Ian Hogbin belongs to anthropology's heroic age. He was a member of the brilliant between-the-wars generation that included Raymond Firth, Reo Fortune, Margaret Mead, Gregory Bateson, and Hortense Powdermaker, all of whom pioneered modern field research in the insular South Pacific. The Island of Menstruating Men was a path-breaking exploration of gender in Wogeo when first published. Today it remains an important full-length study of a Melanesian religion, examining it in relation to other facets of culture-mythology, beliefs about illness and death, growth and maturity, magic, social structure, and morality. It is an articulate, insightful examination of the meaning of tradition and of the integration of culture. It is also a captivating account of ethnocentrism and the Wogeo's justification for it, exemplifying, in miniature, what appears to be one of the great problems of the human species.
I had to read this for an anthropology course. While fairly dense in content, I believe it provides an amazing insight into the inner workings and culture of a group of people most people will never know. It was interesting to see the dichotomy of gender roles and how each had their own forms of rituals.
culturally interesting but the assumptions made in the observations irked me. i suppose i should keep in mind that the author visited New Guinea back in the thirties but still...