1st out of 30 books
—
64 voters
Forgotten Country
by
Catherine Chung (Goodreads Author)
A Booklist Top 10 First Novels of 2012 pick
A Bookpage Best Books of 2012 pick
On the night Janie waits for her sister, Hannah, to be born, her grandmother tells her a story: Since the Japanese occupation of Korea, their family has lost a daughter in every generation, so Janie is charged with keeping Hannah safe. As time passes, Janie hears more stories, while facts remain...more
A Bookpage Best Books of 2012 pick
On the night Janie waits for her sister, Hannah, to be born, her grandmother tells her a story: Since the Japanese occupation of Korea, their family has lost a daughter in every generation, so Janie is charged with keeping Hannah safe. As time passes, Janie hears more stories, while facts remain...more
Hardcover, 296 pages
Published
March 1st 2012
by Riverhead Hardcover
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Disclaimer: I received a free review copy from LibraryThing's Early Reviewer Program
I found this book extremely well-written, but I never really connected with it except on a very superficial level. Janie, the narrator, was very sympathetic but not very empathetic. She was very... flat. Her emotions and motivations never shone through the story. Hannah, her sister, was this great mysterious void, but once she showed up in the plot again shrank into the background.
Throughout the book, I wanted m...more
I found this book extremely well-written, but I never really connected with it except on a very superficial level. Janie, the narrator, was very sympathetic but not very empathetic. She was very... flat. Her emotions and motivations never shone through the story. Hannah, her sister, was this great mysterious void, but once she showed up in the plot again shrank into the background.
Throughout the book, I wanted m...more
I received this book from a goodreads giveaway;
I was under the impression that this book was going to be about Janie's search for her younger sister, which it isn't really.
Instead, I was met with a young Korean-American woman, who reminisced about her times as a childhood and other family stories. (I am secretly grateful it wasn't a mystery novel after all.)
Janie's devotion to her heritage and family is tested, however its not really a book about how she came out stronger or better or smarter,...more
I was under the impression that this book was going to be about Janie's search for her younger sister, which it isn't really.
Instead, I was met with a young Korean-American woman, who reminisced about her times as a childhood and other family stories. (I am secretly grateful it wasn't a mystery novel after all.)
Janie's devotion to her heritage and family is tested, however its not really a book about how she came out stronger or better or smarter,...more
From the first chapter alone, it was clear that this book was going to be tremendous. I could not wait for it to come out. And, luckily, I didn't have to. I just finished a galley copy, and it is fantastic.
The writing reminded me of aspects of both Shaker furniture and Ishiguro's best works---it was perfectly crafted, dealing with big themes in an understated and unadorned but rich and beautiful manner. And the characters broke my heart in the best way possible.
The writing reminded me of aspects of both Shaker furniture and Ishiguro's best works---it was perfectly crafted, dealing with big themes in an understated and unadorned but rich and beautiful manner. And the characters broke my heart in the best way possible.
Unfortunately, the summary doesn't reflect what the book was really about; it plays up a mystery that doesn't even exist. I'd say a more accurate description would be a family struggling to regain connections when the father is diagnosed with terminal cancer. While I would expect a book that depicts a main character dying of cancer to be tremendously sad (which it was), there were several other unrelated stories that added to the overall bleak feeling I had when I finished the book.
Janie, the n...more
Janie, the n...more
This book is tough. It's a very real and gritty portrayal of what, at first I didn't think was going to be a book about cancer, but it wound up being one. It was hard to read, but I think it was very realistically portrayed. I'm not sure there was as much of a resolution to the family dynamics as I would have liked. It seemed like there were some periphery issues that bubbled to the surface and then were dropped. The issue of the sister's disappearance, which seems to be the focus at the beginni...more
An okay book about typical Asian family dynamics and the struggle between independence in a country founded on it and obedience, the cornerstone of Asian culture. There is the good sister who does as she is told, studies what is expected of her, and stays home to care for an ill father and help her parents return to Korea, the old country they escaped to avoid political persecution, all the while the obedient sister questioning the reasons she feels beholden to her family and the pleasure and sa...more
This book was amazing. It really opens your eyes to another culture and how someone moving to the United States from another country can be treated differently. The love of family or being a member of a close group can make you stronger or pull you apart when you are in a difficult situation.
