THE PHANTOM CHRONICLES is noted as being “17 Original Tales of Action, Adventure & Intrigue.” And as is true with most short story collections, the contents are “hit or miss.” Indeed, out of the 17 stories, I found three that I very much enjoyed and one that I thought could have been better, but it was fun to read. However, that doesn’t mean that the others are poorly written.
“The Phantom,” as a syndicated comic strip, changed markedly over the years. The character who fascinated me as a younger Reader was dark, mysterious and quite enigmatic. He didn’t kill people, but he meted out his own brand of justice. If you were fortunate enough to do something that merited The Phantom’s thanks, you may receive a “good mark” pendant that would bring him to your aid in the future. If you were a miscreant, you might receive a jaw-swelling blow that left a “skull mark,” identifying you as an evil-doer.
Through the years, I lost interest in reading “The Phantom” because the stories became so “family friendly.” The Phantom was less mysterious, smiled often, became a family man, and was prone to levity. In many ways, it was similar to Batman’s “detour” in the 1960’s.
So, four of the stories contained in this book were about the version of The Phantom that I really liked to read about. That is less than a quarter of the tales. The remainder ranged from “wild meanderings” to melodramatic excursions or family friendly “cool guy” fan-based fiction. The contributors are all published writers, so I imagine that your enjoyment will depend on The Phantom “type” you appreciate the most. I wanted a harder edge, and there wasn’t a lot of that.
On the plus side, I think there were only a couple of stories that I actively disliked, making THE PHANTOM CHRONICLES a pleasant enough diversion.