This book follows our characters from the other books in the series as they move to a new Fletcher class destroyer being completed at Bath Iron Works, Maine, and sail her through the Panama Canal into the Pacific to join the operations against Japan. While in the history of World War II, the Battle of the Atlantic was certainly of great importance in facilitating an Allied victory in Europe, the war in the Pacific was more obviously a naval war and the point of view of a ship's crew is in a rhetorical sense at the very center of the Pacific campaign.
The author has created a sweeping narrative of the Pacific war, rich with detail, in which to involve his characters. This is both a strength and a weakness. The strength is that the tale hews closely to actual events and it's possible to learn the history from this book (something I've written about unfavorably before but here, I'd say it's safe). Reading this book is a lot easier and more entertaining than Morison's "Two-Ocean War." But, it's a weakness because as a novel, the reader seems to have lost the characters in a larger web of events that they are swept up in but have little influence over. Of course, it's possible the author is doing this on purpose and certainly, people involved in such huge events, covering thousands of miles of distance, will feel small and unimportant even to each other. Both officers and enlisted men develop romances through letters and phone calls while at sea and that's certainly how things had to happen in days with limited air travel and sea travel menaced by enemy submarines. But the story is dominated by the famous battles whose names should be familiar, like Guadalcanal, Tarawa, Leyte Gulf, Iwo Jima, and Okinawa. Given the point of view of the second USS Woodside, these events are told exactly as they happened (with one minor exception, I think the destroyers participating in the Battle of Surigao Strait suffered damage from Japanese gunfire during their torpedo attacks, while Woodside escapes unscathed).
This is not a book you can read at one sitting, the "plot" is too complex. But, that's also part of the approach of following the history so closely. Given that, it moves along briskly and keeps the reader engaged. Having a destroyer captain on the Japanese side also be a character, similar to the U-boat captain in the earlier books of the series, seems to work well although I was skeptical early on in the book.
So, I give this book 5 stars. It's a serious contender among World War II novels, and that's high praise for something written in recent years by, and for, people too young to remember the war. It has high standards to compete with. It doesn't have the depth of The Cruel Sea, but it's a much faster, easier read, and for people who weren't alive in those times (maybe they didn't even have fathers or uncles who served), it gives readers a good grounding in the war's events. The author's style is plain and matter of fact, very easy to follow.