The main character Janie is trying to get her doctorate in math. She was born in Korea and was transplanted to Michigan with her mother father and sister. The books starts out with Janie's sister Hannah disa...more
The main character Janie is trying to get her doctorate in math. She was born in Korea and was transplanted to Michigan with her mother father and sister. The books starts out with Janie's sister Hannah disa...more
This is the story of a South Korean family who flees to America amidst the Japanese occupation. It's not a mystery to find a missing sister as the Goodreads description may imply. Instead, it's more an internal search, possibly to get past the stories we tell ourselves, dealing with difficult things such as culture shock/cultural bias, estrangement and serious health conditions. There's a lot of reminiscent flashbacks and cultural stories to help fill out who the characters are.
This is beautiful...more
This is beautiful...more
the reviews & jacket copy for this book were very misleading. check them out--they say thatjanie's sister hannah mysteriously "goes missing" & in the process of searching for her, janie stumbles across a "family secret" about how every generation of her family "loses a daughter". i was definitely anticipating more of a mystery--about the lost daughters, about hannah's disappearance...about anything.
instead, this is a book about two adult daughters & a wife standing vigil while the pa...more
instead, this is a book about two adult daughters & a wife standing vigil while the pa...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Forgotten Country, is a novel that holds many stories. It is the story of two sisters who struggle to define themselves in relationship to each other, their family, and the cultures they’ve inherited and have grown up in. It’s the story of a family straddling two countries, languages, cultures, histories—of how they navigate what to hold on to, what to reach for, and what to let go. It is the story of two countries—America and Korea—with their separate and linked histories of violence, separatio...more
Janie takes her role as eldest daughter seriously in “Forgotten Country,” Catherine Chung’s debut novel about a family that comes to the United States, out-running potential political persecution in their home country, Korea.
Hannah, her younger sister, has a bit more moxie. When the family’s traditions start to weigh her down, she runs away to California without leaving a forwarding address. Janie’s resentment toward her grows when their father is diagnosed with cancer and eventually decides to...more
Hannah, her younger sister, has a bit more moxie. When the family’s traditions start to weigh her down, she runs away to California without leaving a forwarding address. Janie’s resentment toward her grows when their father is diagnosed with cancer and eventually decides to...more
Mar 21, 2012
Kathleen Hagen
added it
Forgotten Country, by Catherine Chung, Narrated by Emily Woo Zeller, Produced by Audiogo, downloaded from audible.com.
Jamie, the protagonist of this story, is Korean, grows up in a Korean family who leave Korea suddenly when she is about twelve and move to the U.s. Their Korean names are dropped for American names. Hence she becomes Jamie, her younger sister becomes Hannah. Jamie is the older daughter who feelsthe pressure to protect her parents and her sister. Hannah on the other hand, doesn’t...more
Jamie, the protagonist of this story, is Korean, grows up in a Korean family who leave Korea suddenly when she is about twelve and move to the U.s. Their Korean names are dropped for American names. Hence she becomes Jamie, her younger sister becomes Hannah. Jamie is the older daughter who feelsthe pressure to protect her parents and her sister. Hannah on the other hand, doesn’t...more
Mar 20, 2012
Thorn MotherIssues
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Shelves:
read-2012,
adoption-reading-challenge
Just a gorgeously written book with organic twists and turns, deep characters all over the place. Janie immigrated to the US from Korea as a child, and now she's working on her PhD and her parents return to Korea when her father is stricken with a health crisis, while her younger sister has run away and wants nothing to do with the family. Janie's grandmother had told her that each generation of her family loses a girl, and much of the book has to do with the governing stories people tell themse...more
I received an ARC of this book as a participant in BOOK CLUB, a joint venture between Linus' Blanket and Devourer of Books.
