Closer to 3.5 but couldn't justify rounding it up.
This book continues the story of Cassandra, a widow in the process of adopting the child of the unwed teenager she has mentored. We also follow the rocky road of romance once again as she works out her feelings for Daniel, the gorgeous but womanizing hunk she's falling in love with. Like it's predecessor, "Mourning Becomes Cassandra", the writing holds a realism seldom found in Christian novels, while keeping the message a sound one. The characters are human not perfect, not cardboard cut-outs, not black and white but all the shades of grey found in real life. That is what makes this book so endearing.
I especially loved the fact that Ms. Dudley tackled the touchy topic of what it would really be like to fall for a cover-model-drop-dead-handsome man who has women falling all over him everywhere he goes. Seldom do you see stories deal with the insecurities and problems that would develop, especially if the man has quite a reputation for indulging in all the benefits and has no qualms about it - publicly and otherwise. The reader has the opportunity to question, "What would I do if I found myself falling for a man whom I have caught humping more beautiful woman than I knew existed" and "How would I handle it if he professed his love for me but every time I see him, another woman is fawning over him." Hard questions, no easy answers and most assuredly not the flowery gloss-over most romances use.
The problem with the book lies in the way Cass doesn't handle it. These two are the reason we are reading the book! They are the couple to root for, to get that happy ending. Although they do get it, through the majority of the book we see nothing but Cass being really nasty to Daniel. She insists on seeing only the worst in him and rather than being honest and open when she has doubts, she repeatedly jumps to conclusions, judging him while refusing to tell him the reasons for her behavior. That is SO far from biblical teachings (Doesn't it say in Matt 18:15, that if we find offense, we should go directly to the person and clear it up?) As the misunderstandings mount, one wants to slap Cass upside the head or chuck the book at the wall (yes, my wall gets a lot of abuse.) At least TRY to practice what you preach!! By the end of the book, poor Daniel was such a confused mess over Cass's mixed messages, he didn't know up from down. With those misunderstandings taking up so much space, the reader never gets to see the relationship develop in any good way. Which brings us to a very confusing HEA. I absolutely loved this couple, the potential was so great and the dynamics were so original and interesting that when it fell, it hurt worse than if it had just wallowed in mediocrity.