I discovered Alex Gross' cabinet card paintings while traveling. I've always sought out bookshops while traveling and, in recent years, have begun trying to build them into my trips visiting local or famous bookshops. I found this book at Hicklebee's near San Jose. I picked it up as a novelty flipped through it, put it down and kept browsing. Ever so often, though, I would circle back to it. After a few more circles around the store, I decided to get it. (I don't know how many times one can be drawn to book before fate takes over and the book demands to be yours - but I'm fairly certain there's a magic number out there.)
By the time I got it, and the time I finally sat down and went through each page intentionally, it ceased to be novelty. What I think makes these standout is that Alex Gross isn't merely painting over antique pictures. He, to borrow the title, transforms them while, at the same time, keeping the essence of the person being painted over. I think what keeps this from staying in that novelty lane is that the photos dictated the transformation. In all but one or two the person being transformed is truly recognizable under their new painted cosplay. Gross keeps the people there - especially the eyes.
Now there is also the question of if it is right to paint over such pictures. (This has been raised in reviews of an earlier Gross volume.) I don't entirely know. The steps Gross takes, as mentioned above, certainly alleviate most of my reservations. In the hands of a less sure artist, perhaps this would miss the mark entirely. It also helps that, particularly in the volume (I cannot speak for the other), the original photos live on next to their transformation.