Riverhead books describes Forgotten Country: “Weaving Korean folklore and history within a modern narrative of immigration and identity, Catherine Chung delivers a fierce exploration of the inevitability of loss and the conflict between loyalty and freedom. Forgotten Country marks the debut of a graceful, astonishing new voice in fiction, one with a quiet ferocity that will...more
An engrossing read, Forgotten Country addresses a wide range of complex topics while remaining a family drama first and foremost. Catherine Chung weaves in these larger historical events. It seems that each of the three generations undergo major upheaval and loss whether from Japanese invaders, political factions within Korea, an authoritarian regime or from the North Korea-South Korea conflict. Chung weaves the history of the country in with the history of their family so we slowly learn how th...more
Family. The intricacies of family relationships. Our families can define us, our families can destroy us, our families provide us with the roots with which to ground us, and our families love us. But for all the complexities behind family relationships, for all the cruelty and anger we harbor against some of them, there are ties that continue to bind and support us in times of need.
Hannah is missing and her parents expect her older sister, Janie, to find her. Nobody knows where she has gone or...more
Hannah is missing and her parents expect her older sister, Janie, to find her. Nobody knows where she has gone or...more
Having read the blurb and back cover, I expected this book to be about Janie's search for her sister, Hannah, and the unraveling of the curse that causes their family to "lose a sister in every generation since the Japanese occupation" of Korea. However, the book was much more about the family relationships and the father's cancer diagnosis and gradual decline. This is unfortunately the second book I have read this week about which the advance information implied a mystery to solve that was not...more
I love this book although it was quite depressing. I could relate to janie bc im a daddy girl and has done my best to please him but hannah reminds me of my sister who left home to find herself and grew from it. The auntie i dislike bc she reminds me of people who does something for someone only to throw it in their face inorder to get loyalty from that person. This book reminds me that life is a special gift and that we must waste no time crying and fighting over issues that can be resolved wit...more
This is a touching family story of separation (both from country and family) and of connection. Janie is the Korean/American daughter who always tries to do the right thing and who tortures herself for mistakes made. Her younger sister Hannah leaves the family without notice. The family is reunited and back in their homeland of Korea to await the father's death. We are gently led back in time to know the family's history in Korea and of their move to Michigan.
I enjoyed this book and getting to...more
I enjoyed this book and getting to...more
This is a neat little story, and I mean "neat" in the sense of orderly, not nifty. That's not to say I didn't enjoy the read; I rather did, actually. Chung's skipping about between Janie's past and present, as well as the insertion of stories of the siblings in her family's past, worked for me. I'd be interested in going back and tracking the storylines, if I had time. This was the first time in a year or so I chose an "adult" non-fiction, but I see no reason this couldn't be recommended to the...more
At the outset, this book seems to be about a fairly ordinary Korean-American family. Although the younger sister has left town without telling her family where she's gone, her actions seem like an understandable act of rebellion (as opposed to the mystery the jacket-blurb would have you believe). In point of fact, she is relatively easily found and returned to the family fold, although the real reasons she left are frustratingly left un-fleshed out.
Soon after we meet this family, however, it see...more
Soon after we meet this family, however, it see...more
It was decent. It's like an Amy Tan novel meets The Weird Sisters. It reminded me a lot of The Weird Sisters. And by saying it was "like an Amy Tan" novel, I mean it wasn't like an Amy Tan novel but it felt like that's what the author was really aiming for. The ending was totally flat, I turned the page thinking there was more because it was like it just literally ended out of nowhere. Poof! It's over. I don't regret reading it, but it could have been better. The characters weren't likable, not...more
Not what I expected, but a good read. Most of "Forgotten Country's" descriptions include these details: young, Korean-American woman has to track down her sister, after said sister (who has always been somewhat more aloof than other members of the family) takes off and will not visit or speak with her parents or sister. Although this is true, I kind of felt like the bigger story was more about this young woman and her relationship with her parents. Like many young adults, Janie (her American nam...more
There were aspects of the book I did enjoy and others I didn't, but for the most part, it was a well written and enjoyable read.
