I read this novella for SFINCS3 and am leaving an honest review voluntarily
You ever feel like a book was written specifically for you? Like it has all the niche little elements that you thought nobody liked except for you? And you felt all alone in this world full of books because authors are constantly told "your books have to be about XYZ" but XYZ are things you personally never cared for? In fact, you wish MORE books would be about YOUR favorite bookish elements? This was that book for me.
Sunchaser consists of three sequential short stories—three episodic tales of a young woman's adventure around the world she lives in. Glorya is a Sunchaser, a person with the power to soothe winds and calm storms, and she is on a journey, earning her keep while putting her powers to good use.
The set-up reminds me of those classic anime I watched as a kid where the protagonist was on a journey and each episode was its own miniature tale of fantasy adventure, heroism, and flashy action. Visually, I was even picturing it as a Ghibli anime as I read. The world is beautiful and full of hope. While there is plenty to fear, both in the form of storms and pirates, the forces of good are ultimately more powerful. If this world has sexism, racism, queerphobia, or any other bigotry, it is not on display here and Glorya never showed any indication that she was worried about it. The potential is there: in the first story, she boards a sailing vessel full of sailors. I feared the worst, knowing that sailors in our reality have a stereotype for committing some of the most heinous deeds to women imaginable, but this thought never so much as entered Glorya's conscious. This is not a fault of the story, but an element of the culture Barlow wants the reader to enjoy: this is not a world full of lascivious men. The second story reinforced this by introducing us to a culture where people wear minimal clothing. Although Glorya is initially embarrassed to wear such attire, she quickly adjusts, even finding joy in sleeping nude. And once again, she never fears harassment because that sort of thing simply does not happen in this world. If you want to read a fun fantasy adventure, but you don't want to see the worst of humanity, this is a good place to go.
One of the elements emphasized to a great deal is the worldbuilding. Every time Glorya goes to a new place, she learns about the culture: their language, their customs, their manners. The books feels like a travelogue in how it explores these fantasy cultures. This is something I enjoy a *lot* as a fantasy worldbuilder and aficionado, and why I fell in love with this novella. Worldbuilding is one of those things that authors are told not to emphasize, and it drives me nuts. It's a breath of fresh air when I, a writer and reader who despises the commonly-held notions of what a book 'should' be, gets a chance to read a book that actually caters to *my* taste. I especially enjoyed the magic on display here. There's an element of science to it; in order for Glorya to calm a storm, she has to reach out with her senses, detect the flow of air currents, and strip winds from them bit by bit. If they're too strong for her, she can erect a protective barrier around them. Once again, this felt catered to me so strongly it was like the book was written for me. I've always felt a connection to wind-based magic and I was pleased to see her work it so deftly and with such care for the environment and agriculture.
This is a prequel novella to a larger series which, at the time of my writing of this review, has one book out. For the sake of the SFINCS contest, I can only judge this book on its own merit, not on my assumptions about what may come. As such, my one bit of criticism may be resolved in the novel series:
That being I wish we had gotten to know more about Glorya herself. Despite being our MC and us seeing everything through her perspective, we know very little about her background or her values as a person. She's very likeable; in fact, every character she meets seems to adore her, if not immediately then after she uses her Sunchaser abilities to save them. But I want to know more about what makes her tick, and I feel like some of the space in this novella dedicated to quiet worldbuilding moments could have been given to her, to flesh her out and give her some interiority.
Regardless, this was a fantastic novella and I'm eager to read the rest of the series, where perhaps my questions will be answered.