“No Longer I” contains a clear argument, a desire to read the Biblical text closely, and (most importantly) a compelling Gospel presentation. The author demonstrates some familiarity with the Greek text, though he does not get bogged down in exegetical minutia. He ably counters the common (mis)readings of Romans 7 and emphasizes the power found in Romans 6. I think that this is a good read, especially for lay-leaders and mature high school students.
That being said, there are at least two areas that could use improvement (but both have substantial implications). First, there is no secondary literature cited. While many readers are intimidated by 100 page bibliographies and dozens of footnotes, to eschew outside sources entirely does a disservice to readers who want to learn more. Furthermore, there were several places where Hotchkiss could have substantiated his argument by drawing on insights from some of this secondary literature. One such example is his discussion of flesh (sarx in Greek), which has some similarities to the famous work of Jimmy Dunn in “Theology of Paul the Apostle.” Even if Dunn is too academic for his audience, I also detected room for the influence of Dallas Willard, Robert Foster, and Scot McKnight.
Second—and related to the first—there are a few places where secondary literature could have *improved* his argument. Most glaringly is that his Gospel presentation—compelling as it is—comes across as too individualistic for my (or Paul’s) taste. Not that individuals are not saved, but Paul has more to say about the Church and the Communities that he is writing to (especially in Romans). Even an additional chapter on living out faith in community would have helped to address this oversight. Here the recent work of E. Randolph Richards or Jackson Wu would have served and remained largely accessible to the intended audience. I’d also commend the more technical work of Ben Witherington, Bruce Malina, and David DeSilva.
These concerns notwithstanding, I would gladly place this book in the hands of a small group (though I also wish the book had build in discussion questions!) or a lay-leader.
I received an advance review copy of this book for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.