The characters were okay, they weren't likable, but they were unlikeable either. I think that if I had been able to connect to the characters a little better, the story would have had a different impact on me. Janie was a character who was difficult to like and because the story revolves through her perspective, it definitely influenced how I felt about the book. Her c...more
The characters were okay, they weren't likable, but they were unlikeable either. I think that if I had been able to connect to the characters a little better, the story would have had a different impact on me. Janie was a character who was difficult to like and because the story revolves through her perspective, it definitely influenced how I felt about the book. Her c...more
This book was at times harrowing in its unflinching look at Korean family relationships and how they were affected by history. It's almost too much for a single novel to contain every traumatic historical event for the past 75 years--from Japanese atrocities to repatriation of Korean-Americans, but the limited space of a single book forces Chung to keep returning the focus to nuclear family relationships, especially the troubled relationship between the two sisters. This is all well-covered terr...more
Forgotten Country is a very emotionally moving novel full of heartbreak, betrayal, forgiveness, reunion, and death that spans many generations and two countries - America and Korea.
At the heart of this novel are two sisters born in Korea and raised in America by immigrant parents. Younger sister, Hannah, mysteriously leaves, and Janie has the burden and responsibility placed on her by her family to find her and bring her home. The girl's father has become ill, and the urgency to bring Hannah ho...more
At the heart of this novel are two sisters born in Korea and raised in America by immigrant parents. Younger sister, Hannah, mysteriously leaves, and Janie has the burden and responsibility placed on her by her family to find her and bring her home. The girl's father has become ill, and the urgency to bring Hannah ho...more
(3.5 stars)
Forgotten Country is the story of generations' worth of family tragedies, from the death and destruction of the Korean War through modern-day struggles with loss and grief. Chung's prose will draw you into the tumultuous circle of the protagonist's close-knit family and the series of misfortunes that makes up their past and present. The relationships are beautifully rendered, especially between main character Janie and her father. Janie's struggle to learn that living your life to ple...more
Forgotten Country is the story of generations' worth of family tragedies, from the death and destruction of the Korean War through modern-day struggles with loss and grief. Chung's prose will draw you into the tumultuous circle of the protagonist's close-knit family and the series of misfortunes that makes up their past and present. The relationships are beautifully rendered, especially between main character Janie and her father. Janie's struggle to learn that living your life to ple...more
This book was amazing. It really opens your eyes to another culture and how someone moving to the United States from another country can be treated differently. The love of family or being a member of a close group can make you stronger or pull you apart when you are in a difficult situation.
The main character Janie is trying to get her doctorate in math. She was born in Korea and was transplanted to Michigan with her mother father and sister. The books starts out with Janie's sister Hannah dis...more
The main character Janie is trying to get her doctorate in math. She was born in Korea and was transplanted to Michigan with her mother father and sister. The books starts out with Janie's sister Hannah dis...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NYC Cornellians B...: March Book | 4 | 20 | Mar 17, 2013 12:05pm |
Catherine Chung lives in New York, where she is working on a new novel and a collection of essays. She can often be found eating ice cream, petting other people's dogs, or wandering around with her nose in a book.
More about Catherine Chung...
Share This Book
5 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“Each life contains as much meaning as all of history.”
—
6 people liked it
“My father told his acquaintances about that for years, even though both Hannah and I had given up on wormholes and the Child Genius series very soon afterward. That must have made my father sad, as it had made him sad when we stopped being excited about family vacations, when we stopped being open about our interests, and left home and pursued lives of our own. It was just regular growing up, of course, the kind everyone does, but it still made him sad, I know, like the memory I have of the time he dropped me off at the train station when I was going back to Chicago. I could see him through the window of the train, but he couldn't see me through the tinted glass. From up in the train, he looked so small. If he'd seen me, he would have smiled and waved, but he didn't know I could see him, and the sadness on his face was exposed to me then. He looked lost. He stood there on the platform a long time, even after my train started pulling away, still trying to catch a glimpse of me waving back.”
—
3 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view all 4 comments















