Architecture and the Crisis of Modern Science

by Alberto Pérez-Gómez

This important book, which won the 1984 Alice Davis Hitchcock Award, traces the process by which the mystical and numerological grounds for the use of number and geometry in building gave way to the more functional and technical ones that prevail in architectural theory and practice today. Between the late Renaissance and the early nineteenth century, the ancient arts of architecture were being profoundly transformed by the scientific revolution. This important book, which won the 1984 Alice Davis Hitchcock Award, traces the process by which the mystical and numerological grounds for the use of number and geometry in building gave way to the more functional and technical ones that prevail in architectural theory and practice today. Throughout, it relates the major architectural treatises of successive generations to the larger culture and the writings of philosophers, mathematicians, scientists, and engineers. The book leads the reader through the controversy that was generated by Claude Perrault in the seventeenth century. His writings began to cast doubt on the absolute aesthetic value of the classical orders and the "perfect" proportions that were architecture's legacy from Pythagorean times. Thus the once immutable "invisible" system lost its special status forever. The book focuses in particular on eighteenth-century developments in the science of mechanics and emerging techniques in structural analysis which slowly entered the architectural treatises and found their way into practice, often by way of civil and military engineers. And by the nineteenth century, the book notes, even architectural rendering and drawing were radically changed through the introduction of new descriptive and projective geometries. Tracing these fundamental changes in architectural intentions, Pérez-Gómez challenges many popular misconceptions about the theory and history of modern architecture. At the same time, he suggests an intangible loss, that of a culture's power to express through a building its total mathematical, mystical, and magical world-view.

Genres: Architecture, History

424 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1983

Reviews

[Joseph M. · Rating 4 out of 5]

Good scholarship, could also be titled "Modern science and the crisis of architecture"
Will drop some quotes later. It introduced me to a lot of authors and interesting history I didn't know about. Great piece of writing.

[John Trefry · Rating 4 out of 5]

A very readable history, but not making much of an argument like a Robin Evans text might be seen to.

[Geoffrey Baddams · Rating 5 out of 5]

A fantastic exploration of the influence of science and technology on architecture circa 1500-1850 and the resulting loss of symbolisation.

[mahatmanto · Rating 4 out of 5]

di sini ada uraian gemilang mengenai relasi geometri, sains modern dan arsitektur. bagaimana geometri sudah dibelokkan oleh modernitas [sudilah melihat juga tulisan huserl tentang 'origin of geometry', yang merangsang derrida untuk menulis buku 'introduction'nya].

buku ini lama saya cari-cari, dan baca hanya fotokopinya doang. untunglah beberapa minggu lalu dapet yang 'used'. lumayanlah...