Reading the Prophets as Christian Scripture: A Literary, Canonical, and Theological Introduction

by Eric J Tully

Southwestern Journal of Theology 2022 Book of the Year Award (Honorable Mention, Biblical Studies)

This survey textbook is grounded in the view that the prophetic books of the Old Testament should be read as Christian Scripture. Although it covers critical issues such as authorship, background, and history, its primary focus is on the message and theology of the prophetic books and the contribution they make to the Christian canon. Particular attention is given to literary issues, such as the structure of each prophetic book. Full-color illustrations, diagrams, and artwork bring the text to life. Additional resources for instructors and students are available through Textbook eSources.

Genres: Old Testament

432 pages, Hardcover

Published March 29, 2022

Reviews

[Lanie Walkup · Rating 5 out of 5]

Really great intro to the prophets that attends to historical, literary, and theological concerns. While the author does come from quite a conservative viewpoint (re: authorship and composition), he presents other views as well. I wouldn’t say that these contrasting view points are a huge part of the book but are only briefly introduced if someone wanted to go for further study.
Overall, this is one of the more readable textbooks that I’ve read during seminary, and I would recommend to both students and more academically inclined lay people, though others would benefit as well!

[Christian · Rating 5 out of 5]

Good book for what it is. Not a great book for a seminary class.

[Amanda · Rating 4 out of 5]

This textbook was enjoyable to read. A great intro to the prophets.

[Kirk Miller · Rating 4 out of 5]

A really good introduction to the prophets. I would recommend this for use as something like an undergrad textbook.

The title is a little deceptive. It's less about "as Christian scripture," and more just a general introduction to the prophets.

I should be interviewing the author soon on the Church Theology podcast. Stay tuned.

I received an advanced copy from the publisher.

[Noah · Rating 5 out of 5]

A solid introduction to understanding the Prophets from an evangelical perspective. I found it particularly helpful in grasping the big ideas of each prophet as well as situating them within their contexts. Dr. Tully has a knack for finding application to modern contexts, and that not only makes his work much more engaging but also much more meaningful.

[Adsum Ravenhill · Rating 5 out of 5]

Taken from *the Raven's Writing Desk* @atravenhill:

All the quotes below are from the book unless otherwise stated.

Profiting from the Prophets

“When we talk about inspiration, we don’t mean that the prophets were inspired in the way that a painter is inspired by a beautiful sunset or enters into some kind of highly creative state. In that case, the source of the inspiration is not always clear, and the artist does not always even know the meaning; it may be more of an emotion. But a true prophet undergoes a different kind of inspiration. He or she knows that the word is from God, and the meaning of the words is understandable (though perhaps the prophet does not know the full implications). In the case of the artist, inspiration means that the content comes from within; in the case of the prophet, it means that the content comes from God.”

It’s likely that at some point this year you’ll find yourself reading one or more of the prophetic books of the Bible. If that’s the case, I can highly recommend that you go and pick this book up to help you in that endeavour. It covers all of the prophetic books, meaning that if you go and pick this up on Logos that’s $2.63/£1.94 per prophetic book + eight brilliant chapters on everything from the Historical and Theological contexts of the prophetic literature to false prophets.

Disclaimer: I think it’s always a good idea to get a specific commentary on any book you’re looking to study in detail. That said, this book is a great idea if you’re wanting to get more out of the prophetic books of the bible, understand how they fit together with one another and with the overall narrative of the Bible.

With that said, here’s how I would recommend reading this book:

2 Books

My suggestion would be to treat this book as two separate books. I would read Parts 1&2 (Chapters 1-8) as if that was a whole book, perhaps a month or two before you start any prophetic literature in your bible reading plan. This will give you some time to process, chew on anything you struggled with within that literature, and then digest the wisdom. Especially if you’ve always struggled with the prophets or haven’t read them before, this is a great primer. Once you’ve read that, the first book, use Part 3 as a set of commentaries. Again, to my prior disclaimer, it would be worth getting a commentary or a few commentaries on a few of the books which would help to make sure you’re hearing a variety of voices on what you’re reading.

