Reviewing this before I donate this book. It was funny when I read it as a tween but now, it's time to let go.
This was a rather entertaining read but lacked any real voice from the characters. I didn't actually like any of the characters but I could relate to their experiences at secondary school (bullies, peer pressure, mean friends, wanting to impress, unsatisfied parents, annoying teachers). The unique Australian setting gave me a fresh perspective on my bookshelf because I did not have many books set in that country.
The book is told over the course of essays of the students. There are a few references to their previous relationships and teachers from primary schools. The students each had their own distinct voices and personalities which you could tell from their writing styles. Thadeus is rigid and wordy. David Pierce is the average joe. Joan is sensible, quiet and observant. Kathryn Chambers is just plain mean and she always points out everyone else's shortcomings. Kirsty Dean is vapid, shallow and her writing reflects her one-track mind: boys, crushes, popularity. Peter Karlos is essentially the Charlie Brown of the group, constantly worrying and being bullied over his dorky personality while crushing hard on Bridget who doesn't give him the time of the day. We also get a few new characters like Melissa, a cool new girl who is hiding secrets of her own and a few rag tag students who break the rules.
Rachel Flynn provides a rather comprehensive and non-judgmental picture of secondary school students. We see the real troublemakers having a chance to tell their story alongside the regular joes and the nerds who won't dream of causing trouble. She juxtaposes the selfish and self-obsessed diatribes of Kirsty alongside the sensible words of Joan and the mean words of Kathryn Chambers. It was also clever how she wove in details from each essay into an event that would happen next, showing a chain reaction caused by the behaviour of the students. A prank phone call can lead to a lot of trouble for the boys!
Personally, I feel this book would be a good discussion among parents or teens or in a book group. I think there might be young readers realizing that their friends are Kirstys or Joans or Kathryns. There are also funny characters who point out the absurdity of secondary school with its new rules, cultures and teachers.
A missed opportunity would be the school bulletins and announcements interspersed between the diary entries. I thought they could have been funnier but they weren't. The cartoonish doodles made by the students are top notch though and lends an air of realism to the book, making me feel like I stumbled across their essays in real life.