A study in the methods of Dickens. Includes chapters on The Text of Edwin Drood, External Testimonies, Notes for the Novel, The Illustration on the Wrapper, Was Edwin Drood Murdered? Who Was Datchery? Other Theories, How Was ""Edwin Drood"" to End? A valuable bibliography is included in the book. This title is cited and recommended by Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature.
Sir William Robertson Nicoll was a Scottish Free Church minister, writer, journalist and editor. He was editor of the British Weekly and literary adviser to the evangelical English publishing house Hodder & Stoughton.
William Donaldson has described him as 'the Godfather of the Kailyard'.
About twice as long as it needed to be, given the author's tendency to tell us what someone had said, and then quote what they said in full. Still, some interesting arguments about the characters and the possible outcomes of Dickens' unfinished novel.