This was good. I like Pastor Strauch, he has a lot of really solid ideas and good information, but he seems to lack a lot of practical advice.
A lot of the book becomes him explaining an idea that is far too obvious to need explanation (i.e. pastors/elders should be responsible with church funds) at that rate . . . we need to look at our audience. Pastors/elders who are stealing from the church are not interested in the bible based, expository book that Strauch produces. Same with a pastor who is not expositing the Word. If they are not doing that already, this book isn't going to make them change their mind.
Then you also have the large chunks where Strauch is trying to convince you that the Bible says what the Bible is clearly saying. He goes and finds other times Paul repeated his message in the Epistles. There is nothing essentially wrong with cross-referencing, but when 2/3 of the chapter is your cross references to the point you are trying to make . . .
Then you have the sections where he stays with the metaphor too much. Pastors/Shepherds do indeed watch over the flock of God, they feed the flock, they guard the flock. But the only time he gives a literal definition of these metaphors is when he discusses feeding the flock and expository preaching. Beyond that . . . I am simply at a loss. I would love to get a big shepherd's staff and start smacking around false teachers, but I don't think that's what I'm called to do.
Pastor Strauch fails to explain what it is I am supposed to do when confronted with a false teacher. The church I was at hired a false teacher and the elders simply ignored him. Was I supposed to . . . question him? Challenge him? Hit him with a stick? Start a subgroup within the church where we talk bad about him behind his back, eventually leading to a church split and the denouncement of everyone who stayed?
I questioned him . . . and was ignored, his section on false teachers is exactly right. He talked for hours to say nothing, made the entire thing so complicated and as to mean nothing, and then when all else failed just lied to make his point.
Everyone else in the church just decided to ignore the problem and bad mouth the man behind his back.
Neither of those options seem like the healthy church thing to do. But this book . . . doesn't really tell an elder what to do about it. I think they should have fired him on the spot. But I don't know. Gee . . . I sure wish there was a book that could help with this problem instead of telling me for the 15th time that a good shepherd loves the flock.
Again, the information isn't wrong or bad, but it isn't super practical. When someone steps to the front of your church and teaches heterodox theology, what do you do?
When your church hires a pastor who then invites his gay friends to come join him at church . . . what do you do?
These were the situations I found myself . . . and I'm still not sure how to handle it.
A solid read, even if a little lacking in practical advice.