WRITING WITH A THESIS: A RHETORIC AND READER is based on the persuasive principle-the development and support of a thesis in order to persuade a reader, which is exactly the skill beginning writers in freshman composition just like you need to develop. The book dispenses clear and practical writing advice in a clear and practical way. Leavened with lots of good humor-in both its advice and in its examples of good professional writing-WRITING WITH A THESIS is renowned for being useful and enjoyable to read. Nineteen of the book's 50 professional essays are new to this edition and 3 of 10 student essays are also new, providing fresh voices, variety, and relevance. Almost all of the essays are short and easy to read so that class time can be devoted not to what the readings mean, but to what they mean for your writing. Students receive the most up-to-date information on MLA documentation with the enclosed tri-fold card providing NEW 2009 MLA Handbook formats.
I use this as a resource for my homeschooled kids when they are about 12/13 years old. In order to write a good essay, you have to have read good essays. This is an easy way to accomplish that. We don't use it as a primary writing curriculum, just a supplement, but I wouldn't hesitate to do so if I didn't have something else to use. It is meant to be a college text but is certainly accessible enough for the average high schooler.
The authors write that this book is a rather traditional approach to looking at modes of discourse in writing. I see nothing wrong with such an approach. With that in mind, I still can only give the book an average review.
First of all, there is not much substance. The authors spend about two or three pages touching on some very superficial basics for modes of discourse such as narration, argumentation, comparison/contrast and others. If the writers had given more analysis, more suggestions, and more details to this segment of each chapter, I would have rated the book with more stars.
What I did like, however, is that for each mode of discourse the authors provide several short examples. Each of them is no more than a page or two thus making it very easy to look at several examples in a short period of thime. This makes the book useful in a classroom.
In short,the book may be more useful in a high school composition course, or as a supplement in a community college or in a four-year college "English 100" course