CCC

You can’t be surprised that I would bring this up, but I would still recommend making sure you’re doing this. The introductions to the books are a great way of making sure that you’re getting the context of the books, then after that point, read the bible before each section.

Here’s the best thing though, that’s how the book is structured!

You’re encouraged to read the word (Amos 1:2-2:16) and then it will give you historical, geographical, and theological information to help you understand that text better.

The only difference would be that points 2 & 3 are switched. Point 2 being comparison with other texts in the Bible. The three c’s in this book are, therefore:

Context

Consistency

Comparison

I would advise you to try and re-order that and look at comparing the texts at hand with others in the Bible yourself before heading back to this book. If that would be too much at this stage, the book will give you exercises like:

Compare Amos 5:21-24 with Isaiah 1:10-17. They sopund similar. How are they actually unique in their respective contexts?

Which will assist you in developing the skill of comparison.

Final Word?

My final word on this is that Reading the Prophets as Christian Scripture is not the final word, the Bible is. The author, I sincerely hope, would 100% agree with me here that his writing is fallible and therefore you shouldn’t simply be adopting his views as your own simply because it’s the only voice you’ve ever heard on these books of the Bible. This may be obvious to many of you, but for those of you who are younger Christians, an audience I think could thoroughly benefit from a book like this, this could be a serious temptation. I’ve already mentioned buying other commentaries on a few books, but I hold to what we say on the Consider the Ravens podcast, “discipleship should happen primarily in the context of the local church,” though I believe in conjunction with that that literature the principal way that discipleship has been bolstered throughout Church History, if you’re struggling, go to an Elder, leader, or trusted member of the body to help you work through your questions. Ultimately though, remember that the Bible has the final word and has ultimate authority.

With that said, I think this book (set for release on the 29th March 2022) is well worth picking up. I look forward to using it again in the future and referencing back to it over time.

Grace and Peace,

Adsum Try Ravenhill

Bonus

As a quick aside, for those of you who are nerdy like me, here’s a brilliant quote from the book:

“Consider this nerdy example: some people talk about the "Star Wars canon" and which movies and books really count for the real Star Wars story and universe. I could sit down and write a story about Luke Skywalker, but it would not be canon, and no one would be required to take it seriously. But perhaps you are a longtime fan and do not like one of the new Star Wars movies: too bad! If it is one of the official movies, it counts. It is canon, and the story is authoritatively part of the larger universe long, long ago whether we like it or not. Similarly, each of the prophetic books in our Bible is part of the biblical canon. That means that they are recognized as being official—the Word of God—and just as authoritative as Genesis or 1 Corinthians.”

[Conrade Yap · Rating 5 out of 5]

When we think of the prophets, we often think about the Old Testament and the constant refrain of powerful warnings and prophecies. Few people would think about the New Testament or the letters from the disciples of Jesus. While the Church in general professes both the Old and New Testament as the Word of God, there is a tendency for many to discard Old Testament Scriptures as ancient or irrelevant. Many scholars and theologians have tried to present the two testaments as wholly revealed Word of God authoritative and relevant for the Church today, albeit with varying levels of success. While the ancient texts apply directly to a time no longer existent, there are many principles and prophecies that are still relevant today. Author Eric Tully aims to help us "read" the ancient OT prophets as "Christian Scripture" and to equip our reading with contemporary application in mind. How do modern readers appreciate and understand the Old Testament prophets? How does God speak to us today from the prophets of old? How could the prophets speaking in an ancient context still be relevant for us today? Author-Professor Eric Tully is fully aware of the negative views of the Old Testament prophetical books. He even spells out some of the common perceptions among many readers who find the prophetical books too challenging for comfort. As a result, some believers do not even read the prophets at all, save for occasional references from books, talks, and sermons. Believing that if people understand the contexts better, they would then be able to read the prophets in a more positive light. Chapter 2 and 3 (Part One) address the theological and historical contexts respectively. With covenant as a key theological theme, Tully shows us the tight connection from the covenants of old to the New Covenant in Christ. Historically, he guides us through the various periods of Israelite existence and their geographical locations, pointing out major events we ought to know. Chapters 4 to 8 (Part Two) look at the role of the OT prophets, false prophets, their message, their strategies, and the way the prophetic books were canonized into our modern Bible. Finally, Part Three introduces us to every major and minor prophet in the Old Testament. Tully gives us the following framework:

