What do you think?
Rate this book
Trappers of New York: A Biography of Nicholas Stoner and Nathaniel Foster
Book by Simms, Jeptha R.
308 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 1851
About the author
Jeptha Root Simms
42 booksJeptha Boot SIMMS (1807 - 1883) was a historian, who lived in New York. . During a period of seven years he traveled constantly with his horse and carriage through the central counties of New York, interviewing the early settlers and old persons, and recording any data of interest thus collected.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
February 24, 2021
This book, published in 1850, recounts early settlement of the southern Adirondacks, especially focusing on two hunter/trappers, Nick Stoner and Nat Foster, both of whom figure in the lore or the region. But it's not the best history of this, which seems odd as the author actually spoke with Nick Stoner before his death in the 1840s. Probably 30% of the book is spent describing the area itself, and when it comes to Stoner and Foster, there seems to be a lack of stories and anecdotes for men who became part of the region's folklore.
Stoner is the better covered of the two, and the picture painted is one of a boisterous, adventurous man who might have been a little too eager for a fight. He served in the Revolution as a teenager, and was locally known for several fights with Indians afterwards. One such fight included getting revenge on the British-allied Indian who killed his father during the Revolution. Though most of these fights were over Indian hunters and trappers robbing his traps, considered a huge crime at the time. In other instances Stoner hunted with and even hired Indians during his trips into the wilderness. Stoner also, despite his age, served in the War of 1812 at the Battle of Plattsburg. Depsite all this, the book really doesn't seem to have that many stories about the man's long career, which is a shame.
Nat Foster gets more of the short-shrift. Basically all that is covered of this local legend was his shooting of an Indian he was feuding with (who tried to kill him), and the subsequent trial. There are literally court transcripts included from this. The rest of the man's adventurous life is absent, leaving a man with a long and adventurous career defined by one act.
Beyond that, there's a chapter about the less-known Jock Wright, another regional trapper. Two interesting points I found was that many of the area described in this book are now underwater due to the creation of the Sacandaga Reservoir, and that the author, even in 1850, was extremely regretful of the treatment of American Indians, even going so far as to encourage the recording of Indian place names so they wouldn't e forgotten by the history books. But on the whole the history just falls short, and gives neither of it's subjects the examination they deserve.
Stoner is the better covered of the two, and the picture painted is one of a boisterous, adventurous man who might have been a little too eager for a fight. He served in the Revolution as a teenager, and was locally known for several fights with Indians afterwards. One such fight included getting revenge on the British-allied Indian who killed his father during the Revolution. Though most of these fights were over Indian hunters and trappers robbing his traps, considered a huge crime at the time. In other instances Stoner hunted with and even hired Indians during his trips into the wilderness. Stoner also, despite his age, served in the War of 1812 at the Battle of Plattsburg. Depsite all this, the book really doesn't seem to have that many stories about the man's long career, which is a shame.
Nat Foster gets more of the short-shrift. Basically all that is covered of this local legend was his shooting of an Indian he was feuding with (who tried to kill him), and the subsequent trial. There are literally court transcripts included from this. The rest of the man's adventurous life is absent, leaving a man with a long and adventurous career defined by one act.
Beyond that, there's a chapter about the less-known Jock Wright, another regional trapper. Two interesting points I found was that many of the area described in this book are now underwater due to the creation of the Sacandaga Reservoir, and that the author, even in 1850, was extremely regretful of the treatment of American Indians, even going so far as to encourage the recording of Indian place names so they wouldn't e forgotten by the history books. But on the whole the history just falls short, and gives neither of it's subjects the examination they deserve.
Displaying 1 of 1 review