Ridiculously Simplified Synopsis for Readers Short on Time: “Hellraiser” is the most important and dangerous book of our time because it dares to unmask the horrifying truth of some of the darkest days of our nation’s history that is currently in the process of repeating itself. If you read one book this year, let it be this one. And then raise hell.
Okay-for those that have a little more time; here is my detailed review:
(Note: My actual star rating for this historical novel is 4 ½ stars. The reason for this, as well as why I decided to round up instead of down is explained at the end of this review).
First and foremost; if you are a reader that is looking for a 100% accurate long, drawn-out history of the labor movement during the beginning of the Industrial revolution complete with detailed accounts of every one of the battles and strikes that took place, you won't find that here. If; however, you are a reader that is looking for a realistic portrayal of one of the most important and well-respected union organizers in this nation's history, Mother Jones, with historically accurate summaries of the most impressionable battles and strikes as witnessed from her unique perspective, then you need look no further.
In full disclosure, I am an admirer of Mother Mary Harris Jones and I have studied her life and legacy extensively. I have read nearly every historical account of Mother Jones I’ve been able to get my hands on; therefore, when I inadvertently stumbled upon “Hellraiser” by Jerry Ash, a novel that purported to capture the ‘true spirit’ of Mother Jones, I was immediately intrigued; yet ultimately skeptical. While I may be an admirer of Mother Jones, that also means I have higher than normal expectations.
Many historical tomes about Mother Jones are written in such a way that they dampen her spirit; I’m not certain whether it’s to prevent ‘offense’ or because her actions are historically viewed as more important than her spirit that drove them. As a result, I was determined to find out for myself if this author actually managed to portray Mother Jones as she truly was; bull-headed, fearless, endlessly motivated, strong, fiercely independent, manipulative when she had to be, honest when she knew to be, a force to be reckoned with and downright unladylike according to society’s standards during that time period; roughly from the mid 1800’s through the first few decades of the 1900’s.
So, skepticism intact and expectations very high; I began reading “Hellraiser”, a novel of historical fiction told through first person narrative…through Mother Jones herself. What started out as a book quickly became an experience. In the author’s Preface, Ash boldly makes this claim, “Telling the story through Mother Jones required me to get inside her skin, climb inside her body, see through her eyes, think through her mind, [and] feel through her heart…” And he does, with stunning results. If I didn’t know better, this novel reads as if the spirit of Mother Jones herself uses author Jerry Ash as a vessel and while in full control of his faculties, writes her personal account and, pleased with the results, goes on her merry way!
The labor struggles, the strikes, the marches, the corruption, the violent battles, horrid living conditions, starvation and the seemingly infinite hardships endured during the mass labor uprisings across the country, for living wages and safer working conditions at the start of the Industrial Revolution, are present in this novel and are accurately and historically portrayed as much as possible. As the focus of this book is the spirit of Mother Jones herself; the author successfully manages to balance historical accuracy with very plausible fiction; specifically, crafting the dialog and innermost thoughts of Mother Jones herself. The battles, marches, strikes and organizing that she leads and participates in are not drawn out with lengthy details. That's what the history tomes are for. As readers we are given as much explanation as is necessary before Mother Jones takes off for her next stop as she makes her way across the country and across national borders. Not once does this novel feel rushed or incomplete. The historical accounts contain enough description that the reader can `see' what is happening as well as truly `feel' the despair, pain, bitter cold, sickness, hopelessness and fatigue.
The character of Mother Jones; however, from the way she presents herself in public to her private thoughts during her rare quiet moments is captured and written with a level of intensity, depth, raw emotion and such a fierce sense of self that I still cannot believe that this novel wasn't written by Mother Jones herself! Her dialogue, conversations (and demands and ultimatums) with friends and foes, speeches at various labor camps unrecorded by the press, as well as her private thoughts, are mostly fiction although they can easily be read as very plausible discourse.
Mary Harris, before she became known as Mother Jones was a strong but somewhat reserved woman who was a licensed Teacher as well as a skilled Dressmaker. After she relocates to Memphis it was there that she meets and marries George Jones. He was an Iron Molder and union organizer; Mary Harris Jones was often at his side to assist with organizing laborers. Together they had 4 children and were very much in love; partners in life, matters of the heart, and fighting for a just cause. When tragedy strikes, Mary Harris Jones moves to Chicago and continues the work of her late husband. She lacks a bit of self-confidence and tends to apologize if she accidentally ‘cusses’ during a union meeting. From there, the reader watches her transform from Mary Harris Jones into Mother Jones as the years pass by. So, not only does the author capture the spirit of Mother Jones; he initially was able to personalize Mary Harris Jones and allow the reader to watch her seamlessly transition into Mother Jones as she becomes even more involved with assisting and organizing laborers. How Jerry Ash managed to accomplish such an extraordinary feat with such a limited amount of ‘personal’ material available to reference is nothing short of remarkable literary skill.
