Who "speaks" to us in The Sorcerer's Apprentice, in Wagner's operas, in a Mahler symphony? In asking this question, Carolyn Abbate opens nineteenth-century operas and instrumental works to new interpretations as she explores the voices projected by music. The nineteenth-century metaphor of music that "sings" is thus reanimated in a new context, and Abbate proposes interpretive strategies that "de-center" music criticism, that seek the polyphony and dialogism of music, and that celebrate musical gestures often marginalized by conventional music analysis.
Very vividly written, which is helpful when the subject matter is rather dense. An easier read than many musicology books, though sometimes I did find myself wishing that Abbate would get to the point a little faster.
Challenging to get through, but well worth the effort. Not the densest musicology I've had to traverse (and I won't say whose has been), but this is meaty. The perspective is unique, and valuable.