I’ll start with the positives I felt reading this book. For one, I love fantasy-style books, even more so if the protagonist is a black woman, even more so if that protagonist lives an alternative lifestyle somehow. This book had all of that, so it kept me invested. As a Midwesterner, I loved reading about the locations and events (shout out to Youmacon!) that I recognized. And for the love of god, I’m so happy that the Spanish used in this book was correct. When it came to the main characters of this book, I felt they were characters I could root for, and be interested in.
So why only four stars? Well, it’s little things that added up.
While I enjoyed the meat of this book, so to speak, it felt almost like a beta version. There are a lot of instances of us being told and not shown, which at times gave it a bit of a monotone flow as I read through it: “This happened. Then this did. Then this did. Then this did.” There’s many events that I feel could’ve been greatly more impactful if only the author had not been so direct with stating what happened so plainly. I also felt that, at times, the order in which we were told things (like whenever a new character is introduced, we immediately get their backstory) could have been arranged differently. And I would be remiss to not mention that the formatting of this book, or at least my copy, was a mess. Sometimes it’s hard to tell who’s speaking because a paragraph isn’t started or ended at the correct time. This is actually what took me so long to finish this book. It’s not a long read at all. There’s also a bunch of spelling and grammar errors that would’ve probably been caught with one more editor sweep.
I did like this book a lot; I read the bulk of it within 4 days. But I can’t consider it a 5-star read, because part of me is just a little frustrated with what it could’ve been with the right editor.