As for any additional generic particulars without risking a trip into spoiler territory; the novel is well-edited (pet peeve of mine), all plots and subplots are resolved with no loose ends, and the storyline flows along smoothly and steadily. Most of the characters we meet throughout this novel truly are a part of history while others (not many) are fictional in order to fill-in pieces of information that are missing from historical archives. All characters are well developed with all their assets, faults, and quirks. They contribute even more depth to the overall historical timeline and I found myself truly caring about what lies in store for them. While this novel focuses on a very difficult, depressing and serious subject matter; some of the boldest and wittiest actions taken by Mother Jones literally had me laughing out-loud in a few places which helps lighten the mood. There is also an overwhelming sense of hope woven through the pages; however, it is subtle and stays as true to historical accuracy as possible.
Without giving anything away that isn’t already included in the book description, the last chapter focuses on present day; specifically, the decline of the American economy, a rapidly rising poverty rate, full-time workers not being able to get by with lower and lower wages, and so on. I praise the author for describing the history of the labor movement in the past as well as the beginning of an eerily similar situation developing in the present. He manages to do this all without bias. Author Jerry Ash has not written a politically divisive novel; neither political party nor their specific policies are mentioned in this book, simply the facts of both then and now. This makes for a book everyone can and should read without any need for mud-slinging or playing the blame game.
The very last chapter is also where my minor criticism lies and why I deducted ½ a star from my 5 star rating. Jerry Ash, who brought to life the spirit of Mother Jones, continues to use her voice to discuss and compare past and present day. This is where the novel becomes a bit problematic. I believe it is a good idea and I also believe that the information in the last chapter is vital to bring the novel full circle. In doing so; however, the voice of Mother Jones becomes muddled and the voice of the author begins to show through. It doesn't flow as well with the rest of the book and has, in sections, a choppy feel to it. A lot has changed since Mother Jones died in 1930; yet she is explaining and comparing modern day policies and practices that would be very foreign to her. As one example, Mother Jones jumps right in and begins explaining minimum wage and compares it to poverty-wages and the cycle of poverty in the past; however, the first minimum wage law in the U.S. did not go into affect until eight (8) years after her death.
While there are unarguable parallels between then and now, too much of the political landscape has changed for her voice to continue flowing as smoothly from the past into the present. Perhaps her voice would have come through clearer if the author had written in the differences she notices right away and we learn with her as she struggles to understand the changes (as applicable to the subject matter of course) along with recognizing what hasn't changed and the obvious similarities between then and now. Another approach could have been to not have Mother Jones as the voice for current day events at all; rather an "Author's Afterword," which would have also eased the transition. As it stands, the voice of Mother Jones lost cohesion in places throughout the last chapter. I do not find this a big enough issue to detract more than a ½ star because the `message' is still there, and her voice does still shine through in some sections. Honestly, I may not have noticed the difference in dialog in the last chapter to the degree that I did, had it not been for how strong her voice resonates throughout the rest of the novel.
My final thoughts about “Hellraiser:” This is a dangerous book as well as an important one. It serves as a reminder of all the hundreds upon hundreds of thousands of people who endured great hardship, unfathomable sacrifice and even gave their lives so that future generations would be treated fairly in the workplace and overall, have more opportunities in life. Rights, once earned, must be guarded and fought for in order to maintain them. Jerry Ash has captured the warrior spirit of Mother Jones; a spirit that will jump off the pages and right into reader’s hearts. This novel certainly had an affect on me. It is my hope that this novel will serve as an awakening and jump-start the ‘Hellraiser’ in all of us. It’s time. RAISE HELL. As Mother Jones often said, “I am not afraid of the pen, the scaffold or the sword. I will tell the truth wherever I please.”
Rating Scale: So why did I round up from 4 ½ stars and not down? That’s where my rating system comes in; I’ve learned over time that it differs quite a bit from how others rate books so I have listed it below. 4 stars is the highest review I usually give and goes to absolutely perfect novels. I am very picky with my 5 star ratings. I reserve 5 star reviews only for VERY RARE books that stay with me after I’ve read them and/or impact me in a lasting way. This book did both. I always like to wait a few days after I’ve read a novel to see if I still find myself thinking about it. “Hellraiser” has not let go of me since I completed it and I don’t foresee it leaving my thoughts any time soon.
My rating system
1 star: absolutely terrible; the worst of the worst
2 stars: has potential but needs work in some major areas
3 stars: enjoyable and entertaining; an average yet solid read
4 stars: near-perfect, very well-written, one I highly recommend and the highest rating I usually give
5 stars: only given to those VERY RARE novels that have staying power; one that is so powerful that I find myself thinking about it long after I've finished it.
*In full disclosure with FTC guidelines, I received a free copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review. I do not know the author personally nor did the receipt of this book impact or alter my review in any way.*
*Edited to tighten-up my review and remove some errors and repetitive sentences.*