It's an anthology, so by necesity the quality of the works within are varied. However, on the whole it seemed to me an excellent contribution to transnational immigration/migration history. There were a few selections that were tepid or cumbersome (rural German-American article, for instance), and a couple that were fascinating studies but maintained serious analytical flaws (such as the Emma Lazarus essay conflating Zionism and Jewishness to the point that one would think they were inseparable), but, more often the selections were engaging and percussive. Must read if you're studying U.S. immigration and interested in transcending the "Ellis Island" narrative presented in highschool.