3.5 stars.
I enjoyed the mixture of a medievalesque setting, the magic of the Lumenators and "magic" of alchemical resources, and the dragons and their ability to bond to humans. What I didn't like were the graphic descriptions of violence, crude humor/language at times, and semi-flowery writing (mostly odd word choices that felt like a dictionary synonym pick).
Our two main characters, Kullen and Natisse, are on opposing sides in this kingdom. Kullen is the Emperor's secret assassin, and Natisse is part of the underground rebellion force, the Crimson Fang. Kullen kills noblemen ("Magisters") that get out of line, on order of the Emperor, and Natisse and co. kill noblemen who have acted evilly. However, these two do seem to have similar goals and end up in the same place several times, so maybe the two sides are not as intrinsically opposite as they think they are. Maybe the real "bad guys" are just the noblemen who are greedy, cruel, and vicious. I am interested to see how K & N would reconcile their differences if (when?!) they finally have a conversation.
The plot floundered for much of this book, which is mostly where my 3.5 rating comes from (the other part comes from the excessive violence). The beginning starts with action, intending to engage the reader, but the direction of the plot quickly becomes inscrutable. It seems like everyone is just hopping around and killing noblemen...? My biggest qualm is that we don't get a clear idea of what the Crimson Fang is aiming to do. Are they just a vigilante service? Think Batman, just taking out any baddies that pop up? Or are they trying to change the makeup of the Empire, aka, take out the Emperor or all of his nobles? Unclear. Which takes away from my ability to root for the group, in a way.
Closer to the end, maybe 2/3rds through, the plot finally picks up and a mystery is presented. Action speeds up and has a purpose. (All vague to keep this spoiler-free.) I enjoyed that last 30% of the book the most, hands-down, and I am now itching to start the next book! I hope the abstract - or at least inarticulate - direction of the early parts of this book is a one-off thing, and that the rest of the series feels more driven.
While not my usual level of dark and violent, Black Talon managed to entice me to keep reading and had me invested by the end!
.
.
.
.
**content notes: graphic violence (describing where damage is done, what it does, and the gory results), gore, murder, death. Burns scars and unvoluntary flashbacks to being in fire (probably some PTSD elements here as well). Death of parents/loved ones (mostly in memories, sometimes just mentioned). Attempted sexual assault (to a minor character & stopped by one of the main characters). Crude language, sexual joking, innuendo.
**romance notes: none.