I cannot overemphasize how much we loved this book. Durrant writes these stories on a level that is just right for the target audience. The last baptism book we read was a slog to get through, and I don't think we finished it with any real insights or takeaways, unfortunately. This one not only was more fun to read - it's like a collection of tell-me-about-when-you-were-my-age-Grandpa stories. Most of them start out, "When I was seven years old..." This statement in the last chapter sums it up nicely. He talks about how he learned important gospel principles in Primary and from his parents, then says, "However, ...it was the things that I learned in real life - the things I have told you in this book - that were among the most important things that helped me be prepared to be baptized." While the previous book on baptism we read came with discussion questions after each chapter, this one didn't, yet naturally led to meaningful conversations after our reading. Even before we got the last chapter, we had expressed together how seeing the lessons in young George Durrant's life helped us recognize the lessons we were learning in our own life. The children I read this with are already 8, and were recently baptized. This was in a stack of books I had meant to get through months ago but with some life upheavals, we are just now getting to them. We talked about how even though these lessons are meant to help prepare a child for baptism, they are still stories that we can learn from after baptism as well, to help us to stay on the covenant path.
Another thing all of us enjoyed about this book was the humor. A favorite story was the one in which George brings home an ice cream bar he received in Primary. He wanted to give it to his mother as an apology for treating her poorly and to show her his love. By the time he got home, it had melted, and all that was left was a stick, a pocket full of goo, and melted ice cream that had run down his leg.
A reviewer that rated this book far lower than we did seemed to have missed the humor in one of the stories. When George talks about not liking comic books because the contents of superheroes and space aliens were "not true" as opposed to his "true stories" about the Lone Ranger, he is saying that tongue-in-cheek, poking fun at his 7-year-old self and his boyhood notions. We thought it was funny. I also didn't agree with her assessment that George lied to go play with another child. There is more to the story, so I hope readers don't shy away from the book because of that perception. I'm pretty sensitive to books portraying bad behavior as good, and didn't feel that this was the case at all.
Even though this book is aimed at children preparing for baptism, we are going to be keeping it on our shelves. My kids will enjoy revisiting these stories.