Victim of Honor

by James E. Duffey

Victim of Honor is the story of Confederate officer John Yates Beall, a man of exceptional character and principle, who faces the ultimate challenge to his honor and integrity in the last months of the Civil War. Charged with spying and guerrilla warfare against the North for attempting to free Confederate prisoners in Ohio and New York, he is convicted and sentenced to death. Will he remain loyal to his cause or sell out his countrymen to save himself? Will President Lincoln grant clemency or bow to political pressure from within his administration? Or will John Yates Beall die on the gallows, a Victim of Honor?

271 pages, Paperback

First published January 15, 2007

Reviews

[Joseph · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was rewarding on a couple different levels. It was written by an author local enough to sign and dedicate my personal copy. The other reason is that it dealt with events that took place within my home state of Ohio. The story of John Yates Beall is a sad one. I believe, after reading this book, that Beall was wrongly convicted by a military commission when he should have been tried in a civil court. It is a matter of speculation whether he would have been convicted by a jury of his peers. Overall, a very good study well worth the time spent. A worthy effort.

[Sarah Bierle · Rating 2 out of 5]

An interesting history of the life, expeditions, and trial of John Y. Beall. Previously, I didn't have much interest in the Confederate agents in Canada, but now I'm intrigued.

The author seems to have done extensive research on Beall's life and actions. Well done!

It was a little frustrating that General "Stonewall" Jackson was alive and well in November 1863 (he died in May 1863) and Chancellorsville was implied to have been fought in spring 1864 (it was really spring 1863). But the research and facts on Beall seemed to be accurate, and, as previously mentioned the author did lots of searching and reading on his subject.

The story felt mostly like a history book - and that's no insult - I love history books! But there were times when I wanted more tension to really make me sit on the edge of my seat. The history was exciting, but I wanted to know Beall's "historical fictionized thoughts." Also, I wonder how much Beall really thought about his fiancée; certain dialogue and scenes indicate a deep love for her, but she does not occupy his thoughts or momentarily distract him throughout the story.

There was some mild profanity in the story, mostly when characters were understandably upset.

Overall, I was fascinated by the historical details, the miscarriage of justice, and the honorable character of Beall. I look forward to reading more about the Confederate secret operations in Canada and am glad this book introduced me to the subject.