Without Miracles: Universal Selection Theory and the Second Darwinian Revolution

by Gary Cziko

"The fish's streamlined shape reveals functional knowledge ofthe physical properties of water.... The deadly effectiveness of the cobra's venom shows useful knowledge of the physiology of its prey.... Indeed, knowledge itself may be broadly conceived as the fit of some aspect of an organism to some aspect of its environment, whether it be the fit of the butterfly's long siphon of a mouth to theflowers from which it feeds or the fit of the astrophysicist's theories to the structure of the universe.... But how did such remarkable instances of fit arise? How did the animate world obtain its impressive knowledge of its surroundings? And how do organismscontinue to acquire knowledge and thereby increase their fit during their lifetimes?" In this sweeping account of the emergence of fit, Gary Cziko integrates numerous scientific disciplines within the perspective of a universal selection theory that attempts to account for all cases of fit involving living organisms, including those that might appear miraculous. Cziko's bold assertion is that all novel forms of adapted complexity—whether single-celled organisms or scientific theories—emerge from an evolutionary process involving cumulative blind variation and selection. Without Miracles describes many remarkable examples of the fit of various structures, behaviors, and products of living organisms to their environments in a broad synthesis of humankind's attempt to understand the emergence of complex, adapted entities. These explanations range from the providential accounts of the early philosophers and "natural theologians," through instructionist theories of the type proposed by Lamarck, to an ongoing "second Darwinian revolution" in which natural and artificial selection are being applied to many fields of science to both explain the emergence of naturally occurring adapted complexity and to facilitate the design of useful products ranging from microbes to computer programs. The evolution of explanations of fit from providential through instructionist to selectionist theories, Cziko argues, has occurred repeatedly in many different fields of knowledge along with a growing realization that the Darwinian mechanism of cumulative blind variation and selection is the only tenable nonmiraculous explanation for the emergence of any kind of functional complexity. Cziko applies this provocative selectionist thesis to a stunning range of domains including biology, immunology, neuroscience, ethology, psychology, anthropology, philosophy, education, linguistics, and computer science. The result is an up-to-date, clearly summarized collection of selectionist arguments that shows how our knowledge of the emergence of fit has itself evolved and continues to do so. A Bradford Book

Genres: Evolution, Science

399 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1995

About the author

Gary A. Cziko is Professor Emeritus at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

His two books published by MIT Press in 1995 and 2000 show how the process of language acquisition is itself (alongside other adapted complexity - whether single-celled organisms or scientific theories) a form of universal evolutionary process involving cumulative blind variation and selective retention.

He is the founder and major contributor to the ATALL Wikibook (http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/ATALL) including chapter on http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Autonomo...

Reviews

[Andrea · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book offers some very interesting applications of Darwin's theory of evolution. The chapter on education was most interesting and offered some very deep analysis of the ways that education can be seen through the lens of selection and how this might better facilitate learning. Very dense, but worth it.

[Philip Chaston · Rating 3 out of 5]

An interesting excursion into selectionism from the 1990s and a useful primer on the topic of blind variation/selective retention as a universal tool for human endeavour. According to Cziko, rather like the Great Chain of Being, Universal Selection Theory can act as a Great Method of Being for any step into the unknown or the acquisition of new knowledge. The verdict is still out.

[Anne-marie · Rating 5 out of 5]

blood is thicker than water