in Janelle and Bixby to be sure, there's no sign of any ghosts, thank goodness. I happen to like Halloween (not the creepy stuff though) and liked the atmosphere of this book. I did miss the farm animals but there's plenty of Keats and Percy plus a new friend, and Keats's sister Frost to keep me satisfied.
I just love Ivy! I relate to her love for animals and her deep bond with Keats is very special. She makes a new animal companion friend, proving her bond isn't just with Keats. She can actually understand all animals as she tries to help them. While Jilly is a ride or die friend and can show a steely resolve when needed, she's uneasy because she hates Halloween. Her family has been labeled with the term "witch" in a derogatory way and even though they do seem to have a streak of magical powers, Jilly chooses to ignore it and be normal since the magic skipped her. The others embrace their weirdness and let their freak flags fly! Edna is a hoot and Gertie is right there with her as Edna's ride or die (plus Gertie's trusty rifle, Minnie).
Asher is smarter than he looks and of course Kellan is a phone call away and he knows Ivy too well! It must be hard to have your fiancé be not only the police chief and your big brother's boss but also your brother's BFF and your high school boyfriend! Ivy can't get away with anything but she certainly tries. Asher must clue in Officer Wiebe because Wiebe may be wet behind the ears but he's no fool.
Ivy has a new ride or die friend, Thelma Tilrow, Thistledown’s librarian. She's an older woman, near retirement age but tough as nails. Like Edna and Gertie, she seems to age in reverse. She's capable of handling adventures with Ivy and Keats. She's a little caustic and gruff, like Edna, but a good friend. I do love Cori and relate a lot to her but she's so dramatic! She's going way overboard. While I do appreciate and understand wanting to place the dogs in good homes, her rules are way beyond strict and making people jump through hoops- almost literally - just to adopt a dog is ridiculous, especially since some of the contestants are older. Good thing Bridget's more equable temperament and her beloved Beau even out Cori and choose good homes for the dogs or I don't think any of them would be adopted.
We meet some new characters here that may or may not be friendly. Olive and Kestra Redding are sisters who could not be more different. They were raised apart and have different feelings about it. It sounds like they each think the grass was greener on the other side of the fence. Kestra is impulsive, hot headed and open. She's too perky and Cori doesn't like that. Cori also doesn't like Olive too much because Olive is divorced, insecure and not yet stable. Olive is stressed out because the house she bought for a steal seems to be too good to be true. Of course there are bones in the pumpkin patch! Of course it's haunted! Olive is terrified and on edge. I don't blame her for being freaked out by bones but the haunting has a logical explanation I'm sure. Nigel Byrd is another rescue contestant. He's quiet, mild mannered and seems nice. He may have a crush on Olive. I think I can guess his profession. He gives off a certain vibe. Millicent the mouse is absolutely adorable and very sweet. Ivy really bonds with her, much to the chagrin of Kellan!
In the not so friendly category is Glennis Tanner, a real estate mogul whose family founded Thistledown. She's sneaky and she's a shark. She won't allow Olive to return the house. She claims her clients had no knowledge of the noises in the attic let alone bones in the yard. I'm not sure she's telling the truth since she sold the house for them for a song. That doesn't sound like something someone so high powered would do. Olive's agent, Paige Ogilvy, seems a little nicer, although she copies Glennis's look which is creepy. Paige stands up for Olive and tries to get Olive out of the sale. While the two agents are at loggerheads professionally, they may be friends or in cahoots personally. The same goes for Blenda Mushing, the so-called psychic. She's rude, horrible and mean to Ivy and friends. She doesn't improve upon getting to know her better and she may be personally friendly or in cahoots with the real estate agents. I think they have a deal. They sell old houses low to unsuspecting clients and then when the old bones of the house make noises and unsettle the new owners, Blenda swoops in with her sage and smudging and crystals, for a profit, of course. I'm thinking the three of them have some kind of a deal. There's no way two haunted houses were sold in a short period of time! Glennis's clients, the Sprockets, high tailed it out of town ASAP but now they're back for Halloween. They seems shifty to me, especially him. She, at least, is open if not entirely honest. They're very good customers of Blenda's so I suspect they DID know about the "haunting."
The bones may belong to a Eliza Ormiston and Alonzo Pyle, Thistledown's own Romeo & Juliet. Their families were at odds forever and the young couple eloped and disappeared without a trace. I think the husband killed his wife and then disappeared. He made it look like they eloped together and she was still alive afterwards. Or Eliza's father killed them. He was a stern man and mayor but no one think he was a killer because he appeared to be grieving. Alonzo Pyle, Sr. on the other hand, ran the post office and general store but also the crime.
Vikki Tickle. A local party planner, just happens to be Eliza's sister and still living near Thistledown. She's a great character! A real character in every sense. She loves animals, embraces eccentricity and has a lively, intelligent brain she continues to try to use even after her body has started to break down. She loved her older sister and always wondered what happened to Eliza and therefore is eager to help with the investigation. While Ivy and Jilly think Vikki is their kind of people, I'm not sure I totally trust her.
This was another fun mystery. It may or may not set up a future adventure or spin-off series but it doesn't end on a cliffhanger making me want to read the next one right now but I already started it so... I'm totally addicted to this series.