Gale Project #4
Updated review, 1/2026:
Although I THINK I understood a bit more of what was going on this time around (perhaps because I read it quicker, so facts stayed in my head better), I still was a mite overwhelmed by the sheer number of characters to keep straight - although Evan would, I suppose, be considered the main protagonist, there are at LEAST a dozen other major characters and probably two or three times as many minor ones.
The fact this is really a modern gloss on Trollope became more apparent this time around, and though I didn't find it 'hilarious' as the synopsis indicates, the humor did come more to the fore. There are still quite a number of things I remain unsure about, but I think that is probably intentional - there are several 'dream sequences', as well as a touch of magic realism or more likely mysticism, which I normally don't cotton to, but I more or less accepted it here and let the vagaries go.
Interesting that back 9 years ago I entertained the notion of perhaps reading ALL of Gale - and that IS precisely what I am currently embarked upon!
OG Review:
4.5 rounded down
My only previous experience of Gale's novels is his most recent, 'A Place Called Winter', which I really loved. This, Gale's 4th book from way back in 1988, couldn't have been more different, but I was almost equally enchanted. A modern gloss on Trollope (although Stella Gibson and E. F. Benson have also been invoked as possible influences), it is a fun and funny tale, with a multitude of eccentric characters inhabiting a quaint English town called Barrowcester (pronounced 'Brewster'). My major qualm is that there are perhaps TOO many characters, and I had a bit of difficulty keeping them straight all through the long haul.
Also, there were a LOT of issues that were so obliquely resolved that I am none too sure I QUITE 'got it': the entire sub-plot surrounding Dawn Harper trying to summon her 'missing' daughter Sasha with Satanic incantations; the white doves arising from the tomb of Saint Boniface and the possible angelic bones therein; what really happened to Evan's manuscript, etc. But I look forward to reading more, indeed, maybe all of Gale's back catalog, on the basis of the two I've now read.
PS: the odd title refers, not as I supposed, to a war machine, but to Mrs. Gibbons' erroneous supposition that she was incorrectly toilet trained, and that everyone but her uses a public lavatory 'facing the (water) tank', rather than the door. :-)
My sincere thanks to Netgalley and Open Road Media for the free reading copy in exchange for this honest review.