First, a big thank you to the author,Tony Johnson for sending me a free e-book copy of A Story of Evil, A Hero's Downfall. This was sent in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own.
Companions' Crusade picked up right were A Hero's Downfall left off. The chapter count even continued counting from the last chapter of A Hero's Downfall. I don't know if I had seen that done before, but I thought it was a great idea. It really helped me begin the story with the mindset of a continuation of the story.
All of the positive things I had to say about A Hero's Downfall continued here in Companions' Crusade. The story pacing again was spot on with each chapter flowing perfectly in the next leaving me wanting to immediately read the following chapter. The story kept me guessing from beginning to end. There were some key plot twists I honestly didn't see coming. Specifically the revelation Steve receives with the final vision totally caught me off guard. I believed just as much as he did in the knowledge of Cyrus and Emma and their son.
The characters, for the most part, stayed very true to who it seemed they were from book 1. Steve had some very understandable moments of doubt. An argument between Grizz and Steve where Grizz pointed out some of Steve's potential shortfalls was great as a reader. It was one of those moments where you know your friend is saying the things that hurt you the most because they know that is where you are most insecure. That kind of argument where both parties are saying things that are hurtful, but don't really mean. I was happy to Steve really consider those words and determine how he was going to let them affect him.
Kari is the one character that seemed to take a step back for me. I had her marked as the balance to the trio before. She was always the most level headed. Her tantrum (maybe not the best word, but I'm not sure what else to call it) after not getting to spend the time with Steve she had anticipated seemed wildly out of character. I get that these characters are all young and young romance has a tendency to play with one's emotions. So, a small tantrum may have been something I could overlook, but when she carried it over into the next day, it just didn't feel like the Kari I had come to know at that point.
Ty is Ty. That feels like an inadequate depiction, but it's true. His initial meeting with Shana was one of my favorite scenes in the whole book. It was such a perfect time for him to blow of some steam and just cut loose. Their duty of notifying Almiria leadership of the impending attack was complete. It was time to get some rest and it was a good time in the flow of the story for a bit of comic relief. It was made all the better when he brought up Shana's dart throwing ability when she was looking for a weapon of her own.
Grizz is a character that still has a lot of showing to do. He came into A Hero's Downfall only in the second half and from his introduction we knew his life was going to change, but that didn't occur until the end of the book. So, we got to see the fallout of that. Given that the timeline of the book was only a couple weeks, it was totally fitting that Grizz was still struggling with his despair and escapism for the whole of the book. I think this was very well written. He's that guy you can't help but want to shake and yell at, telling him that the bottle will not help. But at the same time you know, as do his companions, that won't help. He started to come around near the end of the story only to find out things weren't as bad as he thought they were. So, I'm excited to see what comes of Grizz in book 3. And what this means for how he interacts with the party going forward.
Our newest party member Shana was an integral part of how things went down in Almiria. She is definitely a leader in her own right. But aside from a "go getter" attitude, and willingness to be on the front lines with her friends - despite significant inexperience - I don't think we really got to know her as much as the other characters. I'm interested to see her grow and progress in the next story.
We also found out so much more about Malorek in this book. And man, I hate that guy. I know I'm supposed to hate him, but he is one of those villains that I just feel zero empathy for. I get psychopath and sociopath mixed up, but I'm pretty sure he is a clear sociopath. To watch him manipulate the princess and then turn on her the moment they get married made my stomach hurt. Even those these are visions of the past and we already know, for the most part, how things go down, I was hoping his friends would bring him to justice with each line I read.
I still struggled a bit with the overall writing style, and again specifically with inner monologues. I could definitely tell the writing had come a long way from the first book, but I would say that it still isn't quite there. There were definitely points where a thought bubble was exactly what I needed for that insert of knowledge I didn't have previously, but the majority of them felt wholly unneeded. And there are still a few word choices and things that don't flow quite as well as they could. That is why I didn't give this book, that I really enjoyed, a full five star rating.
I am really looking forward to the conclusion of this trilogy. I hope I don't have to wait long as I know it hasn't been completed yet. But the reveal of the whole prophecy right at the end of the story was a killer!