- Orientation of the prophet
- Their timeline
- Prophetical Phase and Exploration
- Brief summaries of the book
- Key message(s)
- Implementation of the lessons learned
- "Christian Reading Questions"

My Thoughts
==============
This is a well-thought-out introductory reference book for Christians in general. Written to rekindle interest and excitement to study the prophets, it is hoped that believers will be able to read the prophets with fresh eyes of enthusiasm. Without such rekindling, it is unlikely to change the common misconception that the prophets are ancient, irrelevant, and literally too difficult to understand. This book offers a correction to any such attitude. Tully does several things well. First, he begins with an understanding of the reluctant reader of the Old Testament prophets. That approach would hook readers to give themselves another chance to actually read the prophets. By explaining the contexts right from the start, he offers the readers much-needed tools to use while going through ancient literature. By explaining the roles of the prophets, readers can reset their expectations not from a modernistic standpoint but from a theological point of view. This should enable readers to understand the contexts and to be sensitive to any timeless principles that might arise.

The second thing that makes this book worth reading is the introductory chapters to every prophetical book in the Bible. Readers will find the presentation of the material not only readable but engaging as well. He begins each book with a modern example, thought, or illustration to pique the interest of readers. He dissects the material not just with words but with many tools that we have grown familiar with. Tools such as tables, maps, visual pictures, bullet point structures, and colourful illustrations. He ends every chapter with questions to help us revisit or reflect on key themes and pointers.

Finally, this book should appeal to those of us who are already reading or studying the prophets. By giving us a new angle to look at the prophets, scholars, theologians, and teachers should add this book to their repertoire of teachings about the prophetical books to move believers from reluctant readers to eager students of the prophetical books.

I appreciate books that inspire and encourage people to read more of the Bible, especially the less popular books of the Bible.

Eric J. Tully (PhD, University of Wisconsin-Madison) is associate professor of Old Testament and Semitic languages and director of the PhD (Theological Studies) program at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School in Deerfield, Illinois. He is the author of The Translation and Translator of the Peshitta of Hosea and coauthor of Old Testament Textual Criticism.

Rating: 4.5 stars of 5.

conrade
This book has been provided courtesy of Baker Academic and NetGalley without requiring a positive review. All opinions offered above are mine unless otherwise stated or implied.

[Lauren Danforth · Rating 5 out of 5]

Really great introduction to the prophets! I found the charts and tables included very helpful in understanding the structure of each of the books. Loved the implementation sections as well to help me think through the relevance of the prophets to the people of God today. A great first textbook for seminary :)

[Eric · Rating 5 out of 5]

An excellent introduction to the prophets! I think the introductory chapters (first 150 pages or so) are worth the price of the book. Each of the respective chapters on each prophet are good as well. His illustrations, applications, and connections (to the NT), were really great as well. Despite being a text book, it was enjoyable to read through.

[Elizabeth ‘Andy’ Terrall · Rating 5 out of 5]

Probably the best organized and planned commentary I’ve read during seminary thus far. Tully is very helpful in explaining context, historical reception, and differences of interpretive thought over time. He gives each perspective a fair intro and doesn’t show extreme bias when discussing textual critics, atheistic scholars, etc. I found it very helpful.

[Dan Mays · Rating 5 out of 5]

Reading the Prophets as Christian Scripture was incredibly beneficial and encouraging.

The prophets can be tough to read and understand, especially knowing who is speaking, to whom, and when. Dr. Tully does a fantastic job of clarifying complex issues so that I could understand them better.

The extra charts, graphics, and side notes were incredibly helpful and greatly benefitted the format of the book. Dr. Tully's writing is clear, concise, and witty!

I used this book as I prepared to preach through Habakkuk and was encouraged because of it. I highly recommend it as an introduction to the prophets!