Good short book, but the author's Calvinism sadly came through.
PROS
+ Great teaching on continual self-denial.
CONS
- Once-Saved-Always-Saved doctrine: "G-d does not disinherit any of His children." THEOS does indeed not disinherit any of His true children, but surely many who were once children, but shipwrecked their faith.
- Typical Calvinist teaching that a believer is impotent to do anything and that THEOS must do everything: "Dearly beloved Christians, say in your heart: "I never, by any effort, can take hold of G-d, or seize this for myself ; it is G-d must give it." Cherish this blessed impotence. It is He who brought us out, who Himself must bring us in. It is your greatest happiness to be impotent. Pray G-d by the Holy Spirit to reveal to you this true impotence, and that will open the way for your faith to say, "Lord, Thou must do it, or it will never be done." G-d will do it." This teaching is not biblical, because it denies Works of Faith and downplays Sanctification.
- Scriptural interpolations: "What was it that led Peter to deny Jesus? Christ had warned him; why did he not take warning? Self-confidence. He was so sure: "Lord, I love Thee, For three years I have followed Thee. Lord, I deny that it ever can be. I am ready to go to prison and to death."
- Problematic exegesis: "Remember that the whole world, with perhaps the exception of Mary and the women, was turned against Christ that day." This is obviously wrong, because we have a lot of examples in Scripture who held to CHRISTOS at any given point (e.g. the two travellers He met on the road; Joseph of Arimathea; most of His disciples ...)
- Questionable speech: "I deserve nothing but the cursed cross; I give myself over to it." Humility is one of the great marks of a crucified man."
- Endorsement of the highly problematic Martin Luther (Augustinian, extraordinarily devoted to the 'Blessed Virgin Mary, Antisemitism, execution of Anabaptists, rejection of biblical inerrancy, rejection of Hebrews, James, Jude and Revelation, Non-Sabbatarianism, rejection of free will).
- Endorsement of the problematic Keswick Convention.