The one thing that I’m sure everyone agrees upon is that Greg is a freaking awesome guy. I’m not a big fan of GFY stories, but if they all had a character like Gregory, I’d easily become one.
So, what makes Gregory so amazing? It’s not his golden blond hair, his warm brown eyes or his sexy body. Well, those too, but it’s more than that. It’s his personality and the way he deals with problems and unexpected feelings.
One day at the beach he meets Charlie and the two of them start being friends, despite Charlie’s insecurities. Greg has always considered himself straight, but after meeting Charlie he starts having unexpected feelings for him and begins to wonder if it can be more than friendship between them. What’s great about Greg is that he doesn’t panic, he’s not overly angsty, he’s not trying to sleep with a woman to prove to himself that he’s straight, he doesn’t drink himself into oblivion, doesn’t pick fights in bars, doesn’t punch walls or random strangers. He’s not mad at himself. He’s just trying to understand what’s happening to him. And when he finally knows what he wants he decides to fight for it at all costs.
Most of the drama comes from Charlie, who’s still recovering – physically and mentally – from the fact that his cheating ex-boyfriend, being a sick fuck, tried to kill him by setting the house on fire. He lost his job, his friends, his trust in people. He’s become a recluse. And then came Greg, caring and sweet, constantly saying how Charlie’s injuries make no difference to him, telling Charlie how sexy and incredible he is.
I loved how after Thanksgiving, Greg gets ready to see Charlie after being apart for a week, carefully choosing his clothes, feeling nervous like a teenager, unsure of what will happen next. I also loved the dirty bed talk.
What I didn’t like was the way sexuality is perceived. The author seems to see sexuality in black and white, but there’s whole Kinsey scale and to me Greg appeared to be in the grey area. A Kinsey 1 to be precise - predominantly heterosexual, only incidentally homosexual. He’s always been attracted to women, he almost married one, and then he meets Charlie and falls in love with him. This doesn’t annihilate his past, though. He can’t say in a definite voice “I’m gay.” Being in love with a guy doesn’t automatically mean being gay.
Besides that, I was slightly annoyed by all the sex in the beginning of their relationship (listen to me, complaining about too much sex!). It felt a little gratuitous and it could have been easily resolved by focusing on other things than their relationship. At some point Charlie and Greg have a fight and stay apart for four days, but those four days are only two pages in the book. It wasn’t enough for me too feel their pain and to wish for them to get back together. I would also have liked to see the Christmas dinner. It would have been a great opportunity for some secondary character development.
All in all, it’s a great book and because I love Greg so much I’ll give it 4 stars.