This is an eyewitness account from a man who was a youth in Charles Town when the raid on Harper’s Ferry occurred, prepared almost 50 years later. Factual and historic errors limit its total value. Small details are frequently reported incorrectly — perhaps from lack of memory or a lack of the full story having surfaced publicly by 1906. Either way, it’s a good book to have in the collection, but it’s usefulness in painting an accurate picture of things as they actually occurred is rather limited.