On Saturday evening, February 25, 1950, a live, 90-minute variety program called Your Show of Shows premiered On NBC-TV and instantly won acclaim from the critics and enthusiasm from the public. An inspired, witty, and sophisticated mixture of comedy, satire, and song and dance, the program starred two gifted, inimitable performers named Sid Caeser and Imogene Coca. In 1977, author Ted Sennett paid full tribute to this legendary program in his book Your Show of Shows. Now the book returns in an expanded edition that demonstrates, more than ever, why the show remains one of television's most glowing achievements.
Yes, it's lovingly written, full of anecdotes, and there are lots of great pictures. But I did not get the sense of being there, of being in the thick of things. It was like sitting and listen to people two or more generations older than me talk about how great things were in the old days. Not that there's nothing to learn from stories about the old days, but... Another thing that bothers me is that this book was written in 1977. Bu this time, Saturday Night Live had been around for enough time that, for a show so obviously derived from YSOS, some critical comparisons could have been drawn. But there is no mention of SNL.
A lightweight look at one of the earliest and best comedy/variety shows on television. It does have extensive photos and dialog from the show. It does contain a lot of early writing by Carl Reiner and Mel Brooks. So what am I complaining about ? I wanted more. Perhaps a bibliography?
The history of the early television show, Your Show of Shows that starred Sid Caesar and Imogen Coca. An amazing breeding ground for comedy and television. Writers and actors included, Mel Brooks and Carl Reiner. If you want to see the first Saturday Night Live go find an old Your Show of Shows. Unfortunately, the book is more of a lighthearted and nostalgic look at the show, sort of an homage. Lots of pictures, lots of great dialogue from the shows, not a lot of meat otherwise, except in rosy colored history. Almost all the shows were destroyed (they were old kinescopes) and I think this book is out of print now, but the impact of this show on television and comedy in general was huge and the book at least tries to capture that.
I did like the book....lot's of photos. A little background on the producer/director Max Liebman who put everything together and a bit each on Imogene and Sid. Descriptions of all the shows and other talent on the show. But not nearly enough on the writers. I heard wonderful stories told by Carl Reiner and Mel Brooks.