I love reading many fiction genres, but high fantasy has always been my favorite. Anything that even resembles The Lord of the Rings, or The Chronicles of Narnia for younger audiences, is a sure bet for my fave list of books. I like the title The Quest, which, while overused, does spell fantasy and more than hints at an adventure, although the subtitle seems a bit flat. The cover is dynamite.
I might as well get what I didn’t like about this novel off my chest first. Rarely have I read a published book that screams for a good copyedit. There are far too many easily fixable grammatical and punctuation errors, which irritated me even while I was enjoying the story. Verb tense errors, sudden POV switches –grrr! With fantasy, an author can get away with a lot, but some of the plot's implausibilities really do stretch this license too far. So, this novel requires two edits—basic proofreading and in-depth content—for it to shake its indie feel and read like a professionally written and edited book, as it should, instead of the draft before the final draft. Simultaneously, fixing some of the visual font issues (at least in the e-book version) would also improve readability.
So, what did I like about the story? A lot. Adventure, suspense, imagery—all the elements that make a gripping fantasy novel are here. The author successfully creates creatures, scenes and happenings that are exclusive to her special fantasy realm. The prologue is a good start, creating a scene that begs for answers to the questions it raises. I found the first chapter’s characterizations a bit stilted and the storyline a little too predictable. But as soon as the four protagonists entered the forbidding forest, I was hooked. As is true of all great fantasy stories, the author cleverly fashions a fantastic world with its own unique peoples and creatures, rules, challenges, codes of conduct—all of which keep the unwitting main characters on edge, and the reader along with them, as it is impossible to know what to expect next. I enjoyed the way the author fairly regularly introduced twists and turns that I didn’t see coming. There is plenty of adventure and close calls in this book. The dialogue is fairly good but may not always be appropriate to the time and setting. I’m personally not big on long-winded descriptions, especially in children’s fiction, and felt the author included just enough but not too much of it. I appreciated that the language was “clean” for young readers. Some scenes weren’t intense enough, though, such a rescue that was so easy, it should have been done years earlier.
This story should appeal to both sexes. Although the main character, Eli, is male, two of his closest friends and members of the core four are female. The girls are cheated out of participating in the big rescue at the end, but they play key roles that make them indispensable assets to the quest throughout the adventure.
I think the target audience (middle-grade readers), who will not be as bothered by the typos as I was, will enjoy this book. And there are many enduring themes that are valuable for young people to be reintroduced to: the possible unintended effects of bullying, the pre-eminence of familial love, the importance of not jumping to conclusions, the risks and rewards of close friendship, the pain involved in destroying even an enemy, the fatal consequences of self-centeredness and jealousy, fighting for the good against unspeakable evil, the unimaginable heartache of being different and so on.
The ending is a bit anticlimactic. Obviously, a sequel is in the plans, because the situation is no better and possibly worse for the principal character, Eli, than it was when he launched his quest. Much is left unresolved. Readers who prefer a complete and satisfying story may not be pleased with the “to be continued” feel of the “finale.”
All in all, for me, this story is a gem in the rough. With some polishing, it really will shine. It has all of the key elements of fantastic fantasy fiction but definitely begs for more editing to be the best it can be.
Hopefully, the sequel will tie up those dangling loose ends. But I wouldn’t count on it. Fantasy series are often divided into threes. I was torn between four and five stars for this book, but I chose five because, with just a little more work, it should be a wonderful series for young readers who enjoy fantasy.