What do you think?
Rate this book
زنان در زندگی نیچه
German
150 pages, Paperback
First published May 2, 2000
14 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
March 20, 2023
When it comes to "women", Nietzsche is unfortunately on the list of bad guys. specifically, 'Are you going to women? I can say that it has become equivalent to the phrase "Don't forget your whip!" every time the subject is brought up...
However, I do not think that Nietzsche has an ideological dislike for feminism or for women as a gender. When we say nietzsche, we are talking about a personality in which only women remained in his life after his father lost at an early age. We see that all criticisms of Nietzsche, whether it is his mother, his sister or his greatest love, are purely subjective criticisms. There are also texts and words that deify women.
The book discusses Nietzsche with a subjective evaluation, through the family and the woman he fell in love with. He wanted to deal with the experienced rather than the idea. and scrutinized what the real Nietzsche thought of women. yes, we can say that Nietzsche has a very serious zig-zag graphic in this regard. but I personally think that in order to understand nietzsche, one must understand arthur schopenhauer. Because I must say that I saw a Schopenhauer effect in Nietzsche, as in many other subjects.
what did schopenhauer say in his metaphysics of love:
"A person can feel the deepest hatred for the person he loves with a passionate love."
"The source of all love, however lofty and lofty it may seem, is the sexual drive."
At this point, Schopenhauer, with the determination that love is a feeling consisting only of sexual attraction, put the woman phenomenon to a very controversial point and handled it as such. Nietzsche, on the other hand, approaches the phenomenon of sexuality a little differently and actually reveals that subtext in his perspective on women. Nietzsche questions how sexuality and this pleasure contribute to the development of human beings. If one goes beyond the social orientation, do people really need it? she questions and escapes from the balance of woman-sexuality to the balance of art-spirit every time.
Based on the fact that no intellectual conversations can be made with women, especially on the subject of art and spirit, nietzsche has brought the phenomenon of women to a controversial point, albeit different from schopenhauer.
Our author has brought this issue, which is a great deadlock in the theoretical sense, to a more understandable point by dealing with what Nietzsche did in practice. This book is one of the best books to read.
However, I do not think that Nietzsche has an ideological dislike for feminism or for women as a gender. When we say nietzsche, we are talking about a personality in which only women remained in his life after his father lost at an early age. We see that all criticisms of Nietzsche, whether it is his mother, his sister or his greatest love, are purely subjective criticisms. There are also texts and words that deify women.
The book discusses Nietzsche with a subjective evaluation, through the family and the woman he fell in love with. He wanted to deal with the experienced rather than the idea. and scrutinized what the real Nietzsche thought of women. yes, we can say that Nietzsche has a very serious zig-zag graphic in this regard. but I personally think that in order to understand nietzsche, one must understand arthur schopenhauer. Because I must say that I saw a Schopenhauer effect in Nietzsche, as in many other subjects.
what did schopenhauer say in his metaphysics of love:
"A person can feel the deepest hatred for the person he loves with a passionate love."
"The source of all love, however lofty and lofty it may seem, is the sexual drive."
At this point, Schopenhauer, with the determination that love is a feeling consisting only of sexual attraction, put the woman phenomenon to a very controversial point and handled it as such. Nietzsche, on the other hand, approaches the phenomenon of sexuality a little differently and actually reveals that subtext in his perspective on women. Nietzsche questions how sexuality and this pleasure contribute to the development of human beings. If one goes beyond the social orientation, do people really need it? she questions and escapes from the balance of woman-sexuality to the balance of art-spirit every time.
Based on the fact that no intellectual conversations can be made with women, especially on the subject of art and spirit, nietzsche has brought the phenomenon of women to a controversial point, albeit different from schopenhauer.
Our author has brought this issue, which is a great deadlock in the theoretical sense, to a more understandable point by dealing with what Nietzsche did in practice. This book is one of the best books to read.
June 3, 2020
... „Gieb mir, Weib, deine kleine Wahrheit!" sagte ich. Und also sprach das alte Weiblein:
„Du gehst zu Frauen? Vergiss die Peitsche nicht!" — Also sprach Zarathustra
Oft wird Nietzsche auf dieses Zitat reduziert im Bezug auf Frauen und dabei legte er diese Sätze in den Mund des alten Weiblein. Mario Leis versucht mit dem Bick auf Frauen um Nietzsche diese einseitige Sicht auf ihn zu beleuchten und ich finde es ist ihm gelungen in mir eine umfassendere, differenziertere Meinung zu Nietzsche zu erzeugen.
„Du gehst zu Frauen? Vergiss die Peitsche nicht!" — Also sprach Zarathustra
Oft wird Nietzsche auf dieses Zitat reduziert im Bezug auf Frauen und dabei legte er diese Sätze in den Mund des alten Weiblein. Mario Leis versucht mit dem Bick auf Frauen um Nietzsche diese einseitige Sicht auf ihn zu beleuchten und ich finde es ist ihm gelungen in mir eine umfassendere, differenziertere Meinung zu Nietzsche zu erzeugen.
November 3, 2016
An interesting take regarding the influence of women on Nietzche. A nice read.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews