If you want me to dislike a book call it "an essential guide." This sets me up to be critical because whenever I pick up one of these 'essential' books, I say sarcastically to whoever may be listening, "How did I ever manage until now?!?"
So I was predisposed to not like this book even though I normally enjoy Bruggemann. Plus the first couple chapters I felt were good, but just okay. I was ready to give this a middle of the road review.
Then I read the last chapter and loved it. Bruggemann talks about seven aspects of "play" in Israel's worship. By "play," Bruggemann has in mind a sort of dialectic tension. He describes the tensions at play in the way that Israel's worship:
- requires both obedience AND freedom
- emphasizes both holiness AND justice
- consists of both the liturgy of the state cult AND the everyday worship of family and clan
- holds in tension an emphasis on Torah AND the expectation of a Davidic monarch
- deals with the reality of God's presence AND his absence
- has a place for both praise AND lament
- is informed by corporate memory of God's saving action AND the hope of future redemption
These tensions are not simply descriptive of Ancient Isreal's worship but are instructive in Christian worship as well. I found this tremendously helpful and insightful about how the Bible informs current worship practices and what we should continue to value.
This is vintage Bruggemann and worth a read.